忘記密碼
 立即註冊
樓主: hsindao

VTA

[複製鏈接]

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2011-1-16 02:31:52 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 steinhsu
[B]
如果只說是C. Overhang was too long而讓A. Offset angle was too large置身度外,那是不公平的。
我要把它拉下水,一起負責。
...

可見現例的  offset angle偏頭角 beta太大,當然overhang也綁在一起,太大。

如果現在對了B點之後,只進一步調overhang, 不動offset, 是難<喬>好的。
請指正。 [/B]

Good, finally there is someone who can state a different viewpoint with reasoning.  

Your point was that both overhang and offset angle need to be adjusted, agreed.  I never intended to imply that the offset angle was correct.  

When aligning for a specific set of A, B null points, overhang trumps offset angle.  One needs to get the overhang right first before aligning the offset angle.  It is meaningless to discuss offset angle until one gets the overhang right in the real world alignment process.

When you run into the alignment situation as I posted, what is the next step to take?  The alignment can not be fixed by changing offset angle alone, overhang has to be adjusted.  When you wiggle the cartridge forward or backward, the original offset angle is disturbed.  It is after settling on the new overhang then you re-align the offset angle to make the cantilever parallel to the center line.


211

主題

2萬

回帖

150

積分

新手上路

燒膠級會員

舊站積分
9685
舊站發表文章數
21982
發表於 2011-1-16 10:28:12 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 hsindao
[B]
Good, finally there is someone who can state a different viewpoint with reasoning.  

Your point was that both overhang and offset angle need to be adjusted, agreed.  I never intended to imply that the offset angle was correct.  

When aligning for a specific set of A, B null points, overhang trumps offset angle.  One needs to get the overhang right first before aligning the offset angle.  It is meaningless to discuss offset angle until one gets the overhang right in the real world alignment process.

When you run into the alignment situation as I posted, what is the next step to take?  The alignment can not be fixed by changing offset angle alone, overhang has to be adjusted.  When you wiggle the cartridge forward or backward, the original offset angle is disturbed.  It is after settling on the new overhang then you re-align the offset angle to make the cantilever parallel to the center line.


[/B]




One needs to get the overhang right first before aligning the offset angle. It is meaningless to discuss offset angle until one gets the overhang right in the real world alignment process.


why?


我倒以為沒有一定的次序,

因為有效臂長又沒決定.

改變overhang ,offset 都會動到其他參數.

而且如能抓到正確的 offset angle,

才是真正選定的 null point 設定.
[url=http://www.myav.com.tw/bbs/showthread.php?s=&threadid=272190&perpage=12&pagenumber=290]LP 資料庫索引[/url] [url=https://www.facebook.com/%E4%BD%95%E6%B4%8B%E6%B4%8B%E7%9A%84%E9%9F%B3%E9%9F%BF%E5%AF%A6%E9%A9%97%E5%AE%A4-1147636695299945]何洋洋的音響實驗室[/url]

76

主題

1041

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
2461
舊站發表文章數
1116
發表於 2011-1-16 11:45:54 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 hojuiyang111
[B]



One needs to get the overhang right first before aligning the offset angle. It is meaningless to discuss offset angle until one gets the overhang right in the real world alignment process.


why?


我倒以為沒有一定的次序,

因為有效臂長又沒決定.

改變overhang ,offset 都會動到其他參數.

而且如能抓到正確的 offset angle,

才是真正選定的 null point 設定. [/B]


要是下圖的OS-OH(Offset-Overhang combination)是AB的正確目標值的話,另外兩個組合 OS+/OH+, OS-/OH-比較起來,A-B的走位大小如水平粗線。
一內縮,一外張。





我前年用slide rule手算、手畫 250 mm唱臂如下圖:



如果把 offset angle S  的變化 21.5 minus 20度,相當於 overhang H的變化 0.07 minus 0.06 來作調整難度的指標:
則 overhang h= 250*(0.07 - 0.06) = 2.5 mm 相當 beta 偏頭角 (21.5 - 20 )=1.5 度
  or
1.7 mm per 1 degree
您說 1.7 mm 難調還是 1度難調??

67

主題

1萬

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Witch Fly on the Tonearm

舊站積分
7022
舊站發表文章數
12209
發表於 2011-1-16 16:52:55 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 hojuiyang111
[B]



One needs to get the overhang right first before aligning the offset angle. It is meaningless to discuss offset angle until one gets the overhang right in the real world alignment process.


why?


我倒以為沒有一定的次序,

因為有效臂長又沒決定.

改變overhang ,offset 都會動到其他參數.

而且如能抓到正確的 offset angle,

才是真正選定的 null point 設定. [/B]


spindle center to pivot 最先設定

再來是overhang

offset angle是自然到位

如果硬要設定offset angle

我選擇設定offset line

[;)]
站在巨人的肩膀上 我們看得更遠

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2011-1-17 00:57:58 | 顯示全部樓層

浪子回頭



You likely have seen this distortion figure many times before.  Ever thought about how does it correlate to real world listening experiences?  Incidentally, do you know what kind of null points you are using?

For a long time I used  the free protractor  from Enjoy the Music.  It was easy to use and easy to get to the null points without having to rotate the protractor between A and B points.  Used it on Fr-64fx and Signet XK-35 tonearms with and DL-103, Ortofon X5-MC, and Shelter 501 II, I often had distortion at inner tracks no matter how careful I tried to align it.  I knew the null points were based on Lofgren formula but was too lazy to change it.  How bad can it be?  

A simple way to look at Lofgren formula is that it gives the smallest average distortion.  The bad part is distortion rises quickly near the end tracks.  What good is it to have distortion free music first 5/6 but really lousy during the last 1/6?  It is a bad objective.

Fed up with Lofgren, I tried the conservative Stevenson protractor.  Stevenson null points are used by many Japanese tonearm makers.  It sets the inner null point at the end of the track by paying the cost of higher distortion around 4/5 into each side.  The good part is that the maximum distortion is bounded, meaning that it does not go up endlessly like the other 2 methods.  That makes it more forgiving of less than perfect alignment.

The result?  I started hearing distortion 3/4 into each side on both tonearms.  Careful re-alignment did not help.  Time to try the one that I likely should have used in the first place, the Baerwald null points.  

Baerwalds' objective was simple, minimize the worst distortion.  Makes all the sense although making sure a good alignment takes some work.  And the result?  Audible distortion disappeared from most records, or at least not as obvious.  The chart did not lie, Baerwald really is audibly better.

Your mileage may differ.

76

主題

1041

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
2461
舊站發表文章數
1116
發表於 2011-1-17 13:21:51 | 顯示全部樓層

Re: 浪子回頭

原發表者是 hsindao
[B]

You likely have seen this distortion figure many times before.  Ever thought about how does it correlate to real world listening experiences?  Incidentally, do you know what kind of null points you are using?

For a long time I used  the free protractor  from Enjoy the Music.  It was easy to use and easy to get to the null points without having to rotate the protractor between A and B points.  Used it on Fr-64fx and Signet XK-35 tonearms with and DL-103, Ortofon X5-MC, and Shelter 501 II, I often had distortion at inner tracks no matter how careful I tried to align it.  I knew the null points were based on Lofgren formula but was too lazy to change it.  How bad can it be?  

A simple way to look at Lofgren formula is that it gives the smallest average distortion.  The bad part is distortion rises quickly near the end tracks.  What good is it to have distortion free music first 5/6 but really lousy during the last 1/6?  It is a bad objective.

Fed up with Lofgren, I tried the conservative Stevenson protractor.  Stevenson null points are used by many Japanese tonearm makers.  It sets the inner null point at the end of the track by paying the cost of higher distortion around 4/5 into each side.  The good part is that the maximum distortion is bounded, meaning that it does not go up endlessly like the other 2 methods.  That makes it more forgiving of less than perfect alignment.

The result?  I started hearing distortion 3/4 into each side on both tonearms.  Careful re-alignment did not help.  Time to try the one that I likely should have used in the first place, the Baerwald null points.  

Baerwalds' objective was simple, minimize the worst distortion.  Makes all the sense although making sure a good alignment takes some work.  And the result?  Audible distortion disappeared from most records, or at least not as obvious.  The chart did not lie, Baerwald really is audibly better.

Your mileage may differ.
[/B]

題目是VTA,希望各位容許再談HTV下去,"分享" 本人在下 不一樣的mileage。
1974-1984年CD崛起之前用Philips LP player附有一個治具,一舉解決 HTA, VTA.



說它相當 primitive 原始也可以,好用就是了。
2000初 LP is back重拾舊歡,買進的Thorens belt-drive player一樣是治具。
去年買進二手Yamaha GT-1000石磨子player,乾脆給唱頭殼,overhang 可以按標定的 50 mm線,前進後退,但是 offset angle固定不能調的。
幾年前上了網路世界,才知道 已經進化到有 A-B兩點。為了避免被時代淘汰,趕緊做功課,網路有圖必看,還追根究底,從零開始,自己計算。
上次貼的要是把塗色的tracking error取絕對值,向上翻轉,一樣會成<元寶>狀,但是tracking error不等同 distortion %因此有各家自成一說。




唱盤外緣線速度快,容許的tracking error大。








在下DIY長臂製作唱頭殼,需要選定offset angle, overhang,是設定內緣60 mm,外緣150 mm 的 tracking error/radius 誤差角度除於唱溝半徑,是相等的。也就是圖上綠色線,它的斜率相等的條件, tracking error 0.18 跟0.47度差很多的。


按在下的木耳、low-end器材,HTA影響聽覺不大,相對的 VTA影響聽覺很大,立竿見影,墊兩張唱片,就聽出來了。
可惜 VTA在下沒有分析的能力, 心有餘、力不足。

Jan 18 補充一點:
內外緣的 tracking error 0.18 跟0.47度雖然差很多,但是除以個別的 r/l 之後 distortion的指標是一樣的。
同理,中點最大的tracking error 0.27度, 要是一樣畫一條綠色線,它的斜率也差不多一樣。
意即 這最大的<3點共乘distortion>, 是 <試誤> trial-and-error之後找到的最佳<偏頭角、超距組合點>。當然是個人的 mileage。

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2011-1-19 23:33:36 | 顯示全部樓層
If you want a Baerwald protractor, go to   Vinylengine  and download the "Stupid Protractors".  Print it out, cut down the Baerwald portion, CAREFULLY put 2 pin holes at the A, B points, cut the enter hole with a small knife, and tape it on an LP that you longer want.  Now the protractor not only has a good suport, it is at the exact height as your LPs will be.



To use it, (a 5X magnifying glass will help a lot)

1. Rotate the protractor so the stylus will fall exactly on the A point (the outer null point).

2. Align the cartridge so the cantilever is parallel to the center line.

3. Move both protractor and tonearm so the stylus falls on the B point.

4. If the angle of the cantilever is like what was shown in the picture above, overhang is too long.  If the cantilever falls on the other side, overhang is too short.

5. Change overhang and repeat steps 1-3.

6. When you get the cantilever parallel to the center lines at both A, B points, tighten the screws enough so the cartridge does not move easily on the headshell but still allows slight rotation.

7. Go to "B" point and this is the time that you want to make sure that the cantilever is on the top of the center line.  You definitely will need a magnifying glass here.

8. Check the offset angle at the A point.  If it is fine, tighten the screws then re-check at the B point.  If it is not fine at the A point, you may need to go back and fine tune overhang.


Your last offset angle adjustment should always be done at the "B" point as it is the more critical one.

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2011-2-18 01:06:22 | 顯示全部樓層

A good vibration

This tread started about 2 years ago when I was trying to understand what this VTA/SRA was about.  In that period I experimented with VTA-on-the-fly to see how does it affec sound; what should one be listening for when looking for the optimum SRA; what is the SRA that makes most records sound good on tonearms that do not have VTA-on-the-fly capability, and what is the physics behind all of those.   

Follows are reviews of my current understanding of this subject.  They are my personal opinions and you are certainly welcome to raise counterpoints so we can advance understanding of this subject as a group.  However, I do expect you to say something meaningful and not just why this and why that.    This LP forum has a lot of  as-if-one-knew-something but never-really-say-anything type of chit chat.  If that is your preferred style, please do it somewhere else.

There will be long series of articles but let me state the bottom line first.  Changing VTA/SRA does make significant difference in sound.  We need to get SRA into the correct ballpark.  However, I think the final tweaking is not about getting the absolute correct SRA but about resonance control, about getting a good vibration from vinyl/cartridge/tonearm interface.   

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2011-2-18 01:08:57 | 顯示全部樓層

The above figure shows styli with 3 different SRA angles, with stylus-B to have the same SRA as the modulation angle.  We can observe a few things from that figure.

1.  SRA does affect how stylus pick up signals from the grooves.

Stylus-A can trace leading edges of the grooves precisely but less so on falling edges.
Stylus-B can trace both edges perfectly.
Stylus-C can trace falling edges precisely but less so on rising edges.

2. SRA affects high frequency resonance of the cantilever.

When dragged across the surface, all 3 styli will oscillate in addition to the groove signals they pick up.  Stylus-A will encounter most friction when tracing uphill due to its 「hooked」 needle.  After passing the top of the hills, that friction will suddenly be released and cause the cantilever to oscillate.   Styli B and C will encounter less friction than A and therefore less resonance, with B > C.     


Now, if we bring the angle of A and C to be very close to B, all three styli should be able to pick up signals from those grooves correctly.  However, there will still be slight difference in how they oscillate.  There will be more high frequency resonance in A than B or C.  I think this is the reason higher SRA will sound brighter than lower SRA.

(Next, the role of VTF)

151

主題

8413

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
24833
舊站發表文章數
7074
發表於 2011-2-18 13:00:09 | 顯示全部樓層
Theoretically mono record does not have vertical movement, so the graphics should be converted 90 degrees in mind to cover this caveat but I consider the whole reasoning is logical.

However, regarding to the vibration part, I tend to push myself to look at a broader picture recently. Translate that into this VTA discussion, I now turn the VTA knob quickly up and down across a larger range, say, 2-3mm to try to get the "correct height", not a very precise point but a somewhat arbitrary position. In this way, I wish that I can avoid getting the "sound I want" (idee fixe of our audiophile ears? Ha!), rather  the sound out of a better tracing.
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-19 08:45 , Processed in 0.100399 second(s), 41 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表