忘記密碼
 立即註冊
樓主: hsindao

VTA

[複製鏈接]

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2011-2-19 08:45:36 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 alc
[B]Theoretically mono record does not have vertical movement, so the graphics should be converted 90 degrees in mind to cover this caveat but I consider the whole reasoning is logical.

However, regarding to the vibration part, I tend to push myself to look at a broader picture recently. Translate that into this VTA discussion, I now turn the VTA knob quickly up and down across a larger range, say, 2-3mm to try to get the "correct height", not a very precise point but a somewhat arbitrary position. In this way, I wish that I can avoid getting the "sound I want" (idee fixe of our audiophile ears? Ha!), rather  the sound out of a better tracing.
[/B]

The drawing was for one side of the groove and the needle should be a blade that represent the side of a stylus.  It is just a simple picture to show the concept.

How do you determine that you have reached the "correct height"?  If it is not the sound you want, what was it?

We can discuss the "accurate" vs "sound I want"  issue later, maybe in "Can you hear what I hear?"[]  I had wanted to write about vocal music and thought of a title "Vocal scenes".  I also wanted a forum that I can bitch about some audiophile issues so the title evolved to "老宅男的GGYY", learned those interesting words from 髑髏頭.  That gives me the cover of saying anything that is not politically correct but it seems to limit to my own GGYY.  Then a Christmas song Do you hear what I hear?  pop up in my head that seems to be appropriate.  It applies to both software and hardware, and everyone can apply his audiophile arrogance to it, "Can your tin ear hear what my golden ear hear?"[}]

151

主題

8413

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
24833
舊站發表文章數
7074
發表於 2011-2-19 11:42:54 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 hsindao
[B]...
How do you determine that you have reached the "correct height"?  If it is not the sound you want, what was it?...
[/B]

Occasionally I found if I only turned that VTA knob a tiny bit, I still "found" a better point to listen to, but if I went through a longer range, that point proved to be just a fit for some specific aspects, I lost the big picture.

If we can agree that the flatness of a vinyl is so arbitrary and today's tone arm is so good in tracking through all these up and down curves and let us practically ignore these "unflatness", then the result of getting better sound by just tiny bits of turning of that VTA knob will not be the height changes but just the play of that imperfect VTA adjustment structure, the inherent play and resonance characteristics of it.

Basing on this hypothesis, I then as said, pushed myself to ignore the little changes, which if agreed with the above, would be the resonance part, not the VTA matching part. The resonance part to me, is more prone to personal preference, the VTA part then, is more to the "correct playing" part.

You're right that one can not judge what is better if there is no standard, and that standard should be quite personal too. But what I found is, personal as it would, can be minimized by A-B test in a broader scene.  When doing tiny adjustment, we tend to look at a few limited aspects such as reverb, highs extension, phase coherence etc., but if we are exposed to some bigger diferences such as the tone, dynamics, body of image, slam etc. things might be quite different. So I consider that although we all have our own likeliness, we still can differentiate what's good in a broader sense by adding more materials to the comparison.

Several concerts that I went these years were not good enough, per sound. If this is the fact of life that not most of the recordings can bring you the same excitement fits right into your preference, then why the records can? Even though the engineers can do their magics and the mics are in their best positions (I doubt...), they could not possibly have the same preference as you do. So there came another hypothesis, if one can get out of his records the sound he likes most of the time, there probably exists someone who can get out of what HE likes but quite different, most of the time. That, seems to be good examples of personal preference or one can say prejudice.

Cables are some examples too, if one likes one cable, he would likely to add one more into his system, then one more, and finally all of them or, he discovered that there is a characteristic sounding of this cable and starts switching. I am not exempted out of this scheme as you know that I use the same interconnects all the way through. There are many excused as can't find a better one with comparable price, good enough etc., fortunately, VTA adjustment doesn't cost a lot, either money or labor, but are we in the right track?

151

主題

8413

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
24833
舊站發表文章數
7074
發表於 2011-2-19 11:45:04 | 顯示全部樓層
I think I'm interrupting rather then joining, I'll wait for The Role of VTA, till then.

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2011-2-20 06:38:34 | 顯示全部樓層

VTF

Why VTF?  The simple answer is to limit movement of the cantilever through damping.  We want to achieve at least 2 goals:

1. Stylus stays in the groove.
2. Gross cantilever ringing is suppressed so we don』t hear distortion.

The damper will suppress high frequency cantilever movement more than low frequency.  How much additional damping we want to add so a 10K Hz harmonic distortion caused by a 5K signal can be suppressed without loosing a real 10K signal in the groove, for example, is a big grey area.  Manufacturers normally have a 0.2g - 0.4g recommended range likely due to results from test records.  It is a good starting point but not necessarily the best setting.  Besides, cartridges often sounded quite different within that recommended 0.2g VTF difference.

--With lower VTF, and thus less damping, the cantilever can move more freely therefore we hear better high frequency extension, more air, and more dynamic.  
--With higher VTF, the high frequency is suppressed so it gives a sense of better bass.   Air and dynamic suffer a bit.

Many people likely just pick a VTF and settle on it.  Too bad.  I think it is quite worthwhile spending an hour changing VTF from 0.2g below the recommended value up to the maximum recommended value just to know how does VTF affect the sound so one can use that knowledge to tune his/her system.

---

Back to SRA.  As was mentioned in the previous post, SRA affects the amount of ringing and the accuracy of tracing the grooves.  VTF affects the amount of damping on the cantilever movement.  SRA and VTF together control how the cantilever vibrates.

-- Increasing VTF, for example, increase damping, reduce SRA, and changes the relative position of the coil within the cartridge.  It changes 3 parameters although increased damping is the main factor.  When there is a very minor VTF change, it is mainly the damping is changed with the other 2 parameters are barely affected.

-- Lowering tonearm height, as what one would do to reduce VTA, will reduce SRA.  It changes only 1 parameter.

Even though cantilever behavior can be tuned by changing either VTF or SRA, the result will be slightly different.

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2011-2-20 06:57:57 | 顯示全部樓層

Super low VTF

Now let』s apply the above theory to super low VTF (SLVTF).  Since the cantilever is grossly under-dampened, we can expect the following behaviors from SLVTF setting.

1. In order to reduce ringing, the SRA needs to be on the low side, likely even lower than the groove modulation angle.
2. It will have excessive dynamic, likely larger than the real signal.
3. It will have lots of high frequency ringing, adding to the sense of very good high frequency extension with lots of air.
4. It is super sensitive to a little bit of damping or SRA changes.

I have never heard a system set up with SLVTF.  From what has been said,  the above descriptions seem to come close.

As for the claim of achieving absolute SRA matching by pushing small paper roll on the headshell, my take is that it is more about changing damping than changing SRA.

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2011-2-22 10:33:24 | 顯示全部樓層

SRA, what to listen for

What should we be listening for when setting SRA?  I think a simple answer is to get the best high frequency extension without going overboard.

How does SRA affect sound?  If SRA is perfect, we will get all the high HF details.  If SRA is lower than perfect, we will loose some HF information.  If SRA is higher than perfect, we will loose HF details but there will be more HF oscillation that eventually cause harsh sound.  When we move SRA from low to high or high to low, we can hear that transition.  SRA only affects the very high frequency part of the music and that is where we should be aiming for.

What about other qualities like big picture, soundstage resolution, stereo separation, dynamic or tonality that people were associating with SRA?     Like the big picture, we should look into the entire system for the main contributor for those qualities.  SRA is the icing on the cake, that gives the final touch to the sound.  Those audio attributes are not independent factors, they are all linked to HF extension in some way.

-- Good HF extension gives better pinpoint imaging and resolution of layered soundstaging.  I found that if I got the HF extension right, the soundstages were normally good also.  I don』t know if they were the best I could possibly get but definitely were good enough.

-- HF gives sense of more dynamic.  It gives percussion music that quick snap.

-- HF allows the harmonics of musical instruments to be properly reproduced.  It lets one hear the bloom around each instruments and the air around the orchestral music.   When a system sounded dry and shrill, it is often because it does not have good HF extension.

-- Good stereo separation normally is associated with good HF extension.   

I don』t know if getting the best HF extension is the best way to set SRA.  I have tried it in several systems and the results were satisfactory.  It is easy to listen for and can be used in systems that do not have soundstage.  It can be set at the turntable without returning to the sweetspot to listen for the soundstage.

17

主題

802

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

三星級會員

舊站積分
302
舊站發表文章數
522
發表於 2011-2-26 09:56:42 | 顯示全部樓層

Re: SRA, what to listen for

原發表者是 hsindao
[B]

.......

How does SRA affect sound?  If SRA is perfect, we will get all the high HF details.  If SRA is lower than perfect, we will loose some HF information.  If SRA is higher than perfect, we will loose HF details but there will be more HF oscillation that eventually cause harsh sound.  

........

[/B]


以您的系統來說,90°or92°VTA/SRA,那個聽來較harsh?

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2011-2-26 10:36:50 | 顯示全部樓層

Re: Re: SRA, what to listen for

原發表者是 LCL0401
[B]

以您的系統來說,90°or92°VTA/SRA,那個聽來較harsh? [/B]

I don't know what is the actual SRA angle on my system because I don't pay attention to it.  I set it up by listening to music.  Just took a quick look at 2 cartridges and they are all > 92 degree.

This all come back to alc's earlier comment, technically correct or personal preference.  I don't believe we will ever get to know what is the technically correct SRA for each recording so I go by my own preference, that is, it has to sound "musically correct".  

My definition of "musically correct" is that all instruments need to be tonally correct.  They should have their characteristic harmonic and bloom.  Orchestra should have the air around it.  Percussion instruments and pianos need to have the transient speed.  All those require full frequency extension without going overboard.  I don't know what really are in those recordings.  However, if we give those recording engineers some credit that they know what they are doing, I think making each instruments to sound like the real thing should not be too far from the truth.

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2011-2-26 11:14:32 | 顯示全部樓層
I just took a look at the 3rd cartridge, an Ortofon X5-MC, and it looks to be > 92 degree also.  I know I have tried X5-MC at 90 degree and I would say it sounded harsh at times at 90 degree but never at the current SRA.

I have struggled with X5-MC for a long time.  At whatever SRA angle I set, there are still many recordings sounding harsh.  It was only last year when I kept raising SRA and everything suddenly sounded wonderful after all those harmonics and air started appearing.  I hated that cartridges for 10 years and the solution was simply to raise SRA.

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2011-9-17 21:54:04 | 顯示全部樓層

抗滑

記得以前常有人提到抗滑不對容易造成唱針偏一邊.  在下面幾種情況下, 那一個容易造成唱針歪一邊?

1. 抗滑太輕.
2. 抗滑適中
3. 抗滑太重
4. 其他
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-19 08:43 , Processed in 0.101404 second(s), 41 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表