新手上路
四星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 3261
- 舊站發表文章數
- 1711
|
發表於 2010-6-29 08:13:59
|
顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 Kushana
[B]
當然, 有便宜EDn出現,當然買起來站衛兵
不過也失去了聽音樂的樂趣
[/B]
There are many things that can be discussed about LP collections that are more interesting than the well beaten London vs Decca. For example, 1) the house sound of earlier recordings (before mid 60s), and 2) some people loves one label and hates the other, what did they do wrong?
Let me throw in some biased thoughts about Decca ED1/ED2 first. Like Kushana, I bought ED1/ED2 and London blue back when they show up. I might even pay more than what I would pay for a DG even though those EDn/BB all ended up 站衛兵. Why would I do that? Simple, because someone else will pay more for them.
In the 50s and early 60s, the top musicians and orchestras/conductors recorded for UK Columbia/EMI and DG in Europe, and Columbia in US. RCA has Heifetz. Decca at that time mostly only have access to 2nd tier musicians with a few exceptions. If one looks at Decca's catalog before 1962, i.e. those before SXL-2315, those were mostly popular orchestral music and some popular concertos, not really an exciting repertoire. I am not saying that all EMI/DG recordings are more musically satisfying than Decca recordings but I think it is fair to say that most Decca ED1/ED2 are not great performances. I can understand why one would want to collect some but collecting the whole set?
|
|