忘記密碼
 立即註冊
樓主: chucky7

美國網路直售喇叭和超低音的經營生態和使用觀點

[複製鏈接]

34

主題

1311

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Da Man

舊站積分
1718
舊站發表文章數
1326
 樓主| 發表於 2017-10-5 09:56:15 | 顯示全部樓層
以下是我在 avsforum.com 發的有關於6月網聚的最後 write up:

The following is my opinion after hearing and testing the 18" ported subs at various occasions. My ranking is very similar to Marc's. Basically, the products that cost more scored better.

1. JTR Cap 1400, 2015 version ( $2150 shipped ).
2. JTR Cap 118HT ( $1750 shipped ).
3. Rythmik FV18 ( $1700 shipped ).
4. PSA V1801 ( $1400 shipped ).

Rather than doing a full review of the 4 18" ported subs here, which I am not that capable of doing, I would use a Q&A format.

Q: Which one do you like the best?

A: Of course the 2015 JTR Cap 1400 (Mine! Mine! Mine!). It's at least $400 more expensive than the other subs. It has the least cons and the most output across almost all frequencies. Capable of producing the most TR and desirable port wind, and the least chuffing. it is just a step above the other 3. There is no question about it.

Q: Would you say any of the 4 subs sounded bad?

A: Of course not. If the best sounding sub received perfect score of 100, then the worst sounding sub would get a score of 85. Different, yes. Night and day, definitely no. We are comparing the top ID subs in the price range of $1400 to $2150 here. I can't imagine anyone would be unhappy if he has any of the 4 subs here.

Q: Which one would you say has the most bang for the buck?

A: In terms of overall performance per dollar, the 4 products are pretty close. Basically, you do get what you paid for. Strictly output per dollar, probably JTR Cap 1400.

Q: What's wrong with PSA V1801? Is it pretty close to JTR Cap 118HT?

A: There is nothing wrong with it. PSA V1801 did not have as high output down low relative to the other 3 because its cabinet is the smallest. A larger cabinet should improve its output down low. The port design is definitely not as good as the other 3 subs here and it is the most likely to chuff. Can it be improved? Maybe not at its cabinet size. Apparently PSA's design goal here is to put an 18" driver into the smallest ported cabinet with the lowest tuning frequency possible. The compromise is the lowest headroom down low. Because it is a 18" sub in a 15" cabinet, it is very popular. Now, if my budget is a hard $1400, or if my wife only allowed a small sub and I want an 18" one, I would gladly take PSA V1801 and be very happy. Its performance is definitely not close to JTR Cap 118HT but it is $350 cheaper!

Q: Your table shows that the Rythmik FV18 has more output than the JTR Cap 118HT, and Marc seems to like how it sounds the best. How come it did not fare better than the JTR Cap 118HT?

A: Good question. The SQ among them are close enough that the other facets, such as usability, TR, expectation became the determinant for the final ranking. The Speakerpower amp on the JTR Cap 118HT is just more user-friendly and idiot-proof. The Rythmik amp has too many knobs and switches. If my newbie friend got a Rythmik FV18, I would be worried if he messed it up. Yes, Marc believed the Rythmik FV18 sounded the best. Yes, it does sound very much like a sealed sub. But at what cost? The FV18 has the least TR, by far. It is also the largest sub among the four! If I wanted to get a ported sub that sounds like a sealed sub, I might as well just get a sealed sub that is much smaller and cheaper! If a buyer is expecting the grunt and brute force from a ported sub, he might be yearning for more. Therefore, I would choose the other 3 subs if my goal is to rock my neighbor's house. However, if I am used to how sealed subs sound, the Rythmik FV18 would be the bee's knee because it is not too far from my comfort zone. Unfortunately, the Rythmik FV18 was out of commission on the day of GTG. Otherwise, many attendees would have liked what they heard. The Rythmik FV18 has a steeper learning curve than the other 3 here. However, once dialed in, it will satisfy even the most discerning ears!

Q: JTR Captivators have been rated the best for movies among many previous GTGs. Can you shed some light here?

A: It's true. It's true. The CEA 2010 numbers can only tell you so much. JTR's subs are much much more than those CEA 2010 numbers. Jeff really has figured out so far the best combination of output, extension, SQ, TR, and desirable port wind but not obnoxious chuffing here. The Captivators do provide a very compelling ULF package. The improved damping of 2017 Captivator cabinets work wonderfully. I look forward to listening to Marc's JTR Cap 2400ULF. I only wish I could audition a sealed JTR Captivator.

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
發表於 2017-10-5 10:06:16 | 顯示全部樓層
Chucky兄, 前幾天在Marc家的網聚為何迴響如此少? 比起上回的客廳開放空間, 更期待這場的分享說..

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
發表於 2017-10-5 10:12:46 | 顯示全部樓層
最近在Power sound audio的討論裡出現想將那顆四18"單體s7201 退回的心路歷程(這位跟前陣子提出要退回的那位不同人).

即使有很低頗平的頻響表現與大音壓能力, 用家的說法是因為可能危及健康與房子結構才準備忍痛退回, 但在字裡行間總有音量開太大以致家庭關係不諧遭驅逐出境的感覺..

34

主題

1311

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Da Man

舊站積分
1718
舊站發表文章數
1326
 樓主| 發表於 2017-10-5 11:31:23 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 Ken Wu
[B]最近在Power sound audio的討論裡出現想將那顆四18"單體s7201 退回的心路歷程(這位跟前陣子提出要退回的那位不同人).

即使有很低頗平的頻響表現與大音壓能力, 用家的說法是因為可能危及健康與房子結構才準備忍痛退回, 但在字裡行間總有音量開太大以致家庭關係不諧遭驅逐出境的感覺.. [/B]

是同一人. 就是下面這位網友:

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
發表於 2017-10-5 11:47:31 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 chucky7
[B]

是同一人. 就是下面這位網友:
[/B]



Chucky兄前陣子不是才說圖中這位已獲準可留下S7210? 沒細看所以以為是另一人 Orz

感謝更正!

http://www.avsforum.com/forum/11 ... 8.html#post54858500
半個月前的文:
Haven't really listened much at all yet though, a quick demo for about five minutes and the missus said it has to go, she came running down from upstairs.

249

主題

3萬

回帖

220

積分

新手上路

上將

舊站積分
11603
舊站發表文章數
26283
發表於 2017-10-5 11:49:34 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 chucky7
[B]

是同一人. 就是下面這位網友:
[/B]


那這樣之前用兩隻 V1800 應該也會有音量開太大的問題....我想應該還有其他問題沒處理好!
[url=http://www.myav.com.tw/market/showthread.php?s=&threadid=5991]進口超值--色差、同軸數位、S線[/url] [url=http://www.myav.com.tw/market/showthread.php?s=&threadid=127614]綜合商品區[/url] [url=http://www.myav.com.tw/market/showthread.php?s=&threadid=20459395]In-akustik 德國敏力線[/url]

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
發表於 2017-10-5 12:06:50 | 顯示全部樓層
PSA   的Tom V 今天的這則貼文頗有意思, 室內的測量的變數與解讀還是得小心啊.

引用如下:

My very first post on an audio forum(IIRC) was to Tom Nousaine back on the old stereo review ubb site(1995?). I believe I titled it something like "why no standards in subwoofer review/measurements". I went on to compare Hirch's review of the bagend infra 18 to several other reviews published in the same magazine...a couple authored by Tom Nousaine.

I remember the Infra review just gushing superlatives AND offering a few very basic output measurements. I had no idea what the measurements meant I just assumed it must be extremely powerful because of all the subjective/poetic gushing. So I drove 4-5 hours EACH WAY to the nearest dealer...spent $1100(1995 money)...and was pretty disappointed.

So I began looking further into things. Why did this 18" subwoofer perform "meh" when these numbers seem so good----or at least the reviewer portrayed them in that manner.

Tom Nousaine, Michael Riggs, and even Don Keele(iirc) all spent time answering my inquires. Before too long I bumped into one "sjmarcy" on the same forum. We bonded over things like the best way to weld in a cage, pinion angles, stripped m-22 rockcrusher gears....you know...FUN stuff. Anyway, sjmarcy walked me through my first few sub design/builds. We even came up with an affordable way to measure. Believe me, back then, there were no $75 umik kits or "free" RTA programs. I lost count of how many subs I designed, built, tested, redesigned, rebuilt, retested over the next few years.

During that time I realized how variables can affect the measurements. I wasted more hours than I care to admit because I didn't account for a variable. And these variables that would skew entire test sessions, they are often "poo poo ed" away with a virtual hand gesture when someone introduce's them in a discussion.

Anyway----point being.

Sometimes we see two sets of numbers and automatically assume we can make a quick comparison. After all, its just bass...no need to make it so complex!..

But, unfortunately, that's not always the case.
I've spent I don't know how many hours of my life in the past year explaining the difference between 1m/peak and 2m/rms for example.

Outside to in room, here's a couple things to keep in mind.

1)Boundary gain. You're getting +6 in theory for every boundary. With bass, in/near a corner is +12 for the two walls and another 2-3 for the ceiling. (let's simplify this example and leave the floor out of it). Even with loses(the walls wont be concrete.....let's say 10dB total.

2)PVE(room gain). Varies with room size, room construction, openings to other areas of the home, AND frequency. When you see the old formula "12dB gain starting at 565...blah, blah" just ignore that... For a typical room, just figure 12-14dB in the 6-10hz range. That's a BIG approximation but this is just a basic example.

There's other factors involved too, distance between the sub and the mic for example. But the two above dominant the differences involved. So that's 22-24dB of difference. Let that sink in. 24dB. That is like adding 15(?) more S7201 subwoofers. In other words. it would take 16 S7201 subs, measured outside, to equal the output of ONE S7201 measured inside(given the above approximations) in the 5-10hz range.

The good news is we do offer substantial discounts for someone purchasing 16 S7201 for their backyard polo field/home theaters.

Tom V.
Power Sound Audio

34

主題

1311

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Da Man

舊站積分
1718
舊站發表文章數
1326
 樓主| 發表於 2017-10-5 12:36:17 | 顯示全部樓層
很多傳統的美國人就是這樣呀...

買的時後都不多想一想, 到手之後才反悔.

像是 Marc, 團聚前才買的兩台 Seaton 的反射式重低音 MFW-SS Turbo. 現在又要換成 JTR Captivator 2400 ULF. 今年才買的 65 吋 LG OLED, 後來又要換成 售價 1萬美金的 75 吋的 LG OLED. 是我勸他才打消念頭的.   

這位老先生因為重低音有害健康, 現在又想把 S7201 換成 兩台 PSA V3601了. Orz...

Tom 今天就說了. 一般的狀況下, PSA 是不允許 trade in 的客人退貨的. 因為這樣等於客人拿 trade in 的產品換現金了.

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
發表於 2017-10-5 12:49:02 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 chucky7
[B]很多傳統的美國人就是這樣呀...

買的時後都不多想一想, 到手之後才反悔.

像是 Marc, 團聚前才買的兩台 Seaton 的反射式重低音 MFW-SS Turbo. 現在又要換成 JTR Captivator 2400 ULF. 今年才買的 65 吋 LG OLED, 後來又要換成 售價 1萬美金的 75 吋的 LG OLED. 是我勸他才打消念頭的.   

這位老先生因為重低音有害健康, 現在又想把 S7201 換成 兩台 PSA V3601了. Orz...

Tom 今天就說了. 一般的狀況下, PSA 是不允許 trade in 的客人退貨的. 因為這樣等於客人拿 trade in 的產品換現金了. [/B]


據稱他的空間即使是單顆sub, 也沒有頻響差的座位耶. 這實在很難得..

但太搖太震也只好將這尊大佛送出門. 一顆音壓能力太高的超低音原來也有無用武之地的時候[]

只是我總感覺應該原因不止如此..他大可以在家人不在時才開自己喜歡的量, 其他時候就收斂點就好啦?

34

主題

1311

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Da Man

舊站積分
1718
舊站發表文章數
1326
 樓主| 發表於 2017-10-5 13:00:38 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 Ken Wu
[B]

據稱他的空間即使是單顆sub, 也沒有頻響差的座位耶. 這實在很難得..

但太搖太震也只好將這尊大佛送出門. 一顆音壓能力太高的超低音原來也有無用武之地的時候[]

只是我總感覺應該原因不止如此..他大可以在家人不在時才開自己喜歡的量, 其他時候就收斂點就好啦? [/B]

我也是這樣想啊... 更尤其這位網友說他家蓋得很堅固, 是鋼筋水泥建造. 就算有人在他家門口開槍, 他在樓下視聽室也聽不到. 這樣看電影吵不到鄰居. 好啊~~~

美國很多網友家裡女主人講話很大聲的...



我看到很多男主人都只能自主男人窩的擺設. 其他都歸女主人管. 所以才有 WAF. [xx(]

下面就是他十幾個位置測出來的頻響圖. 所以我才說他的空間可謂得天獨厚, 本來的頻響就很平坦了.
  


老先生今天有量 PSA S7201 的 極限音壓了:

您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-20 04:43 , Processed in 0.185187 second(s), 41 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表