新手上路
四星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 150
- 舊站發表文章數
- 1109
|
轉載自AV GUIDE....
The 100 Greatest Pop Albums of the Century
By Allan Kozinn
Let us begin by agreeing that lists of the greatest anything are battlefields, by nature. If they are compiled conscientiously, they are agonized over, and the compiler is never entirely satisfied. Every reader, as well, knows for an absolute certainty that he or she could assemble a better, truer, more valid list. Even if we are only glancingly familiar with the subject of a list, we are likely to cluck our tongues and roll our eyes over both selections and omissions; disputes increase in direct proportion to a reader』s knowledge and passion for the subject of a list.
So I』m not under any illusions that mine is the list to end all lists. It is, I think, reasoned and defensible, and it largely does what I wanted it to do, which was to cover a lot of ground — though by no means the full expanse of popular music. It is a personal list; but it is not a personal desert-island list. That would be quite different. It would, for starters, include the complete recordings of the Beatles, and larger helpings of the Rolling Stones, Bob Dylan, both Elvises (Presley and Costello), Ella Fitzgerald, and Jimi Hendrix, and that would mean that quite a few entries would be jettisoned. I tempered those preferences in the interests of painting a broader picture of the best that the world of pop music has produced.
But what is pop? Perhaps the first order of business should be to define some terms, since virtually every word of the title of this list demands a kind of Talmudic parsing. For starters, my definition of "century" is a bit constricted, mainly because my definition of "album" is as well. Although I do include some earlier music, my century is really only 52 years long, starting with the introduction of the LP in 1948.
For the most part, I am using the current common parlance meaning of "album" as a collection of songs that are physically inseparable — i.e., compiled on an LP or CD, under a title meant to cover the complete contents. Ideally, it is a unified sequence of some kind, which is to say that it was assembled with a clear opening, middle, and end, and with some consideration for the experience of playing it through. At the very least, it is the product of a discrete run of sessions or concerts.
There are several problems with this definition. One is historical and linguistic. However we think of an album now, the term actually alludes to the practice of collecting 78rpm discs in book-like contrivances, in which each page was a pocket that held a single disc. Those were albums in the way that a photo album or a stamp album is, and an LP or CD is not. In classical music, it took such an album to house a symphony; in pop, generally, these albums bound together singles that lived lives of their own, not sequenced album tracks as we think of them today. Had RCA, rather the CBS, won the format war of the late 1940s, 78s would have given way to 45s rather than LPs, and the "album" would have remained closer in concept to the old books of 78s.
The real problem with my somewhat purist definition, though, is that by implicitly excluding compilations and hits collections, it also excludes a great deal of spectacular music — music that I love, and that defines its time — simply because it was produced my musicians who excelled at singles rather than albums. The "girl groups" of the 1950s, the products of Phil Spector』s hit factory, and the incomparable works of the Motown vocal groups of the 1960s are all cases in point. This may be my own failing, but for me, few complete albums by groups within these categories hold up as well as compilations. So I have abandoned the ban on compilations. I resort to them as sparingly as possible.
Still, sets like Rhino』s There』s a Riot Goin』 On, which compiles recordings of Lieber and Stoller classics by everyone from Big Mama Thornton, Ben E. King, and Elvis Presley to Dion and Tom Jones, and the Spector anthology, Back to Mono, with everything from the Ronettes, the Crystals, and the Teddy Bears to Spector』s classic productions for the Righteous Brothers and Ike and Tina Turner, cover so much ground that they can』t be ignored. And they make great listening.
Similarly, Columbia』s compilation of the complete 78rpm recordings of Robert Johnson seemed a must, as did Atlantic』s multi-disc overview of its best rhythm and blues sides, many of them also originally issued on 78s. In Johnson』s case, I could have chosen the old "King of the Delta Blues" compilations, classic albums in their own right. But I allowed rational factors (the possibility of getting the complete works in one package) to override nostalgia. As compromises go, allowing compilations isn』t perfect: Dealing with the girl groups problem, for example, has meant weighing Rhino』s superb Wonder Women against Mercury』s Growin』 Up Too Fast. Choosing the Rhino meant getting some great Shirelles, Dixie Cups, and Betty Everett tracks, but missing The Shangri-Las, Dusty Springfield, and the Angels, all on the Mercury disc — and vice versa. I went with the latter: C』est la guerre, I』m afraid.
My definition of "popular" also needs explaining, since it whittles further at my already shortened century. I』m talking about the rock era here. There are forays into other realms. I included Ella Fitzgerald, Frank Sinatra, and Robert Johnson, for example, because by the broadest definition, they are pop — and more importantly, they are favorites that I wanted on my list. One could argue, though, that vocals of the Fitzgerald-Sinatra kind and Johnson』s blues belong more to the jazz world than to the pop world, and jazz will have a list of its own. So I have stepped gingerly there, defining some fine vocalists (from the Andrews Sisters to Sarah Vaughan, Dinah Washington, Nat King Cole, Tony Bennett, and Sammy Davis, Jr.) as being outside my purview.
There is also a whole industry of middle-of-the-road pop music that is not really jazz, definitely not rock, and also not my cup of tea. If I were offering a comprehensive survey of popular music, I would probably have to tip my hat to Al Martino, Steve and Edie, and Vic Damone, to say nothing of their equivalents in light instrumental music. But again, this is a personal selection. So those singers aren』t included, nor have I included rap groups, popular though they are. For that matter, I haven』t included much in the way of country music or gospel or the purest forms of folk music, except where they intersect with rock.
Is this too limited a definition of "popular" music? Maybe, but to me, the sheer variety of styles that falls within the definition of rock argues otherwise. Besides, my selections are based principally on what I consider great music, regardless of whether it appealed mainly to a niche audience (like Tangerine Dream』s bleakly atmospheric Phaedra) or was sickeningly overplayed (Derek and the Dominoes』 Layla — still great if you can hear it as if though it were your first listening). And there are a couple of entries that few TAS readers will have heard (a magnificent album of acoustic, grandly structured music by the Dutch band Flairck comes to mind); but I felt strongly enough about them to find room here, in the hope that an adventurous listener might seek them out. If I were going to include pop from the non-English speaking world, might I not have been better off with an Edith Piaf or Jacques Brel album? Maybe. My thought was that there are enough of the "usual suspects" on this list to warrant a few eccentricities — and besides, I』m sneakily mentioning Piaf and Brel here, aren』t I?
Even keeping mostly within the rock world, the choices were difficult — and so, on to my definition of "greatest." |
|