新手上路
二星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 20
- 舊站發表文章數
- 295
|
發表於 2002-5-3 14:30:59
|
顯示全部樓層
THE $10,000 AMPLIFIER CHALLENGE RULES Part II {April 21, 2000}
Amplifier Comparison Test Conditions
1. Amplifier gain controls - of both channels - are matched to within +- .05
dB.
2. Speaker wires on both amps are properly wired with respect to polarity.
(+ and -)
3. That neither amp has signal phase inversion. If so correction will be
made in #2 above.
4. That neither amp is loaded beyond its rated impedance.
5. That all amplifiers with signal processors have those circuits bypassed.
This includes bass boost circuits, filters, etc. If frequency tailoring
circuits cannot be completely bypassed an equalizer will be inserted in the
signal path of one (only one and the listener can decide which) of the amps
to compensate for the difference. Compensation will also be made for input
and output loading that affects frequency response. Since we are only
listening for differences in the sonic signature of circuit topology, the
addition of an EQ in one signal path only should make the test even easier.
6. That neither amp exhibits excessive noise (including RFI).
7. That each amp can be properly driven by the test setup. Not normally a
problem but it is theoretically a problem.
8. That the L and R channels are not reversed in one amp.
9. That neither amp has excessive physical noise or other indicators that
can be observed by the listener.
10. That neither amp has DC OFFSET that causes audible pops when its output
is switched.
11. That the channel separation of all amps in the test is at least 30 dB
from 20Hz to 20kHz.
In addition to these requirements the test will be conducted according to
the following rules.
Amplifier Test Comparison Rules
1. To make things easy we would prefer to use high quality home type
loudspeakers for the test. If our speakers are not acceptable, the listener
can provide any commercially available speaker system as long as it uses
dynamic drivers. The actual measured impedance cannot exceed the rated load
impedance of the amplifiers tested. If, however, the tester would like to
perform the test in a car, we will use a car, however, it will have to be
provided by the test subject. For practicality we will have to limit the
number of amplifier channels to four or less.
2. Amplifiers will be powered from the same power supply at a nominal 14
volts DC. (any voltage is OK as long as it is the same for both amps)
3. The test can be conducted at any volume desired; however, the amps will
not be allowed to clip. In other words, listening volume can not exceed the
power capacity of the smallest amp of the pair being tested. (power capacity
will be defined as clipping or 2%THD 20Hz to 10kHz, whichever is less)
4. No test signals can be used - only commercially available music.
5. The listener can compare two amps at a time for as long as desired. For
practical reasons we would like to keep this at least no more than a few
hours. A test session will consist of 12 A/B sequences. Passing the test
will require a positive identification of each amp for all 12 sequences.
Remember, guessing will get you about 6 out of 12. If the differences are so
great, and a subject can really hear the difference, then he/she should be
able to do so for all 12 sequences.
6. To win the $10,000.00, the listener must pass two complete sessions of 12
comparisons. Passing the test means 24 correct responses.* The amp of choice
can be compared to the same or a different amp in each session - challengers
choice. We have many amplifiers in our demo inventory such as, but not
limited to, Alpine, Rockford, Kicker, Phoenix Gold, Precision Power, MTX,
Adcom, Kenwood, Pioneer, Sony, etc. You can pick any of them or bring your
own.
7. All amps must be brand name, standard production, linear voltage
amplifiers. This does not exclude high current amps. Amps can not be
modified and must meet factory specs. They must be "car audio amplifiers
designed to be powered from a car's electrical system."
8. Failure of an amp (this includes thermal shutdown) during the test will
require that the test be repeated after repair or replacement or cooling of
the amp. This means that the entire test session will have to be repeated.
9. The amps will not be overloaded during the session from either a voltage
or current requirement.
10. To save time the listener will have to pass a quick 8 trial session to
qualify for the extended 2 session test for the money prize. Any 2 amps can
be used for this test. Passing this qualifying test will require at least 6
out of 8 correct answers.
11. The amplifier power up and/or power down sequence will not be acceptable
for comparison. (The turn on/off noises of some amplifiers would give it
away.)
12. Although anyone is welcome to take the test, only subjects employed in
the car audio industry or Car Sound subscribers are eligible for the
$10,000.00 prize.
13. Cost to take the test is $100.00. $300.00 for people representing
companies. Payable in advance, scheduled appointments only. Done correctly
the test takes several hours and I don't have the time if you aren't
serious.
* Twelve correct responses in a row is certainly a lot of correct listening
but $10,000 is also a lot of money for a few hours of easy listening. The
way people describe the differences is that they are like night and day. I
would certainly not have any trouble choosing between an apple and an orange
12 times in a row. When compared fairly I believe the differences in amps
are much too small to audibly detect and certainly too small to pay large
sums of extra money for. If I am wrong someone should be able to carefully
take this test and win my money. Even if I am right, if enough people take
the test eventually someone will take my money due to random chance. This is
the reason for the large sample requirement. If you feel that you can easily
pass this test but 12 sequences will give you "listening fatigue" I am
willing to modify the requirements. Since the way it is being offered is a
challenge and only my money is at risk I am willing to let a confident
challenger "put his money where his ears are". If we are willing to make
this a bet instead of a challenge, I am willing to drop 1 sequence for every
thousand dollars put up by the challenger against my money. This would mean:
____My___________ _ _Your________Trails Required to
win__
$10,000 to $0 =
12 Tries
$9,000 to $1,000 =
11 Tries
$8,000 to $2,000 =
10 Tries
$7,000 to $3,000 =
9 Tries
$6,000 to $4,000 =
8 Tries
$5,000 to $5,000 =
7 Tries
$4,000 to $6,000 =
6 Tries
I will not do the test with less than 6 trails. It would be statistically
meaningless and reduce the challenge to mere gambling. |
|