忘記密碼
 立即註冊
查看: 1111|回覆: 10

HTPC 的數位失真(CKL 兄請看、、、)

  [複製鏈接]

30

主題

397

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
9
舊站發表文章數
424
發表於 2001-9-21 10:37:57 | 顯示全部樓層

HTPC 的數位失真(CKL 兄請看、、、)

各位 AV 同好大家好﹕

日前與 CKL 兄臺談及數位失真問題,今晨起床後靈感一來,想起當初抓音軌時做了一個實驗,不妨提出來與各位先賢分享,也聽聽您的高見。

首先把 CD-RW 和 CD-ROM 調到 Sample Offset 為零,再以著名的 EAC (Exact Audio Copy) 抓音軌程式將一首歌曲抓下來以 wav 格式存入硬碟裡,檔案大小約 50 MB,然後用 CDRWIN 透過外接 SCSI Ricoh MP7040S 燒錄在光碟上﹔完成後再以 EAC 把燒好的音軌也抓下來存入硬碟裡,然後用 File Compare 弁鄑潃鴝l檔和複製檔做比較。

結果是﹕可以做到一個 bit 也不差的程度!

從這個實驗來看,訊號以數位形式從 CD-ROM 讀取頭開始旅行,經主機板、硬碟後稍事休息,然後分身經主機板、SCSI 介面卡及外接線,進入 CD-R 後經雷射刻入刻盤裡休息﹔稍後這個分身又被抓入硬碟裡,與本尊共同送到 CPU 遂 bit 比較、、、Bingo! 滴水未漏。

因此個人淺見以為數位傳遞是可以輕易做到零失真的,君不見動輒數百 MB 的程式從地球此端傳至彼端,川流不息﹔伺服器鎮日運行,一刻不歇!

各位前輩請賜高見。竭誠以待、、、

Happy AV!

2

主題

24

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

初級會員

舊站積分
0
舊站發表文章數
29
 樓主| 發表於 2001-9-21 13:11:02 | 顯示全部樓層
Hi, I am not CKL, but I am interested in this.

I agree with you. But then?

Of course there is no error in digital domain in most cases. But what is the conclusion in HTPC? Can you give more details? Thanks!

30

主題

397

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
9
舊站發表文章數
424
發表於 2001-9-21 14:49:23 | 顯示全部樓層
PiG,

Please refer

http://www.myav.com.tw/topic.asp?ARCHIVE=&TOPIC_ID=9983

Thank you and wish you happy AV life.



21

主題

412

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

永久榮譽會員MYAV全體網兄致敬

舊站積分
4
舊站發表文章數
441
發表於 2001-9-21 17:30:34 | 顯示全部樓層
彭兄,

Thank you for your information. 這實驗性資料確定了數碼傳遞的重要性。I heard that some manufacturers will produce DVD player with digital out (DVI or i-link).  It is a good news for all digital monitor/projector.  It seems that DIGITAL will be the main format for all kinds of media.

Meridian uses the DVDROM driver for their CD player 588.  It is strange why CD player using DVDROM.  Meridian said it was more accurate for the DVDROM to read the data.  I think the internal DVDROM in HTPC suffering from vibration and interference.  I plan to build a external SCIS DVDROM driver in a separate case with individual power supply (including filter) and then connect it to the socket of SCIS control card in the computer.  The DVDROM driver should also be damped by suspension system.  Do you recommend any SCIS DVDROM?


Best Regards,

CKL

30

主題

397

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
9
舊站發表文章數
424
發表於 2001-9-22 11:45:02 | 顯示全部樓層
CKL,

Hitachi, Toshiba, Ricoh and Pioneer SCSI are good candidates.

The vibration and interference should NOT affect the video and audio outputs as my music CD burning experiment concluded. It is the s/pdif timing (synchronization) between the chip on the sound card and A/V receiver may generate audio distortion. Itis the most concerned problem area for now.

The CD-ROM reader in the experiment was Afreey 50x and its vibration and noise were tremandous. The audio bits traveled long distance without a problem. The other secret of digital fidelity lies in the Laser pickup of the drive. Pioneer has been very famous of it. Both my dv-535k and single CD Car Audio Pioneer DEH-2050 read CD-R and RW well.

Note that the CD burning experiment is more challenging than DVD and CD playback because the laser sensitive coating on the CD-R and manufacturing process have to be FLAWLESS to pass 50 MB with zero bit error. The software error correction scheme also helps.

Conclusion? Select a DVD-ROM best at pickup data from DVD as an internal drive and you are OK for video/audio sources. Secondly, select M-Audio Audiophile 2496 and you have up-to-date, most accurate s/pdif stream out of your HTPC.

Yet anther dollar two cents thought.

Cheers.


21

主題

412

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

永久榮譽會員MYAV全體網兄致敬

舊站積分
4
舊站發表文章數
441
發表於 2002-3-31 03:19:45 | 顯示全部樓層
彭兄,

I still don't give up the idea of placing the DVDROM outside the main case because of my experience regarding audio CD.  For CD player, the power supply and stable mechanism is very important.  I've raised the same question in AVS forum.  The responses are that this idea doesn't improve the picture quality if the data is transferred correctly.  One important point is that DVD data will be buffered and reclocked again so it is not the same as CD.  I remember that there was external audio DAC using buffering and reclocking in additional RAM to lower/remove jitter from the CD transport.

Ok now I accept that it's not worth to move the DVDROM out if it can read the data accurately.  Do you have any idea how to test the accuracy of DVDROM?  If I use your aforesaid method and there is error,  I can't ensure the error comes from the CD writer or DVD driver.

Best Regards,

CKL

30

主題

397

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
9
舊站發表文章數
424
發表於 2002-4-1 11:24:35 | 顯示全部樓層
Hi CKL,

Yes I read you post and quote from Cliff Watson:

" ”So these cards don't pass on the data bit for bit.”

Actually they do pass data bit for bit. However, the arrival time at the decoder may not always be at the same interval due to jitter. "

I'm using c-media 8738 chip sending s/pdif through a 75-ohm coxial cable to Denon 1801-N (water good imported from Japan. -N means made for Japan market and I do not know if the decoder/DAC any better or worse.) The setup works well I guess because my un-trained ears hear no hickup from DD/DTS soundtracks. Sound field/positioning is good but again, I am no audio fan.

My guess is that a software dvd player and a sound chip that do not mess the raw DD/DTS data and a de-jitter device before decoder shall give you state-of-art sound in s/pdif domain.

On the other hand, some AVS members claimed that s/pdif is not an error-free protocol, thus the best deal is using PowerDVD audio filter that decodes the DD/DTS into wav format in digital, and then using professional DSPs/DACs employed by sound card makers like M-Audio for 5.1/7.1 ANALOG outputs to your power amps for best sound. It remains a dream to me so far.

I am no fan and previous s/pdif had met my need in DVD audio for now.

As verifying a DVD-ROM read accuracy, I would assume it's a different story and the audio CD experiment remains its validity to CD-R only. The DVD-ROM density is 7 times higher and vob files are compressed video and audio and being multiplexed that has to be CRC corrected when retrieving (a huge difference than Audio CD). If you were able to watch films smoothly in video and audio, everything is right in your HTPC.

My 2-cent. Thanks for tolerating.

Best,

Daniel Peng

21

主題

412

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

永久榮譽會員MYAV全體網兄致敬

舊站積分
4
舊站發表文章數
441
發表於 2002-4-1 20:55:09 | 顯示全部樓層
彭兄,

Thank you for your reply.  I don't concern too much the sound quality from movies if the audio and vidoe are playing simultaneously.  Video quality is much important.  I agree that the digital out from sound card has the problem of jitter.  To solve this problem, the following methods can be tried:

(1) using a very high quality sound card with lowest jitter in digital out

(2) using a de-jitter device (if any) in between sound card and AV amp

(3) using a DAC with buffer to reclock the data (if any)

(4) using a very high quality sound card to output 5.1 analogue signal (the method you mentioned)

(5) using a sound card with clock link (if any) to the AV amp so the DAC know the original clock.

(6) using a DVD player with SDI (or other digital out format) so the audio signal is handled by the DVD player and video signal is handled by the HTPC.

Now,  I use the Creative audigy to output the analogue signal to a stereo amp driving B&W N805.   I'm satified the present sound quality in my  small bedroom.  I have no complaint at the noise level from the sound card when there is sound or not.  There is no urge for me to add 3.1 channels.  I'm not criticised the sound from the movie but picky regarding the stereo CD.

Anyway, external DVDROM installation should be my last step to improve the video quality

Best Regards,

CKL

P.S.  I remember you are using NEC projector as well (right?).  Please check if the attached CD including a program to change the gamma table.  If yes, you can input the new values to Natural 1 & 2.

30

主題

397

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
9
舊站發表文章數
424
發表於 2002-4-2 13:38:35 | 顯示全部樓層
Hi CKL,

I enjoy ZoomPlayer + Ravisent Video + PowerDVD Audio very much. For video camera sources, it's 4:3 anyway and Zooming function is not important. PowerDVD XP fills the need here.

Yes, I have NEC VT-540K and thanks for reminding the input gamma values idea. However my VT-540K packing list did not show any CD-ROM item at all.

This baby is quite accurate in R, G, B colors when Green Contrast Gamma brought down to 33% from factory default 50%. I have no instrument nor AVIS disc. Always add a few grains of salt when reading my 2-cent.

I am glad to hear that you are already happy with current setup. Isn't it time to sit back and enjoy the HT?

Daniel

49

主題

1163

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
1
舊站發表文章數
1206
發表於 2002-4-2 18:34:43 | 顯示全部樓層
"因此個人淺見以為數位傳遞是可以輕易做到零失真的,君不見動輒數百 MB 的程式從地球此端傳至彼端,川流不息﹔伺服器鎮日運行,一刻不歇! "
基本上電腦資料大多有error check ...
這是不能比的
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-23 01:24 , Processed in 0.056011 second(s), 40 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表