忘記密碼
 立即註冊
查看: 776|回覆: 6

另一篇不錯的投影機比較:VW11 vs. Z9000

  [複製鏈接]

262

主題

1034

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
66
舊站發表文章數
1298
發表於 2001-9-24 11:49:54 | 顯示全部樓層

另一篇不錯的投影機比較:VW11 vs. Z9000

AVS forum 有一篇很仔細的比較,有興趣者可以看一下:
http://www.avsforum.com/ubb/Forum10/HTML/009085.html

其結論是,out of box without any fine tuning, VW11 is close to Z9000 performance!

不管如何,it's a good read. 大家參考參考。

林宗毅

570

主題

5276

回帖

70

積分

新手上路

努力看事情光明面的Tom

舊站積分
1645
舊站發表文章數
5159
 樓主| 發表於 2001-9-24 22:58:12 | 顯示全部樓層
林版主
這位仁兄應該說的
很中肯吧!

Well I saw the SHARP and the SONY next to each other today.
It was on the same type of screen (Kikuchi something)in an almost completely dark room. I couldn't fiddle around with the settings or anything but from experience I would say
that for what I have to comment on it doesn't matter that
much.
The SHARP is superior to the SONY when it comes to contrast.
It's not even close. I cannot understand how anybody can say the difference is small. It is not.
In dark scenes the details are washed out with the SONY but clearly visible with the SHARP. Go see for yourselves.

When it comes to color the difference was moot, maybe the SHARP had better reds.
When it comes to lumens (as it was set up) there was no big difference.

But for me the most important aspect of a projector is contrast, and there the SHARP wins hands down.

If you are in Tokyo, go to Akihabara, Dynamic Audios new location, 3F. They have an excellent room where they show the SHARP, SONY, a Mitsubishi ~LV-2000 and some other not
so good projectors. The Mits was horrible.

The SHARP will cost you 668.000 Yen and the SONY about 550.000.
I would say there is no question about which one to buy.


...............................

最近公事繁忙
暫時閉關修養
目前使用的器材和心得(gundam奮鬥之路)
http://pub31.ezboard.com/favlife ... e?topicID=201.topic

717

主題

5233

回帖

110

積分

新手上路

Moderator

舊站積分
1241
舊站發表文章數
5254
發表於 2001-9-25 00:05:58 | 顯示全部樓層
Doctor Lin:


Very good evaluation on the Z9000 & 11HT; However, it would have been better
had a 480p source been used instead of 480i source where the projectors'
built-in i/p scalers had great influence on their respective presentation.

terry

   EMC 世界盃高球賽11月日本開打,NHK hi 1080i 直播!

173

主題

3121

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
36
舊站發表文章數
2801
發表於 2001-9-25 10:23:34 | 顯示全部樓層
果然再度證明人的眼睛是主觀的
在AV SCIENCE的那篇中提到:
Overall impression

I'd take either projector home. The Sharp was amazing, and had slightly deeper blacks than the Sony, but the Sony put out a brighter image that looked "crisper" than the Sharp and in some ways was more satisfying as a result. I was quite surprised how good the Sony looked in comparison especially considering how negative the reports were from CEDIA. It wasn't a night-and-day difference. More a matter of degrees. The Sony had a SLIGHTLY more visible screen-door effect, but I didn't feel the Sharp was screen-door free either. I'll talk more about that when I describe each separately. The Sharp seemed to have a more lush color pallette than the Sony...reds seemed more true on the Sharp (which actually had INCREDIBLE red reprodution. I've never seen Reds like that on any digital projector).

但是在GUNDAM兄轉載的文章卻說:
I cannot understand how anybody can say the difference is small. It is not.
The SHARP will cost you 668.000 Yen and the SONY about 550.000.
I would say there is no question about which one to buy.

兩種截然不同的評價,我想投影機真的要自己去看過才好


21

主題

412

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

永久榮譽會員MYAV全體網兄致敬

舊站積分
4
舊站發表文章數
441
發表於 2001-9-25 10:43:13 | 顯示全部樓層
Yes, everyone should let his eyes tell what he likes.

I think the discrepant comment on the same projector is mainly caused by the different setup and personal taste.  There may be night and day difference between poor and good setup (including screen, video source and fine tune).  I'm sorry that most of setup at the showroom, exhibition and AV shop are not good enough to show the real potential of the projectors.  There are exceptional cases but seldom.  I think the best demo is at videophile's house who is familar to the setting of his projector and has the ability to make it shine.

262

主題

1034

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
66
舊站發表文章數
1298
發表於 2001-9-25 12:10:49 | 顯示全部樓層
我原本想寫說,跟我看的11HT怎麼插這麼多,後來打住不寫,讓每個人自己去嬝炕C

基本上我是不相信11ht z9000會如此接近,除非美國的機器設定與調整,跟亞洲截然不同,which is almost impossible.

I agree with Jon and CKL, that set up is important, and hence don't trust too much the store setup, do see it IN Person in a good setup (either a very professional store or people like JBL, Gundam, ...)

So, that's why my brief conclusions was "大家參考參考". It shows again that different people at different set up saw different things and have different comments. But it's interesting to see how he compares things.

And, Terry, yes, I agree that 480p is also a source people need to test and compare, not just HD, or not just 480i.

So, I tend to think that MyAV projector shoot out is more like introduce to people what is the difference in display technology, everyone should make his/her own opinion and judgement. No matter how professional the expert may be, his opinion may not be necessarily yours.

MY opinion, [], is VW11 is a good projector in its own merit, but when it comes to contrast and 景深 of the picture, I think it is still not the better choice, considering other choices we have. But it maybe ideal projector for some whose priority may not necessarily be contrast and 景深, maybe it's the ease of use and the brandname.

林宗毅

570

主題

5276

回帖

70

積分

新手上路

努力看事情光明面的Tom

舊站積分
1645
舊站發表文章數
5159
 樓主| 發表於 2001-9-26 00:23:36 | 顯示全部樓層
我想該不會r
他們的Z9000不是日規  
或是說和日規出場顏色設定和畫面設定
根本性格就與日規的機器不同的關係
您說呢??

...............................

最近公事繁忙
暫時閉關修養
目前使用的器材和心得(gundam奮鬥之路)
http://pub31.ezboard.com/favlife ... e?topicID=201.topic


被 gundam重新編輯於 09/26/2001  00:26:29
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-21 04:07 , Processed in 0.099955 second(s), 35 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表