新手上路
初級會員
- 舊站積分
- 0
- 舊站發表文章數
- 15
|
發表於 2001-10-31 11:33:36
|
顯示全部樓層
參考一下 www.hometheaterhifi.com 的文章, 好像大部份的 dvd player 都用 genesis 的 chipset 耶 (9000es, sd9200, ...)
A look at some common chipsets
Genesis gmVLX1A-X & gmAFMC
This is by far the most common deinterlacing chipset used in progressive DVD players. The gmVLX1A-X is the actual deinterlacer, and has both a film mode and a video mode, as well as a 「graphics」 mode which is just a simple weave of every pair of fields. The main chip does not, however, have any way of analyzing the video to determine whether it should be in film mode or not, and that』s where the gmAFMC comes in. It uses data (provided by the gmVLX1A-X) to figure out if there is a 3-2 pulldown sequence coming in, and switches the main chip on the fly between video and film modes.
Not all players use both chips. Some players use their own strategy for deciding when to be in film mode and when to be in video mode, so they forgo the gmAFMC. We』ll mention that in the individual player reviews. But most players use the two chips as a set.
The video mode on the Genesis is not motion-adaptive as we have defined the term. It uses "vertical-temporal filtering" which appears to us to be a slightly more advanced version of the vertical filtering we mentioned above, with the current field providing more of the input to the finished frame than the next or previous fields. It switches to a simple weave algorithm when the image is still or near-still. Overall, its video deinterlacing is poor, but watchable.
The Genesis chipset offers lots of useful options, including scaling 4x3 input to 16x9 output, and scaling any input signal to a wide range of output resolutions. These features were designed for the scaler market, but some DVD players are starting to make use of them for scaling and zoom features, and doing things like automatically scaling letterboxed movies to make them appear to be anamorphic to the TV.
The main Achilles heel of the Genesis chipset is that it doesn』t buffer more than one field, so it can』t look ahead to see cadence breaks coming in advance. Accordingly, the Genesis is almost guaranteed to comb on 3-2 pattern breaks. By the time it knows the cadence has broken, it has already sent out at least one bad frame. In addition, the Genesis is not very good at identifying or handling 2-2 cadence, which comes up more than you might think.
The players that use the Genesis chipset don』t all have exactly the same deinterlacing performance. There are tradeoffs that can be made by adjusting the sensitivity of the gmAFMC chip to cadence mismatches, and that causes some players to do better than others on certain kinds of material. Often, though, on other material the advantage is flip-flopped. There is no perfect setting.
Silicon Image Sil503 (DVDO DV103)
(DVDO recently was purchased by Silicon Image, so we'll refer to current chips by their Silicon Image names, and older chips by the DVDO names.) This chip (like its earlier incarnations, the DV101 and DV102/Sil502) is a single-chip solution that does both deinterlacing and mode detection. It does not scale the signal to different resolutions, but the latest revisions of the chip can do 4x3 to 16x9 conversion. While the bulk of the work is done by the SiI503, Silicon Image also recommends an off-the-shelf programmable coprocessor be used as well, running their proprietary MC503 software. This adds more sophisticated cadence analysis, and improves the handling of complicated material immensely. Almost all DVD players use this extra chip.
The Silicon Image chip buffers 4 fields at all times, which it uses for cadence analysis as well as motion analysis in video mode. As a result, it is much better than the Genesis at handling cadence problems, and combs very little. Its video-mode deinterlacing algorithm is motion-adaptive, and is substantially better than the one on the Genesis. It handles 2-2 cadence with no trouble. Overall, it』s one of the best performing deinterlacers on the market, comparable only to much more expensive products from Faroudja, and a few others.
The video deinterlacing on the Silicon Image is motion-adaptive on a pixel-by-pixel basis, which is very good. The Silicon Image has some edge detection and smoothing algorithms, but they are not as complex as the ones on the Sage chip. Overall, however, the Silicon Image does an excellent job deinterlacing video material.
|
|