新手上路
四星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 3261
- 舊站發表文章數
- 1711
|
發表於 2010-6-5 04:25:18
|
顯示全部樓層
Even though the friction associated with playing a grooveless LP or an LD is different from a real LP, there are still value in doing that exercise.
--------------
1. It tells us the LOW BOND of what the anti-skating force (AF) should be.
With only the tip of the stylus touching a smooth surface, the friction, and thus resulting skating force, will be lower than the real thing. The AF setting that balances out the inner moving force will be the minimum setting requirement.
--------------------
2. It lets us observe how does the anti-skating mechanism work.
This article shows the following diagram of how does skating force change across the record surface assuming friction coefficient of 0.3.

Look at the pink line. The maximum value is 1.34 (100%) at the outer edge and the minimum value is 1.29 (96%) at about 2/3 from the edge. If I normalize the maximum value as 100%, we can see that there is only 4% variation.
Now let's look at THEORETICALLY how well do some common anti-skating mechanisms track the theoretical variations.
The weight and string of SME 3009 provide a constant AF. A simple and reasonable approach given that there is only 4% variation in theoretically value.
Graham 2.2 at the outer edge. About 22 degree down. Cos(22°) = 0.93.
Graham 2.2 at the inner edge. About flat. Cos(0°) = 1.0.
The torque that generates AF in the Graham 2.2 is proportional to the horizontal part, cos(), of the bar. Anti-skating in this case increases almost linearly from the edge (93%) to the center (100%), with about 7% changes.
FR-64fx at the outer edge. Manual suggests that the bar be at horizontal position. Max at 100%.
FR-64fx at the inner edge. Cos(45°) = 0.7.
The FR-64fx has the maximum AF at the edge and decreases almost linearly (drops faster near the inner side) to about 70% of the max force at the inner edge.
If we superimpose all those curves together, with blue line being SME, black line being Graham, and pink line being FR, we can easily see how those designs differ. Playing an LD is a way to observe that mechanism, like Kevin did earlier.
-------------
3. We can get a feeling of how do manufacturers calibrate their AF settings.
Have you ever wonder how those 1.0g, 1.5g, ... AF setting were calibrated? I set the AF to be the same as VTF on Graham, FR, and Signet, played an LD, and 2 of them would move slowly toward the outer edge, as one would have expected.
The FR-64fx, on the other hand, still moved toward the center rather quickly. With VTF of 2.0g, it took AF=2.8g just to counter the skating force in the outer 2/3 region. The 2.8g AF was not enough to counter the skating force within the inner 1/3 region.
It seems that Ikeda prefer low AF for some reason. The manual of Ikeda IT-407 suggests setting AF equal to 1/2 VTF. The AF of Ikeda designed tonearms also drops much faster toward the inner grooves than other designs. I wonder why.
|
|