新手上路
MyAV第一人氣廠商
- 舊站積分
- 2902
- 舊站發表文章數
- 16910
|
發表於 2001-12-8 11:49:03
|
顯示全部樓層
以下轉貼宗毅版主的文章!!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
其實大家不要太執著於廠商的『數字戰』,廠商為了加強競爭力,分別用數字來拉大競爭者的差距,可是實際效果卻未必有如期數字所暗示。
早先Sony推出的DRC,播放DEMO片漂亮不已,可是一遇到film就錯誤百出。 Panasonic一度也以ADC的bit數來誇稱自己的影像有多少倍的增進,有的投影機也以用多少bit來做gamma校正做為特點強項,10bit真的比8bit好上4被嗎?I really doubt it. If fine-tuned properly and extensively, it could be better, but not 4 times better!
因此在progressive技術成熟的年代,廠商只好以"upconvert to 720p" or "upconvert to 1500i", no matter how touching the name may be "Digital Emotional ...", one has to see it to believe it.
此外,能在36吋、16x9的電視上顯示720p or 1500i的解析度,映像管必須是dot-pitch在0.635mm(32吋必須要0.565mm)以下,目前除了Sony可以辦到,Toshiba的HD管子,Panasonic新的映像管之外,大概也沒了吧。
Besides, any "upconvert" 技術端賴scaler的好壞,more does not necessarily mean better! If you look at many projector's upconverted image, you will know what I mean.
總而言之,還是老話一句:眼見為憑。
林宗毅
這次日本電子展中,Victor有展出其1500i scanning的映像管電視,旁邊瞻F一台傳統的HD電視,播放1080i訊號,個人覺得1500i反而讓影像變軟了,邊緣模糊了,雖然較smooth,可是犧牲了銳利度。我反而偏愛1080i scanning的電視。
因此寶座歸誰可能還有待商榷。 這可能是一個 "多不見得比較好" 的例子。
我越來越覺得,anything in its native form is better, unless we have a super powerful scaler/transcanner to upconvert the signal to higher resolution. And from what I've seen so far, probably Faroudja's NRS and Snell$Wilcox's box (I forgot its name, it's a transcanning technology) are the only ones that can claim the title. I have not seen a single scaler that can upconvert nicely, except for ATI Raedon/GeForce 3. But the later are not stand-alone scaler, they require PC platform.
So, scaler is the key to future digital displays! I hope someone is listening ...
林宗毅
|
|