忘記密碼
 立即註冊
樓主: chucky7

美國網路直售喇叭和超低音的經營生態和使用觀點

[複製鏈接]

34

主題

1311

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Da Man

舊站積分
1718
舊站發表文章數
1326
 樓主| 發表於 2017-11-11 22:45:19 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 ashinn
[B]後級的部分棒透了!不會影響 Subwoofer 輸出的風量音量,我給 100 分。 [8D][/B]

我 AVR 是只看 Costco 有在賣什麼便宜貨, 去挑個 500 美金左右的... [:I] [8)]

944

主題

1萬

回帖

50

積分

樂特音響

舊站積分
9655
舊站發表文章數
13910
發表於 2017-11-11 22:46:39 | 顯示全部樓層

34

主題

1311

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Da Man

舊站積分
1718
舊站發表文章數
1326
 樓主| 發表於 2017-11-11 22:59:05 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 leon88
[B]自己的經驗跟聽過的感覺,多顆並不一定會更震撼

75dB聆聽,一顆也是最高也是115dB 兩顆也還是115B聆聽 當然自訂125dB以上聆聽的就不在建議範圍內

頻響的完整當然就包含極低的補償,這是一顆低重音最難做到的地方

多顆聽起來的密度當然是更好的,但是互補跟互抵的狀況下,聽感通常不會比一顆來的更有體感,因為駐波效應降低了,頻響的平均值更好了,單一頻率的凸出感也降低了 [/B]

您說的 115dB 音壓目標, 若是一顆就可達到, 那是當然的.

但我看不少玩家第一顆因為預算或是知識不足買太小 (10坪大用一顆10 吋的... [xx(]) 後來第二顆買12吋的, 兩台一起用...

這個情況下, 多顆重低音其中一個目的就是為了取得更多音壓.

145

主題

2629

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
793
舊站發表文章數
2157
發表於 2017-11-11 23:35:20 | 顯示全部樓層
也是 有玩標準的 玩開心的 跟玩耳聾的 [] []

需求不一樣  KK還建議人家4顆疊在一起使用
[URL=http://www.myav.com.tw/bbs/showthread.php?s=&threadid=421175&perpage=12&pagenumber=1]時光鏡[/URL]

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
發表於 2017-11-12 02:17:29 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 leon88

自己的經驗跟聽過的感覺,多顆並不一定會更震撼

75dB聆聽,一顆也是最高也是115dB 兩顆也還是115B聆聽 當然自訂125dB以上聆聽的就不在建議範圍內

頻響的完整當然就包含極低的補償,這是一顆低重音最難做到的地方

多顆聽起來的密度當然是更好的,但是互補跟互抵的狀況下,聽感通常不會比一顆來的更有體感,因為駐波效應降低了,頻響的平均值更好了,單一頻率的凸出感也降低了

-------------------------------------
原發表者是 chucky7

您說的 115dB 音壓目標, 若是一顆就可達到, 那是當然的.

但我看不少玩家第一顆因為預算或是知識不足買太小 (10坪大用一顆10 吋的... ) 後來第二顆買12吋的, 兩台一起用...

這個情況下, 多顆重低音其中一個目的就是為了取得更多音壓.
[/B]


其實兩位所說的情況.. 以個案來說都可成立, 看空間與超低音性能,  還有設定"目標"如何.

簡單的說法:

如果空間不大, 某單顆超低音性能便可達目標, 那在量感上增加的效益就較小

如果空間大到某單顆超低音性能未達目標, 加第二顆確實會更有量感.

在假設的情況下, A:小空間, B:大空間
經過校正, 主觀聽感(包括量感, 均衡度, 低失真表現等綜合)可能會類似如此:

A 處 1 sub 85分, 2 subs 90, 4 subs 95
B 處 1 sub 60分, 2 subs 80, 4 subs 90

而純以量感主觀感受則可能會像:

A 處 1 sub 95分, 2 subs 100, 4 subs 100
B 處 1 sub 60分, 2 subs 75, 4 subs 90

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
發表於 2017-11-12 04:10:14 | 顯示全部樓層
From Rythmik thread HERE
關於JTR 開孔式超低音喜歡用的長扁方形開孔型式, 以前Tom V @PSA也質疑過, 現在Rythmik也提出他的看法, 提供參考:

Slot port.

Marc, I know you and some others have push me for slot port, but JTR measurement shows the slot port has higher "compression".
It is physics. If you look at the compression plots at Databass, a slot port at port tuning frequency loses about 1db per 5db increment starting from 90db.
So at 105db its output at port tuning frequency is already 3db lower than that at 90db and 105db is still 10db from the max output.
This is at the output range that "thermal" hasn't played a significant role, and it just gets worse at higher outputs.
But still 1db loss for every 5db output increase is quite significant, isn't it?


.. If you look at the compression plot of FV18, at the output of 105db, it only deviates 1db from the 90db FR, and at 100db, it is even lower at 0.3db.
The FR at 90db and 95db are practically identical and therefore very calibration friendly.
The higher compression at 110db and higher is because the sub is already close to its max amplifier output.

(FV15HP does have a bit more port noise, but that is because it can achieve higher output than other similar size/power ported subs.
I can reduce the port output using a super stiff spider on the driver. But that also limits the max outputs on low frequency band. So it is a design decision. )


...(續談slot port)
The loss of air flow is due to the contact surface where air flow meets the solid surface which produces a drag.
Slot port has the largest contact surface vs opening area ratio. But this is the least of my concern. To reduce drag, the surface condition is very important.
..

Lastly, the air in a slot port can flow off axis. It produces less coherent or less predictable air flow.
If we can do a simulation, we should add a pertubation to the flow and watch how fast it can recover. To fully investigate the dynamic behavior of slot ports vs round ports, that is what you need to do.
Running a 20hz steady sine wave does not study dynamic behavior. I am pretty sure this discussion won't end here. There will be chapter 2, 3 and so forth.
..

個人以為一般用家並不容易留意到這麼細的設計層面與性能妥協的部分, 如其所言, 那些都是設計取捨, 實用上還是看用家自己的目標,當然還有實際上場的表現囉.

148

主題

3757

回帖

240

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
4615
舊站發表文章數
3354
發表於 2017-11-12 07:00:08 | 顯示全部樓層
#1. 居家空間以 (THX) Reference Level 播放 "太大聲了",其理由、依據請看本串前文。

#2. 超低音和其他喇叭的相位配合調整,也請看本串前文。

#3. 關於多超低音喇叭

先要感謝 Ken 兄整理了許多重點,分享在前面的討論中。

Leon 兄也是玩 2 顆的實戰玩家,會那麼說應該有他的道理。

小弟跟 Leon 兄有看過 SVS 在台灣辦活動時玩 2 顆,也有幫同好玩 4 顆。

經驗中只有 "堆疊並列" 和 "在對稱的擺位上(如左右兩邊)有一致的響應",從 1 顆變 2 顆到變 4 顆才能有效獲得 6 -12dB 的音壓增量。

以平滑響應、減用等化、減輕多座位差異為目標的玩法,獲得的音壓增量跟理想狀態會有明顯差異。


◎ The Pros and Cons of Multiple Subwoofers ~https://hometheaterreview.com/the-pros-and-cons-of-multiple-subwoofers/

不同位置上的超低音喇叭有不同的響應峰谷,結合後的響應因為不同頻率的峰谷產生均化補償的作用,所以有更平滑的響應。

( 對立位置上的不同超低音,激勵的同頻駐波會產生抵消弱化的效果 )
... the reason four subs deliver flatter response is that some of the subs cancel out the other subs' response peaks and dips caused by room acoustics. Place a single subwoofer in a room, and it'll have huge peaks at some frequencies and huge dips at others. The frequency and magnitude of the peaks and dips vary tremendously depending on where you're sitting. Add another sub somewhere else in the room, and because of its different position, it will interact differently with your room's acoustics. It'll have peaks and dips at different frequencies, and thus will partially cancel the first sub's response errors. Add two more subs, and the response should get even smoother.

However, if you think about it, you might get the idea that some of the energy from those extra subs is spent cancelling out the first sub's errors instead of increasing the total output of the system. Several manufacturers I know have speculated about this, ...


目標是更多的音壓輸出,應先考慮將多個超低音喇叭堆疊或並排 (相當於變成 1 顆更大的超低音喇叭)...

( 看到國外堆疊並列使用的圖例,也不宜論斷是為求高音壓或誤解成避免梳狀濾波,若說是為了 15Hz 以下的表現也許更合理一點 )
... If you want more output from four subs, you could put, say, two subs each in the front corners of your room, stacked or side by side, instead of putting one sub in each corner.

But my experiment did allow me to come to one general conclusion: Adding more subs in different locations is likely to increase the average bass output of a system significantly, but not by the theoretical six dB with two subs and 12 dB with four subs. And depending on where you're sitting and what you're listening to, you might not hear any improvement at all.
音樂性是用音響性釀的酒;電影的現場不在電影院,音樂的現場不在音樂廳

34

主題

1311

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Da Man

舊站積分
1718
舊站發表文章數
1326
 樓主| 發表於 2017-11-12 09:20:42 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 Ken Wu
[B]

其實兩位所說的情況.. 以個案來說都可成立, 看空間與超低音性能,  還有設定"目標"如何.

簡單的說法:

如果空間不大, 某單顆超低音性能便可達目標, 那在量感上增加的效益就較小

如果空間大到某單顆超低音性能未達目標, 加第二顆確實會更有量感.

在假設的情況下, A:小空間, B:大空間
經過校正, 主觀聽感(包括量感, 均衡度, 低失真表現等綜合)可能會類似如此:

A 處 1 sub 85分, 2 subs 90, 4 subs 95
B 處 1 sub 60分, 2 subs 80, 4 subs 90

而純以量感主觀感受則可能會像:

A 處 1 sub 95分, 2 subs 100, 4 subs 100
B 處 1 sub 60分, 2 subs 75, 4 subs 90 [/B]

是的.

對我目前使用狀況而言 -- 在9 坪, 2420 立方英尺大的非密閉空間中使用 單18吋 1400 W 的重低音, 衝兩粒以上重低音, 最大的目地為 平滑響應, 減用等化, 減輕多座位差異, 只有一小部份為音壓增量. []

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
發表於 2017-11-12 11:45:25 | 顯示全部樓層
The Birth of Sound Field Management

關於多顆超低音的應用解決頻響問題, 前陣子在本串提到過 SFM, 看起來頗promising
..An optimization algorithm then chews away at the data and comes up with specifications for the signal processing necessary for the signals being delivered to each of the (usually) four subs.
Amplitude, delay and one parametric filter will be specified.
The goal is to minimize the bass variations among the specified seats so that equalization, if it is necessary, will be equally effective for all listeners. It works superbly.
My room is shown in Figure 13.18 and another in Figure 13.19. There are no bass booms. Kick drums are "tight", and it works for all five seats, some of which are in 「unconventional」 locations – it is a media/family room, not a dedicated theater, but with a 10 ft screen and seven identical loudspeakers it is mighty good.
Below is a summary illustration emphasizing the fact that although less power is delivered by the subwoofers, an average of about 10 dB higher sound level is achieved in the room. Some of the subs are loafing, and could be reduced in size and power. Remember, in any normal situation turning up the volume by 10 dB uses 10-times more power. The subs can be flexibly located, although there are preferred locations, and they need not be identical. This is truly room mode control, removing destructive cancellations and liberating more good bass for more listeners. There is no global equalization in the curves shown.


相關的後續討論串也頗值得參考: https://forums.audioholics.com/f ... om-acoustics.98230/
裡面提到些EQ的概念, Audyssey使用, manual parametric EQ的做法等等.
相關文檔: The Measurement and Calibration of Sound (pdf file from AES)
(市面上大量出現的自動等化產品該如何看待?
For decades it has been widely accepted that a steadystate
amplitude response measured with an omnidirectional
microphone at the listening location in a room is an important
indicator of how an audio system will sound. Such
measurements have come to be known as generic 「room
curves,」 or more specific 「house curves.」 That belief has a
long history in professional audio, and now it has penetrated
consumer audio with stand-alone products and receivers incorporating
automated measurement and equalization capabilities.
The implication is that by making in-situ measurements
and manipulating the input signal so that the room
curve matches a predetermined target shape, imperfections
in (unspecified) loudspeakers and (unspecified) rooms are
measured and repaired. It is an enticing marketing story.

...

有興趣可花時間看看. )



另外,
此處有本人簡釋

Sound Field Management is an active mode control scheme, requiring measurements, an optimization algorithm and signal processing in each subwoofer signal path. It is available only in Synthesis systems at the moment, although it will be coming to the SDP75 - what I am waiting for.

The passive multi-sub schemes work ONLY in rectangular rooms, and the subs must be identical. The latest data on this is in:
Welti, T.S. (2012). 「Optimal Configurations for Subwoofers in Rooms Considering Seat-to-Seat variation and Low-Frequency Efficiency」, Audio Eng. Soc. 133rd Convention, Preprint 8748. Go to www.harman.com/innovation to download color versions of the plots in this paper.
and in my new book. Long story short, four corners are optimum because this arrangement is the most efficient and it yields very good control of seat-to-seat variations. The mid-wall positions work too, but they are not efficient. The best seats are in the center portion of the room avoiding the nulls at the 25% lines from each wall



最近有網友詢問 F. Toole 相關SFM 獨立產品可能上市時機, 可惜他的答覆是"上頭"的評估是暫時還看不到商機, 因此暫時無積極推出成品的打算.

148

主題

3757

回帖

240

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
4615
舊站發表文章數
3354
發表於 2017-11-12 14:25:20 | 顯示全部樓層
#4. 使用等化器

認為全範圍的頻段都可以盡情的使用 EQ 拉平拉直的專家(?)和支持者們,建議把前一篇 Ken 兄分享的討論連結內容看過。

很早就有許多同好表示難以接受衛星聲道 EQ 後的聲音,真的不是隨便說說的啊!(全範圍的頻段使用 EQ 拉平拉直的,觀念和耳朵的鑑賞力有可能需要加強...)

相關的文章,包括讓小弟腦筋打結的 X 曲線:Validity of X-curve For Cinema Sound ~https://audiosciencereview.com/forum/index.php?threads/validity-of-x-curve-for-cinema-sound.204/


小弟之前的貼文:
把到 20kHz 這個大頻帶拆成幾個區帶來看,空間最低共振頻率以下、往上到施羅德頻率、再往上到 10kHz、10kHz 以上,拉 EQ 要考慮的重點不會ㄧ樣,有的頻帶甚至不應該拉。

杜比:為避免降低聲音重播的品質,盡可能只在低頻段使用 EQ。
Dolby 5.1-Channel Music Production Guidelines -  Room Equalization:

Equalization may be necessary when the linearity of the operational room response curve cannot be achieved by architectural means.

To avoid degrading the quality of reproduction, electrical equalization should be used carefully, and if possible, in the low-frequency range only.
音樂性是用音響性釀的酒;電影的現場不在電影院,音樂的現場不在音樂廳
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-19 15:33 , Processed in 0.128590 second(s), 41 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表