新手上路
五星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 3604
- 舊站發表文章數
- 5787
|
發表於 2017-11-14 03:35:45
|
顯示全部樓層
Dr. Toole's Room 照片請按(圖大, 在下方連結"其一"可見)前牆, 與 全貌
在下方連結的分享提供了他相關規劃的想法.
看起來還真是神人都免不了要面臨妥協[ ]
文長請進入觀看:
其一 (現況心得, 節錄引用於下方)
Here are some of his comments, which also touch on something else I』ve been harping on - that Room EQ above transition is a really bad idea, especially with truly accurate speakers like the Revels in his theater.
..
I make a direct attack on "room EQ" which I regard as a disease in our industry - except at low frequencies, of course.
There it can work for a single listener, unless one employs a multi-sub strategy to reduce seat-to-seat variations.
Without trustworthy anechoic data on the loudspeakers it is not possible to interpret a steady-state room curve, and without interpretation one has no idea of what is causing what is seen in the curves, and what remedial measures must be taken. EQ is very limited in what it can do and some of the most common problems in loudspeakers can only be corrected with a better loudspeaker.
Acoustic treatments..
As you know, above the transition frequency room treatment is much less of a factor if one starts with well designed loudspeakers.
I attach photos of my entertainment room illustrating that absolutely superb sound can be delivered in a room that does not look "technical". That was my goal many years ago.
..
The wall mounted inverted Salon2s are remarkably unobtrusive for such large speakers.
..
Gem2s provide surrounds that are perfect timbral matches. Two more will be installed at the +/- 60 deg locations.
It is as good as any sound I have ever experienced and it is in a room that looks more like an art gallery than a home theater. There is a 10 ft screen the rolls down for front projection.
Four subs are in a Sound Field Managed configuration so the bass is smooth and resonance free down to about 17 Hz.
No bass traps required. Elevation speakers are yet to be installed. A JBL Synthesis/Trinnov processor is planned for control.
As I now have time to listen more - TIDAL is wonderful! - I realize even more than before that the true weak link in audio is the recording.
I like comparing 10 versions of the same movement in a classical recording. They are horrendously variable in the sophistication of directional and spatial rendering and in timbre.
One still needs tone controls for serious listening, but the directional and spatial qualities are often impossible to fix. A neutral playback system is unforgiving of these defects.
..
In the old book I wrote a small section (18.2.6) on it, saying that there was no science behind the cinema and dubbing stage calibration process.
A film sound mixer read it, agreed, and managed to get SMPTE interested in investigating the status of film sound.
Long story short, they invited me to be involved, many measurements were done, the results were a mess - some immaculately calibrated facilities sounded significantly better if the calibration equalization was turned off.
Add to this the fact that the X-curve is the wrong target curve and it is easy to understand why going to a movie is not always a sonically rewarding experience.
Sometime soon there is hope that work will begin on a new standard. However the traditions and folklore propagated within the industry have lasting effects.
That, and the poor financial state of cinemas these days are not encouraging signs that change may happen.
My feedback from industry sources indicates that immersive audio is not taking off as the moneymakers had hoped - rather like 3D visuals.
Personally, I think a lot of it has to do with better - at least acceptable - home systems, and the scarcity of intelligent dialog and plots in many of the movies.
The current topic of internal discussion in SMPTE has to do with excessive loudness in many movies, which get turned down by cinema owners, with the regrettable loss in dialog intelligibility.
Another mess, driven by directors who want their movie to be the loudest on the block.
Compression is widespread - as is hearing loss among the mixers who aren't wise enough to wear musicians earplugs.
A good home theater is the place to be. I enjoy well recorded music concerts as much as movies. The multichannel sound tracks can be excellent - but not always.
====================
其二 (關於他的空間想法分享, 目標與妥協等) |
|