新手上路
五星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 24833
- 舊站發表文章數
- 7074
|
樓主 |
發表於 2010-2-12 18:23:36
|
顯示全部樓層
Grammophon 的評論
KHATCHATURIAN. Spartacus—Ballet: Dance of the Shields; Adagio of Spartacus and Phrygia. Monte Carlo National Opera Orchestra conducted by Edouard van Remoortel. SHOSTAKOVICH. The Execution of Stepan Rasin, Op. 119. Siegfried Vogel (bass), Leipzig Radio Chorus, Leipzig Radio Symphony Orchestra conducted by Herbert Kegel. Philips Universo 6585 012 (L1-49).
Skostakoctch—burgazn companson:
Hanaa, Slovak PO, SlovAk (7/79) SUAST50958
Stepan Rasin is our old friend Stcnka Razin, of Glazunov symphonic poem renown, a seventeenth-century Volga pirate : but Shostakovich's cantata concerns itself only with the drama of his public execution in Moscow. The work was composed after Symphony No. 13, based on poems by Yevtoushenko, who also provided the libretto for this cantata. It is mostly Shostakovich in his extrovert vein, yet it is by no means lacking in telling touches.
Siegfried Vogel fills the solo role well, though one always thinks this of Russiantype male singers, simply because the very characteristic sound of their voices is so apt to the music. But forget that sound and one can realise here that basically the voice has no great range of colour. Still, he sings the part with the vitality it calls for and the sound is certainly agreeable. The chorus backs him up well. The recording is good but tends to dynamic extremes: that is to say, if you have the loud parts at a tolerable volume, then the orchestra is elsewhere unnaturally soft—at the adagio passage for chorus and orchestra after fig. 52, to mention an extreme instance.
Unfortunately, a copy of the rival bargain-priced version is not to hand: but when RL reviewed it, he also had the full-price HMV Melodiya recording under Kondrashin for comparison (HMV ASD2409, 7/69) and I understand that this is the only one to get the cantata complete on to one side. Both the cheaper records break in a fairly innocuous place but any break in a work of such dramatic continuity is a pity if it can be avoided. RL also complained that the Supraphon had no text or translation (and the latter is especially vital); and Philips too omit to provide this.
RL obviously enjoyed both the performances he heard, as I enjoyed this one, though I suspect that his ultimate preference was for the more expensive Kondrashin, both for performance and recording. But as so often, your choice is likely to depend on couplings. Kondrashin has the jolly Ninth Symphony: Slovak has the Symphony No. 2. The Khatchaturian dances on this present disc are lesser stuff. The "Dance of the Shields" is very much what you might expect from the composer of the famous "Sabre Dance", though the Adagio is very beautiful in its own conventional Russian ballet way. It has an unashamedly romantic tune which comes towards the end with 'all the stops out', sweeping strings that aim at making you swoon, followed by very soft and touching echoes of it on the violins. If you are in the mood, you should enjoy it, for of its kind it is first-class—but I must emphasise 'of its kind', for some listeners will hate it. (I should add that it is this Adagio which is used as the theme music for BBC-TV's Onedin Line.) T.H.
|
|