忘記密碼
 立即註冊
查看: 824|回覆: 9

古典結他<<蔡世鴻/棕髮女郎>>「害」我多花四萬多元升

  [複製鏈接]

43

主題

137

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
0
舊站發表文章數
103
發表於 2004-12-27 18:03:58 | 顯示全部樓層 |閱讀模式


SEIKO TSAI SOLO GUITAR
LA FILLE AUX CHEVEUX DE LIN

http://www.windsong.com.tw/db_detail.asp?brand=china

這張CD一放,馬上讓我多花四萬多元將音響再度升級.
原來應該是一張「極普通」的古典結他獨奏,卻抓出我的音響臭蟲.
我的多聲道音響系統主要是以DENON AVR-3805加上外接兩部後級擴大機來推動前面的B&W Nautilus 801,中罝及後罝喇叭則利用DENON  AVR-3805內罝的擴大機來推動,原本聽了半年多的音響系統,播放任何CD都未曾有什麼大問題,連「阿姐鼓」都推得順順的,卻給這張CD打敗了.
大家聽過「阿姐鼓」的發燒友都知道裡面的大鼓威力,如果用Adobe Audition分析,第一聲大鼓的動態起伏,有26dB(-4dB vs -30dB)之距,也就是說有大約512倍功率的差距.我用一部150W的後級和一部300W的後級擴大機分別推N801的中高音單體及低音單體,聽了半年多也不覺得有什麼不妥,直到播放「蔡世鴻/棕髮女郎」這張CD才發現原來用來推動N801的中高音單體的150W後級電流不夠.
這張CD並沒有任何高動態的片段,不過只要播放第一首曲子的第一粒撥弦,我的N801便會發出一些撥弦以外的怪聲,於是大家湊上前面靠近高音單體仔細研究,我們可以清楚聽到撥弦後,聲音音量下降時會有斷斷續續的情況發生,就好像機車不夠油,快要死火那樣.我嚐試播放其他CD,發現的確有相同的現象,不過卻不會那麼明顯,於是我試著將DENON AVR-3805接上N801的中高音單體,嘩!情況更是糟糕,播放出來的簡直是破爛不堪的哀鳴,於是我把「蔡世鴻/棕髮女郎」改由後聲道播出,這時我們聽到從DENON AVR-3805推動後置的B&W DM605S2,發出完美無誤的正確聲音.故事說到這l裡,相信大家都心裡有數,問題出在B&W Nautilus 801的身上,為了澈底瞭解原因,我把N801的高音單體防塵蓋小心移開,把沾在上面的一切塵土小心掃除.結果卻是沒有半點改善,現在只好把接在N801低音上面的300W擴大器接到中高音單體上試試看,這時候播放出來的聲音是清晰無誤的撥弦,太好了,臭蟲終於找出來了,原來是這台150W後級不夠力,我花了一個星期,找到一部20年保固的Bryston 3BSST (150W)二手貨,足足多花了四萬多元才解決了一個不明顯的臭蟲.一張沒有什麼大動態的CD,「蔡世鴻/棕髮女郎」 卻可以那麼容易將我的音響臭蟲找到了,真是意料之外.

很多人對喇叭這種器具很著迷,花了三五十萬台幣購入一對高級喇叭,但卻接上一些對不上的擴大機(因為太大食了),我就是一個活生生的示範,滿以為一部萬多元的後級可以推得動N801的中高音單體,卻不知不覺地聽了半年失真的聲音,要不是這張「蔡世鴻/棕髮女郎」CD的出現,我看再聽十年也未必如此輕鬆的把臭蟲抓出來,蔡世鴻老師,太感謝了!
Paul Ng

568

主題

2萬

回帖

125

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
32767
舊站發表文章數
7791
發表於 2004-12-27 20:51:57 | 顯示全部樓層
恭喜在音響之路上又有新的發現,N801應該不是易與之物,在音響展中廠商以
數部PASS伺候仍發出令我搖頭(甚至想奪門而出)的聲音,當然也有可能是擺r
位及房間吸收擴散處理不良,但是這喇叭需要調校卻是不言可喻。
喇叭的確是很迷人的一環,的確如你所說,基本上只要擴大機不要太差,接上喇
叭幾乎都會有還OK的表現,但是卻要到真正找到與它有良好搭配的擴大機才能
知道原來它可以做的是這麼多!!關於B&W的搭配在版上應該不難搜尋,或許r
爬爬文章你會有新體驗~[]
Love is so short, and forgetting is so long... by Pablo Neruda

109

主題

8067

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
20359
舊站發表文章數
2489
發表於 2004-12-27 22:20:57 | 顯示全部樓層

哇.真棒.

這篇如果貼到"純音響發燒友討論區" 那邊.
一定有很多同好會響應的.[]

43

主題

137

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
0
舊站發表文章數
103
 樓主| 發表於 2004-12-27 22:36:34 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 李
[B]恭喜在音響之路上又有新的發現,N801應該不是易與之物,在音響展中廠商以
數部PASS伺候仍發出令我搖頭(甚至想奪門而出)的聲音,當然也有可能是擺r
位及房間吸收擴散處理不良,但是這喇叭需要調校卻是不言可喻。
喇叭的確是很迷人的一環,的確如你所說,基本上只要擴大機不要太差,接上喇
叭幾乎都會有還OK的表現,但是卻要到真正找到與它有良好搭配的擴大機才能
知道原來它可以做的是這麼多!!關於B&W的搭配在版上應該不難搜尋,或許r
爬爬文章你會有新體驗~[] [/B]


SEIKO TSAI's guitar solo album comprises of simple clear plunks of strings on the classical guitar. The first plunk is a 600Hz sound that falls into the tweeter range of the N801. According to the STEREOPHILE MAGAZINE N801 Review in 1999, the measured impedence is 3-4 ohm at the mid-hi range, that is, well below the "norminal 8 ohm" stated in the manufacturer's manual. DENON AVR-3801 is not suggested to output to any speakers below 6 ohm (look into the manual). Now the problem lies in B&W as she did not speak the truth. According to my measurement, the bass unit and the mid-hi unit of N801 has a efficiency descrepancy of 6dB. This means if you want a balanced sound between the bass and the mid-hi speaker units, you need 4W feeding to the bass when the mid-hi unit sounds at 1W. This 4:1 descrepancy is fatal to many audiophiles when people simply think that a single high power amplifier can handle the N801. In fact N801 was described as very bright by many reviewers who did not acquire this knowledge. I personally think that B&W has to admit her wrong-doing of hiding these basic facts to the customers. (The Focal Lab Grand Utopia might have the same problem.).

http://stereophile.com/loudspeakerreviews/207/index8.html

edit: some typos
Paul Ng

43

主題

137

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
0
舊站發表文章數
103
 樓主| 發表於 2004-12-27 22:40:19 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 drpaulng
[B]

SEIKO TSAI's guitar solo album comprises of simple clear plunks of strings on the classical guitar. The first plunk is a 600Hz sound that falls into the tweeter range of the N801. According to the STEREOPHILE MAGAZINE N801 Review in 1999, the measured impedence is 3-4 ohm at the mid-hi range, that is, well below the "norminal 8 ohm" stated in the manufacturer's manual. DENON AVR-3805 is not suggested to output to any speakers below 6 ohm (look into the manual). Now the problem lies in B&W as she did not speak the truth. According to my measurement, the bass unit and the mid-hi unit of N801 has a efficiency descrepancy of 6dB. This means if you want a balanced sound between the bass and the mid-hi speaker units, you need 4W feeding to the bass when the mid-hi unit sounds at 1W. This 4:1 descrepancy is fatal to many audiophiles when people simply think that a single high power amplifier can handle the N801. In fact N801 was described as very bright by many reviewers who did not acquire this knowledge. I personally think that B&W has to admit her wrong-doing of hiding these basic facts to the customers. (The Focal Lab Grand Utopia might have the same problem.).

http://stereophile.com/loudspeakerreviews/207/index8.html

edit: some typos [/B]
Paul Ng

43

主題

137

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
0
舊站發表文章數
103
 樓主| 發表於 2004-12-28 16:14:29 | 顯示全部樓層

修正錯誤

「阿姐鼓」第一大鼓動態應為0.4dB vs 31dB = 30dB左右,敲鼓前後功率比約為1:1000W (因為Abobe Auditon 以 .4標示 0.4,所以誤讀了)

參考:
1        W   0dB
2        W   3dB
4        W   6dB
8        W   9dB
16        W   12dB
32        W   15dB
64        W   18dB
128        W   21dB
256        W   24dB
512        W   27dB
1024        W   30dB
2048        W   33dB
4096        W   36dB
8192        W   39dB
16384        W   42dB
32768        W   45dB
65536        W   48dB
131072        W   51dB
262144        W   54dB
524288        W   57dB
1048576        W   60dB
2097152        W   63dB
4194304        W   66dB
Paul Ng

568

主題

2萬

回帖

125

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
32767
舊站發表文章數
7791
發表於 2004-12-28 18:44:51 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 drpaulng
[B]

SEIKO TSAI's guitar solo album comprises of simple clear plunks of strings on the classical guitar. The first plunk is a 600Hz sound that falls into the tweeter range of the N801. According to the STEREOPHILE MAGAZINE N801 Review in 1999, the measured impedence is 3-4 ohm at the mid-hi range, that is, well below the "norminal 8 ohm" stated in the manufacturer's manual. DENON AVR-3801 is not suggested to output to any speakers below 6 ohm (look into the manual). Now the problem lies in B&W as she did not speak the truth. According to my measurement, the bass unit and the mid-hi unit of N801 has a efficiency descrepancy of 6dB. This means if you want a balanced sound between the bass and the mid-hi speaker units, you need 4W feeding to the bass when the mid-hi unit sounds at 1W. This 4:1 descrepancy is fatal to many audiophiles when people simply think that a single high power amplifier can handle the N801. In fact N801 was described as very bright by many reviewers who did not acquire this knowledge. I personally think that B&W has to admit her wrong-doing of hiding these basic facts to the customers. (The Focal Lab Grand Utopia might have the same problem.).

http://stereophile.com/loudspeakerreviews/207/index8.html

edit: some typos [/B]

這大概也是許多801用家使用電子分音、多部擴大機同時驅動的原因吧。
不過即使像Paul Ng(您是香港或新加坡人吧?)兄使用兩部擴大機,假設一
部功率為另一部的四倍,也無法保證對單體輸出功率是四比一吧?
小弟不是電子科班,上請Paul兄解惑。[8)]
Love is so short, and forgetting is so long... by Pablo Neruda

43

主題

137

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
0
舊站發表文章數
103
 樓主| 發表於 2004-12-28 20:06:46 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 李
[B]
這大概也是許多801用家使用電子分音、多部擴大機同時驅動的原因吧。
不過即使像Paul Ng(您是香港或新加坡人吧?)兄使用兩部擴大機,假設一
部功率為另一部的四倍,也無法保證對單體輸出功率是四比一吧?
小弟不是電子科班,上請Paul兄解惑。[8)] [/B]


可以用電子分音(我有用),也可以不用,只要在前級調整好差6dB即可讓N801達到平衡.N802比較好推可以說成,N801及N802同樣擁有相同的中高音單體,但是N802的低音單體比較高效率,用一部擴大機去推,不至引起如N801那麼離譜的偏亮.音響論壇最近出版一本「高級音響精品錄」p.52提及用「雙擴大機療法」來對付JM Lab Grande Utopia Be,應該是同樣在前級上調整好低音和中高音單體之間的差距,但是要用「SKII面膜法」以捲筒衛生紙2-3張遮在高音單體之前就有點土味,不過我認為罪過的應該是製造商,最少也要把「秘密」告訴代理商才對,連代理商都要自己想辦法法療用單一擴大機推動時高音偏亮.消費者花了一百萬買一對要用捲筒衛生紙2-3張遮在高音單體才能聽的喇叭回家...的確要檢討.
因為我對空間處理下了很多功夫,才會用電腦測量一些音響數據,也更瞭解為何大家一直在換機器和喇叭...說來話長.
Paul Ng

568

主題

2萬

回帖

125

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
32767
舊站發表文章數
7791
發表於 2004-12-29 00:54:07 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 drpaulng
[B]

可以用電子分音(我有用),也可以不用,只要在前級調整好差6dB即可讓N801達到平衡.N802比較好推可以說成,N801及N802同樣擁有相同的中高音單體,但是N802的低音單體比較高效率,用一部擴大機去推,不至引起如N801那麼離譜的偏亮.音響論壇最近出版一本「高級音響精品錄」p.52提及用「雙擴大機療法」來對付JM Lab Grande Utopia Be,應該是同樣在前級上調整好低音和中高音單體之間的差距,但是要用「SKII面膜法」以捲筒衛生紙2-3張遮在高音單體之前就有點土味,不過我認為罪過的應該是製造商,最少也要把「秘密」告訴代理商才對,連代理商都要自己想辦法法療用單一擴大機推動時高音偏亮.消費者花了一百萬買一對要用捲筒衛生紙2-3張遮在高音單體才能聽的喇叭回家...的確要檢討.
因為我對空間處理下了很多功夫,才會用電腦測量一些音響數據,也更瞭解為何大家一直在換機器和喇叭...說來話長. [/B]

再請教:如果雙擴大機療法兩台擴大機使用不同廠牌,欲取"截長補短"之用意不知合理可行否?
Love is so short, and forgetting is so long... by Pablo Neruda

43

主題

137

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
0
舊站發表文章數
103
 樓主| 發表於 2004-12-29 09:36:18 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 李
[B]
再請教:如果雙擴大機療法兩台擴大機使用不同廠牌,欲取"截長補短"之用意不知合理可行否? [/B]


Basically, you don't need to bi-amp a well-balanced design of speaker system that consists of equal (or near-equal) efficiency on its speaker units. But bi-amping is a "must" for such kind of speakers like N801 with the efficiency discrepancy so great (6dB).
To choose power amplifiers for the N801 as an example, you need a high power current-limitless amp for the bass unit and another (still current-limitless) with less power (you don't need so much power) for the higher-efficient mid-hi units. Look into the measured impedance of N801, you've got 3-4 ohm load across "most of" the frequency spectrum (vs the 8 ohm stated in the manufacturer's manual). So, if you output a current-limited amplifier to the N801 to what ever the bass or the mid-hi units, you'll get distorted result depending on the current drawing ability of the amplifier's output. You may choose a 300W high-current amp to drive the bass unit and a 100W high-current amp to drive the mid-hi units of such low impedance speaker system.

However, for whatever kind of speakers, it's a good idea to use bi-amp with lesser power per each one rather than using a single high power amp.
Ref:
http://sound.westhost.com/bi-amp.htm#power_dist

Read carefully and you'll get the idea why a pair of 100W amps gets you more unclipped power than a single 200-300W amp in driving any speakers with terminals ready for bi-wiring (and thus bi-amping).
Paul Ng
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-22 17:27 , Processed in 0.705480 second(s), 43 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表