忘記密碼
 立即註冊
查看: 148|回覆: 2

170吋 另類 DLP 數位電影院欣賞 心得報告

  [複製鏈接]

262

主題

1034

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
66
舊站發表文章數
1298
發表於 2003-12-27 19:41:40 | 顯示全部樓層 |閱讀模式
首先,謝謝網友的參與,希望是個愉快的下午。[]

今天共有四個段落:

Part I: 2..35:1 480p/576p DVD HTPC/DVI --> 1280x720 H76+16x9 Lens (ALL digital)
依序播放了:
魔戒I --  電影預告篇
Notting Hill -- 片尾主題曲
Harry Potter II -- 小藍鬼片段
人魔 -- 魚市場槍戰
世界末日 -- Sling-shot the Moon

Part II: ATSC 720p HDTV 電影 DVHS --> 1280x720 H76 (1:1 mapping, no scaling)
The Rock
Charlie's Angel
Galdiator

Part III: BSD 1080i HDTV 電影 HDD -->1280x720 H76 (scaled)
Monster Inc.

Part IV: D-VHS iLink to Samsung DTV STB, DVI/HDCP --> H76 (ALL Digital)
重複 Part II 的電影,由於剛拿到STB機台,還沒能細調到滿意的畫質,僅供與 Part II 的類比色差輸出作比較用。

大家似乎對 Part II 及 III 沒有太多 comment,反而對 Part I 的組合能讓DVD畫質有所提升感到有意思! [|)] [|)]  

這次的網據主要就是讓網友瞧瞧,細心的搭配組合與調整,可以讓個人的家庭劇院增色不少。

心得報告?  當然不是我,而是各位有參與的網友吧! []
林宗毅

37

主題

1940

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Digital = Simplicity

舊站積分
30
舊站發表文章數
1976
發表於 2003-12-27 21:48:49 | 顯示全部樓層

Re: 170吋 另類 DLP 數位電影院欣賞 心得報告

原發表者是 林宗毅
[B]

Part I: 2..35:1 480p/576p DVD HTPC/DVI --> 1280x720 H76+16x9 Lens (ALL digital)
依序播放了:
魔戒I --  電影預告篇
Notting Hill -- 片尾主題曲
Harry Potter II -- 小藍鬼片段
人魔 -- 魚市場槍戰
世界末日 -- Sling-shot the Moon

大家似乎對 Part II 及 III 沒有太多 comment,反而對 Part I 的組合能讓DVD畫質有所提升感到有意思! [|)] [|)]  

這次的網據主要就是讓網友瞧瞧,細心的搭配組合與調整,可以讓個人的家庭劇院增色不少。

[/B]


First of all, thanks for the hospitality of Mr.Lin and GIN123.

And yes, most of the quests today are surprised with how a well edited/mastered traditional red-laser DVD can do after careful tuning, scaling and some extra help of an anamorphic lens. The picture can be so film-like. I have two points to share with my member fellows:

1. 856x480 chip for DVD watching is the MINIMUM spec:

We were told times to times (by Epson and Panasonic mainly) that best projector for DVD watching must use 856x480 chip for 480p @ 1:1 mapping. Believe me, it's a commercial propaganda for the Epson's 856x480 chip and Panasonic's AE100.

I had once read an article on AVSFORUM about the best chip for DVD watching, it stated the best chip must be of two (2) or three (3) times the pixels of the DVD's picture pixels. However, I had never really experienced this before today, and I didn't buy it, though theoretically it's most likely a truth. For 2.35:1 picture ratio, the basic picture pixels needed is 858x360, and the best picture pixels just happen to be 1712x720 (2x2) or 2568x1080 (3x3). With 2 times or 3 times of pixels, the scaling will be pretty much an easy job, and the details can be easily recovered by simple math. matrix calculation. And this is exactly what happen taday. None of us can say 720p HD content from D-VHS definitely overpowered the 480p DVD content, as long as the DVD is well edited/mastered like LOTR (C/F).

Though HD2 is not truely an 1712x720 chip, the most demanding condition "Vertical 720 pixels" is fullfiled; and with some help from the anamorphic lens, a nearly perfect picture was obtained today. It's a lost, if you did not attend today. I fully believe 1920x1080 (2568x1080) will be even better.

2. The DVD's editting/mastering/encoding are definitely CRUCIAL to the picture quality.

The C/F of LOTR must be at 9M bits rate for the best interest of NEW LINE CINEMA, and the NORTTING HILL must be at 6M bits rate. What the studios said "SUPERBITS", "EXTREME EDITION", "COLLECTOR'S EDITION", "DIRECTOR'S CUT",....., they are all what DVD's suposed to be made at the beginning with 9Mbits rate. GOD DAMED greedy film makers, %&*($**$.......

Best regards, Peter
BLACK @Level 16, WHITE @Level 235

37

主題

1940

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Digital = Simplicity

舊站積分
30
舊站發表文章數
1976
發表於 2003-12-28 15:58:47 | 顯示全部樓層

Re: 170吋 另類 DLP 數位電影院欣賞 心得報告

原發表者是 林宗毅
[B]

Part II: ATSC 720p HDTV 電影 DVHS --> 1280x720 H76 (1:1 mapping, no scaling)
The Rock
Charlie's Angel
Galdiator

[/B]



A)

The Rock:            16:9 screen ratio for HDTV
Charlie's Angle:   16:9 screen ratio for HDTV

My positive comments:
Resolution, Colour saturation, Black level, White peak.

My negative comments:
Too much sharpness comparing to detail (which maybe caused by MPEG2 decoding artifact through HDTV broadcasting), too much  DIGITAL feeling (it's funny, the D-VHS deck was cabling via YPbPr analogly);
S/N ratio is not as good as PART One sensitively (I don't mean the mosacic caused by poor signal reception);

B)

Galdiator:            2.35:1 screen ratio

It's the worst of the day's, poorer than most of Part One's DVD, except Nortting Hill (It could be a DVD5 old version); well, it's 720p format with actual 480p scan line. Maybe we should cable the signal like Part One, to scale away the black bars and then to wide the picture though anamorphic lens; just a thought.



After viewing the unbelieveable and exciting Part One, most of us will certainly expect to experience something thrilling for the reason of "HDTV 720p 1:1 mapping without scaling".

I don't exactly know where or what went wrong, were we over-expectting? or ATSC HDTV is not as good as we expectted (Thanks God, Taiwan did not choose ATSC)? What I know for sure is I prefer the Part One "High quality DVD scaling content" to Part Two "HDTV 720p 1:1 mapping. Am I blind?.

May somebody please correct what I commended above. I am surely not qualified as a professional.

Regards, Peter
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-20 08:03 , Processed in 0.909912 second(s), 28 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表