忘記密碼
 立即註冊
樓主: asus.V.S.acer

3坪大的空間有辨成出現20HZ或以下的極低頻嗎?

[複製鏈接]

0

主題

100

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

一星級會員

舊站積分
0
舊站發表文章數
90
發表於 2009-3-30 22:57:35 | 顯示全部樓層
棄子?
沒父親, 難怪變成這樣.....

原發表者是 ashinn
[B]分身用來行善就好,要製造紛亂卻不敢用原來的帳號見人還真是沒格調!比棄子還不如! [/B]

148

主題

3757

回帖

240

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
4615
舊站發表文章數
3354
發表於 2009-3-30 23:06:42 | 顯示全部樓層
不懂下棋又不識近籐光是何許人也?

勸君莫造口業!報應落在自己身上便罷!若殃及親人則親人何辜?
原發表者是 soundhome2009
[B]棄子?
沒父親, 難怪變成這樣.....

[/B]
音樂性是用音響性釀的酒;電影的現場不在電影院,音樂的現場不在音樂廳

37

主題

3360

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
76
舊站發表文章數
2855
發表於 2009-3-31 01:02:14 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 yo4kf7ox6
[B]ashinn前輩如果瞭解的話,
請大方與網兄們分享~
不須要處處留一手~~~~~
相信網兄們都會很樂意聽您的分享!
Kazama輩如何誤導方向?請您解釋一下讓大家瞭解..
[/B]

小許兄,先前ashinn兄所提及AVTalk英國網站的MX350測試以及Bass EQ
檔位選擇的看法,當年曾有MyAV高手網兄至AVTalk引用原廠手冊文字詢問
戶外測試時是否應該選用無響檔位(EXTENDED)才對,該網站也承認他們進行
戶外測試時因為沒有原廠手冊供參考而誤以為THX檔位頻響適用於戶外測試。

這已是2005年的往事,相關討論若小許兄有興趣請參考:
http://www.avtalk.co.uk//showthread.php?t=12080&page=3

英國網站AVTalk測試人員在閱讀了MyAV網兄所提供原廠手冊關於Bass EQ
設定的英文章節後,同意了MyAV網兄的看法。

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
28-11-2005, 09:24 AM  
Ken Wu     Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Taiwan
Posts: 4  

Re: M&K: MX350 MkII

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Quote from MX350 user maunal(pdf file):

page 8:

OPERATION OF THE BASS EQ SWITCH

This switch gives you two choices of subwoofer response in the deep bass region below about 30

Hz. For the flattest in-room frequency response, set the switch to the THX position. This position

also gives you the maximum output level, dynamic range, and headroom.

The ANECHOIC position produces flat anechoic response, which actually results in a rising

output below about 30 Hz. Its in-room output will increase as you go lower in frequency, due to a

phenomenon known as room gain. Room gain means that the bass produced by a subwoofer in a

room actually increases in amplitude at frequencies below 30 Hz, at a rate of about 12 dB per octave.

Our own measurements in a very wide variety of actual rooms have clearly documented this fact.

In the majority of cases, we strongly recommend using the THX position. This will give you the

most accurate (flat) response, along with maximum output and dynamic range. The EXTENDED
position is provided for measurements
and for those who might prefer that acoustic characteristic.



According to the manual, shouldn't the BASS EQ switch for outdoor testing(without room gain) of MX350 set on EXTENDED?


Or did I miss something here  


  #22    28-11-2005, 12:02 PM  
Godfather  
Mega Talker   Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Edinburgh
Posts: 1,321  

Re: M&K: MX350 MkII

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

You're right Ken. Well done for spotting that.
We didn't have the manual on hand and were under the impression that the 'THX' setting would give the flattest anechoic response. This explains the surprisingly steep roll-off.


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

148

主題

3757

回帖

240

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
4615
舊站發表文章數
3354
發表於 2009-3-31 01:41:17 | 顯示全部樓層
可否麻煩 kazama 兄翻譯原廠說明書資料:(MX-5000THX MkII / MX-350THX)

OPERATION OF THE "BASS EQ" SWITCH:
This switch gives you two choices of subwoofer response in the deep bass region below about 30
Hz. For the flattest in-room frequency response, set the switch to the "THX" position. This position
also gives you the maximum output level, dynamic range, and headroom.
The "ANECHOIC" position produces flat anechoic response, which actually results in a rising
output below about 30 Hz. Its in-room output will increase as you go lower in frequency, due to a
phenomenon known as room gain. Room gain means that the bass produced by a subwoofer in a
room actually increases in amplitude at frequencies below 30 Hz, at a rate of about 12 dB per octave.
Our own measurements in a very wide variety of actual rooms have clearly documented this fact.
In the majority of cases, we strongly recommend using the "THX" position. This will give you the
most accurate (flat) response, along with maximum output and dynamic range. The "EXTENDED"
position is provided for measurements and for those who might prefer that acoustic characteristic.
音樂性是用音響性釀的酒;電影的現場不在電影院,音樂的現場不在音樂廳

0

主題

100

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

一星級會員

舊站積分
0
舊站發表文章數
90
發表於 2009-3-31 08:47:05 | 顯示全部樓層
高級外省人的用詞果然是比普通台灣人深奧....... [}]
普通台灣人看不懂, 正常.

原發表者是 yo4kf7ox6
[B]寫白話一點~~

況攏某!

[/B]

21

主題

1431

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
33
舊站發表文章數
1412
發表於 2009-3-31 11:11:46 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 ashinn
以消費者的立場,正因為超低音是要在自家空間中使用,更要對同一顆超低音
在三坪與三十坪空間中,超低音同樣播放20Hz,感受卻不盡相同的現象有所
認知,會有助於選擇適合自家空間的產品。

超低音放在操場上,與放在三坪及三十坪密閉水泥磚牆空間中,單體都發出
20Hz是一回事,而在上述三個不同的環境中對低頻的感受,又是另一回事。

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

老實說小弟對您是從非常尊敬到有點反感!
AVTalk 裡 MX-350 在戶外測試的數據不好看,切到無迴響那個檔位只會更難看!
好比用 EQ 把不夠的頻響往上拉,動態就被壓縮了,說明書您仔細看過了嗎?
不光是動態裕度變小,單體衝程常推拉到極限附近,失真、暫態特性都會變差!

Bass EQ(THX 和 ANECHOIC 檔位)不就好比 Room COMP 的功能...... [/B]



我有點不瞭解想請教一下...
kazama兄所發表的這一篇論述....錯誤地方在那??..為何會誤導大家..
這只是一般論而以...很明確的陳述一些事實結果...
請您只針對kazama兄所發的的這篇文章做出指正即可..

至於MX350在戶外的測試....五年前所討論的文章...若要再探討應該另擇主題才是..
直接這樣牽扯感覺有點牛頭不對馬嘴~~

21

主題

1431

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
33
舊站發表文章數
1412
發表於 2009-3-31 11:14:11 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 ashinn
[B]可否麻煩 kazama 兄翻譯原廠說明書資料:(MX-5000THX MkII / MX-350THX)

OPERATION OF THE "BASS EQ" SWITCH:
This switch gives you two choices of subwoofer response in the deep bass region below about 30
Hz. For the flattest in-room frequency response, set the switch to the "THX" position. This position
also gives you the maximum output level, dynamic range, and headroom.
The "ANECHOIC" position produces flat anechoic response, which actually results in a rising
output below about 30 Hz. Its in-room output will increase as you go lower in frequency, due to a
phenomenon known as room gain. Room gain means that the bass produced by a subwoofer in a
room actually increases in amplitude at frequencies below 30 Hz, at a rate of about 12 dB per octave.
Our own measurements in a very wide variety of actual rooms have clearly documented this fact.
In the majority of cases, we strongly recommend using the "THX" position. This will give you the
most accurate (flat) response, along with maximum output and dynamic range. The "EXTENDED"
position is provided for measurements and for those who might prefer that acoustic characteristic. [/B]



另~~此篇.....我代kazama兄回答一下...
kazama兄看了說明書,認為戶外測試要選EXTENDEDKen Wu兄看了說明書也認為戶外測試要選EXTENDED英國網站測試人員看了說明書相關英文,同意Ken Wu兄看法
請問ashinn兄看了英文說明書,戶外測試應要選?

6

主題

912

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

三星級會員

舊站積分
275
舊站發表文章數
774
發表於 2009-3-31 12:03:26 | 顯示全部樓層
請你自己先翻譯這一句話吧:

[B]The "EXTENDED" position is provided for measurements and for those who might prefer that acoustic characteristic.[/COLOR][/B]

為何DD在規範錄LFE音軌時要降10dB?  降音壓的結果本來就能獲得較大的動態, 餘裕與降低失真,
"Extended"比"THX"在30Hz以下音壓大延伸低, 本來動態餘裕就是會比較差.

從以下這段文字, 我實在看不出到底原廠是降音壓還是昇音壓來處理這問題,
我只看到"THX"有較正確(平)的in-room頻響, "Extended"則比"THX"在30Hz以下昇起,
因此in-room頻響較"THX"更為延伸,

所以"THX"有較佳的動態與餘裕等, 原廠強烈建議使用,
"Extended"則作為量測或重視音響特性者使用, 我想就是在說像你這樣的人吧.


原發表者是 ashinn
[B]可否麻煩 kazama 兄翻譯原廠說明書資料:(MX-5000THX MkII / MX-350THX)

OPERATION OF THE "BASS EQ" SWITCH:
This switch gives you two choices of subwoofer response in the deep bass region below about 30
Hz. For the flattest in-room frequency response, set the switch to the "THX" position. This position
also gives you the maximum output level, dynamic range, and headroom.
The "ANECHOIC" position produces flat anechoic response, which actually results in a rising
output below about 30 Hz. Its in-room output will increase as you go lower in frequency, due to a
phenomenon known as room gain. Room gain means that the bass produced by a subwoofer in a
room actually increases in amplitude at frequencies below 30 Hz, at a rate of about 12 dB per octave.
Our own measurements in a very wide variety of actual rooms have clearly documented this fact.
In the majority of cases, we strongly recommend using the "THX" position. This will give you the
most accurate (flat) response, along with maximum output and dynamic range. The "EXTENDED"
position is provided for measurements and for those who might prefer that acoustic characteristic. [/B]
**不在追求眼見的事實   而為獲得心中認為的真**

148

主題

3757

回帖

240

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
4615
舊站發表文章數
3354
發表於 2009-3-31 14:55:38 | 顯示全部樓層
我這種人就是因為有仔細看原廠說明書,
過去用 MX-5000 就用 THX 檔,kazama 先前給別的用家錯誤的建議時是誰多事指正?

您、kazama 兄、AVTalk 有把握 EXTENDED position= EQ Off 嗎?
就算 EXTENDED position= EQ Off,測量結果除了 30Hz 以下的頻響拉昇外,
請不同於我這樣的人的您判斷一下,其他測量數據會比較好嗎?還是 MX-350 「因誤得福」?

原發表者是 Nigel
[B]請你自己先翻譯這一句話吧:

[B]The "EXTENDED" position is provided for measurements and for those who might prefer that acoustic characteristic.[/COLOR][/B]

為何DD在規範錄LFE音軌時要降10dB?  降音壓的結果本來就能獲得較大的動態, 餘裕與降低失真,
"Extended"比"THX"在30Hz以下音壓大延伸低, 本來動態餘裕就是會比較差.

從以下這段文字, 我實在看不出到底原廠是降音壓還是昇音壓來處理這問題,
我只看到"THX"有較正確(平)的in-room頻響, "Extended"則比"THX"在30Hz以下昇起,
因此in-room頻響較"THX"更為延伸,

所以"THX"有較佳的動態與餘裕等, 原廠強烈建議使用,
"Extended"則作為量測或重視音響特性者使用, 我想就是在說像你這樣的人吧.


[/B]
音樂性是用音響性釀的酒;電影的現場不在電影院,音樂的現場不在音樂廳

148

主題

3757

回帖

240

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
4615
舊站發表文章數
3354
發表於 2009-3-31 15:02:49 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 jehau
[B]
我有點不瞭解想請教一下...
kazama兄所發表的這一篇論述....錯誤地方在那??..為何會誤導大家..
這只是一般論而以...很明確的陳述一些事實結果...
請您只針對kazama兄所發的的這篇文章做出指正即可..

至於MX350在戶外的測試....五年前所討論的文章...若要再探討應該另擇主題才是..
直接這樣牽扯感覺有點牛頭不對馬嘴~~ [/B]

jehau 兄,
小弟要表達的是換另一個檔位後,測量數據會變好嗎?

『AVTalk 裡 MX-350 在戶外測試的數據不好看,切到無迴響那個檔位只會更難看!
好比用 EQ 把不夠的頻響往上拉,動態就被壓縮了...
不光是動態裕度變小,單體衝程常推拉到極限附近,失真、暫態特性都會變差!』
音樂性是用音響性釀的酒;電影的現場不在電影院,音樂的現場不在音樂廳
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-20 23:24 , Processed in 0.639084 second(s), 41 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表