新手上路
五星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 3861
- 舊站發表文章數
- 3644
|
樓主 |
發表於 2010-9-13 17:50:09
|
顯示全部樓層
Re: Discrete op amp ?
原發表者是 mug
[B]
head-case有位cetoole兄說得似乎很有意思,只可惜我聽不太懂,辜先生翻譯時又有些口齒不清,缺漏之處請各位指正。
cetoole兄以North Star m192的第一代和第二代dac解碼晶片後端電路差別為例,其意見似認為,離散元件能比opamp ic好聲,但要出好聲不容易,且須視所搭配的零件線路而定。
The North Star m192 mk1 used a voltage out DAC, CS4396 IIRC. Discrete output stages for v-out DACs are very easy to design, as the output requires nothing more than a buffer and LPF, and there are plenty who even feel that that is redundant, and take the output straight off the DAC. You can make a great buffer with just a pair of JFETs, or a simple discrete opamp, or whatever floats your boat. Works great.
North Star m192 mk1使用的電壓輸出解碼晶片,CS4396 IIRC。其離散輸出級非常容易設計,作為輸出所需,只不過是一個緩衝和低通濾波器,用一對 JFETs便可搞出很棒的buffer,或弄個簡單的離散運算放大器,隨你,爽就好,都能出好聲。但很多人仍認為那是多餘的,便予以省略,並從 DAC解碼晶片直接輸出。[/COLOR]
The North Star m192 mk2 uses a current out DAC, PCM1792 IIRC. Discrete output stages for i-out dacs are much more difficult to properly design, though there are a few approaches you can take. Common base/source amplifiers are a good way to do this, though I am sure there are those who use simply a discrete opamp. Some also use a passive I/V and discrete gain stage follower, though this really isnt a good approach (IMO). It is much, much easier to just use opamps for the I/V conversion, and they work well enough for most.
North Star m192 MK2的使用電流輸出解碼晶片,PCM1792 IIRC。電流輸出解碼晶片的離散輸出級雖然有好幾種方案,但較難妥善設計。共基 /共源放大器是一個很好的辦法,然而我相信還是有很多人使用簡單的離散運算放大器。有的還使用一種被動的I / V和離散原件的增益級隨耦器(謎之音:這是啥碗糕),雖然這真的不可能一個好辦法。在我看來,只使用opamp ic來作I / V轉換會更、更容易(謎之音:作者好像在罵人),而且大都能出好聲。 [/COLOR]
With a discrete design, you get to choose everything. If you dont want to use NFB, and there are some good reasons not to here, you dont have to. Its more about choices I guess. You can also bias discrete parts much hotter than the transistors inside an IC opamp.
使用離散設計,你可以(或必須?)選擇元件。如果有一些很好的理由不用負回授的話,你可以不要,見仁見智啦。您也可以將離散器件加大偏壓,讓他比op ic中的電晶體更熱些。[/COLOR]
------------------------------
http://www.head-case.org/forums/ ... iscrete-op-amp.html [/B]
感謝mug兄的說明
被動的I / V指的是用電阻做I / V轉換
後面只需加上電壓放大級&緩衝級即可
work well enough for most
解釋成"大都能出好聲"似乎有些背離原意
"對多數人都夠用了"或許會貼切些 |
|