忘記密碼
 立即註冊
查看: 59661|回覆: 63

關於Room Gain

[複製鏈接]

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
發表於 2017-8-11 10:46:08 | 顯示全部樓層 |閱讀模式
關於Room Gain 找了些資料, 集中放在此處供參考討論.


1. 對於Room Gain的描述, 這段可以參考看看 :    interesting discription about room gain and frequecy below 20hz

Oftentimes Room Gain in HT refers to the sub-set of Pressure Vessel Gain (PVG), and Boundary Gain.

Boundary Gain is just that; increasing the gain by the addition of a boundary.
Beginning with a full spherical space, the ground merely halves the previous full space. This halving, theoretically mirrors another like powered driver, thereby resulting in a theoretical 6db gain. Each subsequent halving of space, with the addition of another boundary, also results in a theoretical 6db gain.

The maximum added SPL for each boundary is 6 dB per boundary.
So full corner loading adds 18 dB, less whatever is lost through the boundary. Boundary gain is only frequency limited to 1/8th the wavelength. Regarding a sub crossed at 80 Hz, you have a 14 foot, or 168 inch, wavelength. If the sub-woofer's drivers are within 21 inches of all three boundaries (for corner loading), you will get boundary gain up to 80 Hz.

Pressure Vessel Gain (PVG) is the scenario whereby the longest dimension of the room can no longer support full propagation of the waveform.
At this point, the acoustic propagation transitions to acoustic pressurization. The manner in which the sound is reproduced into the space changes from a normal cyclic propagation, to pressurization because the wavelengths are too big for the space.


The frequency at which this occurs is approximately the point whereby half the wavelength of a given frequency is equal to the rooms longest dimension. So, a 20 hz frequency has a wavelength 56.5 feet. So half of that, 28.25 feet, is the point of transition. Any frequency below that point pressurizes the room, and any frequency above that point propagates freely. So in this room that's approximately 28 feet in the longest dimension, from 20 hz downward, the room gives back acoustically.

At this frequency, the results are a gain in acoustic pressures in the room that grows as the frequency decreases. This acoustic support reciprocity, is theoretically 12db per octave. The percentage of the 12 db/octave gain one achieves, entirely depends on the integrity of the boundary walls and surfaces. If it was the theoretical concrete bunker, a full 12db/octave boost would occur. Typically, somewhere between 6-10 db octave could result. Also, in addition to the walls and surfaces flexing, other aspects may affect the point at which room gain begins. Furniture, cabinets etc, anything that consumes a certain measure of cubic feet, may slightly alter the transition frequency merely because the items take up space.

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
 樓主| 發表於 2017-8-11 10:47:45 | 顯示全部樓層
2. FAQ about Room Gain  
      
來源
Q: What principles factor into room gain?

A:To the best of my knowledge, it is largely a matter of room size and how rigid the boundaries are.


Q: Does a sealed sub have a higher potential than a ported sub?

A: A sealed sub tends to be better able to take advantage of room gain as it's natural rolloff of 12dB/octave lines up quite well with the theoretical 12dB/octave boost you'll get from room gain. Conversely, a ported sub rolls off at a rate of 24dB/octave below tuning, and is usually filtered against such inputs to prevent driver damage.


Q: Can it be approximated before you put a sub into a room?


A: You can always try to approximate it, but how close it is to reality is a whole different ball of wax. Basically, you divide the speed of sound by twice the longest dimension of your room, in my case 24 feet, to find the frequency where room gain should start to kick in. So for my room, were talking a little under 25Hz. As mentioned above, gain is a theoretical 12dB/octave. However, my room boundaries aren't exactly ten inch thick steel plates, so there will be losses.


Q: I have an ungodly sized area in my main home to fill with sound and I have no issues with my current 3.2 setup...So do I have a room with exceptional room gain???

A: You're probably not experience room gain; while your subs aren't necessarily output kings, they aren't pansies either. I'd fully expect them to be able to generate sufficient output to shake things up a bit.

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
 樓主| 發表於 2017-8-11 10:51:57 | 顯示全部樓層
這串: How to Figure out Room Gain 有更進階的解釋, 焦點資訊請看Mark Seaton 與 Bossobass的文.


前些時提過的data-bass的 Investigating Room Gain, "How much boost is my subwoofer going to get?" 也有很不錯的資訊.

然後這個串: Boundary Gain/Room Gain Questions 有人做了簡明的模擬圖示("boundary augmentation simulation")放在#10 , 說明在最長room mode 以下低頻增幅的情況..
不像以前雜誌與某些寫手玩家寫過的錯誤觀念, 密閉小空間並不是不能再生更低頻率, 反而是愈往極低頻的量能愈增加.

這在實測都能輕易証實的.

可能有人將room gain 與 room mode 搞混了. 如果先把定義搞清楚應有助於理解.

Room gain 開始影響的頻率, 以一般居家小型空間多半在30hz附近以下,  (cabin gain /pvg)量能隨愈低愈增幅恰好發生在人類聽覺不敏感的區域, 並不像room mode 發生在聽覺感知較高處, 也不像它有劇烈的量能起伏.
極低~infrasound 範圍也是超低音效率相對較低處, 尤其理論上密閉式超低音設計的自然衰減曲線與Room Gain的增幅斜率大致吻合(-12dB/Oct vs +12dB/Oct, ideally speaking), 小空間有這樣量感的自然補助, 剛好提供一個平坦頻率延伸的好處.

雖然少見.. 偶而還是有白吃午餐的機會啊[]

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
 樓主| 發表於 2017-8-11 12:05:23 | 顯示全部樓層
延伸資訊:

根據Harman的研究, 多數人喜歡的聽覺頻響曲線是略帶空間增益的.
盲測結果顯示幾近平坦的頻響曲線下, 比較上來說, 受試者普遍描述是中高頻較不耐聽低頻也略薄弱.

請參考An Acoustic Basis for the Harman Listener Target Curve

..here is a graphic of a JBL Synthesis professional room correction, including subwoofers.
The JBL target curve and measurements before and after EQ are plotted.
Again, the entire curve family slopes 10 dB across the spectrum, 1dB/octave






B&K 早期調查了許多錄混音場所的曲線, 也有類似走向.
It is also instructive to compare the classic Bruel & Kjaer curve from their 1974 AES paper measuring multiple critical listening rooms and studios. There is a 6dB decrease from 160Hz to 20kHz, about 0.9dB/octave, but the pattern is consistent.


226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
 樓主| 發表於 2017-8-11 12:22:21 | 顯示全部樓層
Room gain 補充說明 by Tom Danley 來源串

Room gain is a room thing related to acoustic size, unrelated to what kind of woofer is or alignment is used.
What happens is that if you think of free space, you can easily picture the sound radiates away from the source. When you put a speaker in a room, the sound also radiates BUT when the frequency is low enough so that the longest acoustic dimension is about a half wavelength or less, then the room acts to confine the pressure instead of it bouncing around and being absorbed.

In an absolutely solid concrete bunker, once your well below the lowest room mode, room pressure is proportional to driver displacement.
From the speaker point of view, this provides 12dB per octave gain as the frequency falls. In a perfect world like this, that slope EXACTLY compensates for a sealed box's roll off which also reaches 12 dB/oct.
That reciprocal set of slopes fix or EQ each other and the response extends flat to DC.
One of the extraordinarily few cases of a nearly free lunch.

In a real room, not a 3 foot thick concrete walled airtight bunker, the slope is always less than 12 dB per octave due to flexing and leakage.
Rooms I have measured (and this would be from a number of averages) tended to be in the 3 to 9dB per octave range, open plan houses having the least room gain.

System types;

Sealed box speakers have an asymptotic roll off that is 12 dB per octave although in the region of the knee, it can easily be less if it is a low Q alignment.

Vented boxes, passive radiator alignments have an asymptotic roll off of 24 dB per octave, basically, the higher the order of the alignment, the steeper the roll off is.

Tapped horns tend to be an in between alignment, typically in the 15 to 24 dB per octave range depending on the horn size relative to wavelength.

You can hear room gain yourself in your car where the room gain corner F is usually around 50 - 60 Hz. Here, a small sealed box with a 50Hz corner will deliver deep bass in the car when the windows are up.

34

主題

1311

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Da Man

舊站積分
1718
舊站發表文章數
1326
發表於 2017-8-11 13:00:55 | 顯示全部樓層
將重低音擺在離牆面 21 英吋以內來增加量感的方式一般稱為 Boundary gain 如下:  



Cabin gain 是因為音波波長超過空間最大尺寸而產生的.

理論上 Cabin gain 開始頻率: 音速 / ( 2 * L )

音速是 343 公尺 / 秒.

L 是空間中拿尺量最長的距離.

所以一個空間 長 5 公尺 * 寬 3.5 公尺 * 高 3.0 公尺, 那麼最簡單的算法, 最長的距離 L 就是 5 公尺. 則 Cabin gain 開始的頻率是 343 / ( 2 * 5 ) = 171.5 / 5 = 34.3 Hz.

問題是這個 "拿尺量最長的距離" 不是空間的長 -- 五公尺, 而是斜角距離. 因為空間是 3 D 的, 音波也不會只延著空間的長走. 我個人習慣是算出斜角距離. 這個空間斜角距離是 6.8 公尺. 則 343 / ( 2 * 6.8 ) = 171.5 / 6.8 = 25.22 Hz.  Cabin gain 開始的頻率是 25.22 Hz. 這個增益開始的頻率比較保守.

理論上, 每低八度就有 12 分貝的增異. 低八度就是頻率 / 2. 所以, Cabin gain 從 25.22 Hz 開始, 到了 12.61 Hz 有 12 分貝的增異, 到了 6.31 Hz 有 24 分貝的增異.      

大家有沒有發現, 空間最長的距離越長, Cabin gain 開始頻率就越低. 亦即一個空間越大就越不該指望 Cabin gain 能夠在夠高的頻率開始有足夠的增異.

上面就是 "封閉式重低音比較適合小空間, 反射式重低音比較適合大空間" 這個通則的基礎. 一般來說, 反射式重低音在開孔頻率附近 ( 通常是 16 ~ 32 Hz ) 的最大輸出會比封閉式多了 8 ~ 12 分貝. 若是在小空間採用封閉式重低音, Cabin gain 可以補足這個最大輸出的差別 ( 假設目標是 flat to 16 Hz ).

以上是理論... 在現實生活中, Boundary gain 還可以盡量排除 ( 把重低音不要靠牆擺 ), 可是 room mode 是無法完全排除的. 若是使用的重低音有 CEA 2010 數據, 那麼和室內的極限音壓相比較, 可以粗略算出這個空間給的 "白吃午餐" 是牛排, 還是營養口糧. [}] [}] [}]

249

主題

3萬

回帖

220

積分

新手上路

上將

舊站積分
11603
舊站發表文章數
26283
發表於 2017-8-11 13:11:41 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 Ken Wu
[B]延伸資訊:

根據Harman的研究, 多數人喜歡的聽覺頻響曲線是略帶空間增益的.
盲測結果顯示幾近平坦的頻響曲線下, 比較上來說, 受試者普遍描述是中高頻較不耐聽低頻也略薄弱.

請參考An Acoustic Basis for the Harman Listener Target Curve



[/B]


不錯的建議!
-------------------------------------
在下的看法是、不知要完成這曲線若不靠EQ,不知還能用甚麼方式去完成?。
[url=http://www.myav.com.tw/market/showthread.php?s=&threadid=5991]進口超值--色差、同軸數位、S線[/url] [url=http://www.myav.com.tw/market/showthread.php?s=&threadid=127614]綜合商品區[/url] [url=http://www.myav.com.tw/market/showthread.php?s=&threadid=20459395]In-akustik 德國敏力線[/url]

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
 樓主| 發表於 2017-8-11 13:15:13 | 顯示全部樓層
實際應用上自然是得因地制宜. 除chucky兄敘述說明的cabin gain (/pvg)外, boundary gain的因素也多少有些補充到, 加上空間畢竟不會是真正全封閉且能夠完全反映理論值, 因此期待追求極低頻者會從多顆超低音著手, 兼顧質與量.

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
 樓主| 發表於 2017-8-11 13:19:20 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 ups
[B]

不錯的建議!
-------------------------------------
在下的看法是、不知要完成這曲線若不靠EQ,不知還能用甚麼方式去完成?。 [/B]


雖說那是綜合趨勢圖,並非實際情況都搞這麼平滑 (via EQ)..

You need more subs. 團結力量大!

如果以單顆sub而言, 加上擺位受限的情況.. EQ不見得能帶你上天堂, 頂多就是避免下地獄

249

主題

3萬

回帖

220

積分

新手上路

上將

舊站積分
11603
舊站發表文章數
26283
發表於 2017-8-11 13:58:43 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 Ken Wu
[B]

雖說那是綜合趨勢圖,並非實際情況都搞這麼平滑 (via EQ)..

You need more subs. 團結力量大!

如果以單顆sub而言, 加上擺位受限的情況.. EQ不見得能帶你上天堂, 頂多就是避免下地獄 [/B]


這應該是實際情況圖,非趨勢圖。


\\You need more subs. 團結力量大!
重點是錢!

\\如果以單顆sub而言, 加上擺位受限的情況.. EQ不見得能帶你上天堂, 頂多就是避免下地獄 。

.......用EQ至少還在人間....還不用下地獄。
[url=http://www.myav.com.tw/market/showthread.php?s=&threadid=5991]進口超值--色差、同軸數位、S線[/url] [url=http://www.myav.com.tw/market/showthread.php?s=&threadid=127614]綜合商品區[/url] [url=http://www.myav.com.tw/market/showthread.php?s=&threadid=20459395]In-akustik 德國敏力線[/url]
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-18 19:18 , Processed in 0.117456 second(s), 43 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表