新手上路
四星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 297
- 舊站發表文章數
- 1517
|
發表於 2005-5-4 01:59:49
|
顯示全部樓層
Re: Re: Skill of the sound engineer is the deciding factor
The LFE was the problem since the author was reviewing Germenica and all 3 formats sounded similar, except for the LFE channel
full article is here
http://www.highfidelityreview.co ... reviewnumber=523387
and also check out this one, Roogs Benoit is a sound engineer that does encoding work with both systems. As are a few others in that thread.
can you post the link to that thread your pictures came from? I would like to read it.
原發表者是 ssword
[B]
1.請問為何只比較低頻, 而不比較全頻段(20~20KHz)?這個實驗還不夠完整
畢竟低頻是感覺, 中高頻才是傳達聲音表情與人耳靈敏度較高的部分
希望能看到更完整的實驗報告
2.實驗中似乎沒有提到DD和DTS的data rate?
3.沒辦法看到Germerica其他的review部分?
4.以下是mycai兄的實驗:
實驗一是比較DTS, DD與原LFE聲音波形的比對
實驗二~五是隨便抓段wav壓成dd和dts後,
再解出來任取一點(左聲道)和原始wav比對的結果
1. LFE channel的聲音比對, 可知DTS並沒有對LFE增益(但似乎有提早衰減)
紅色: 原音
綠色: DD 448kbps
藍色: DTS 1536kbps

2. Dolby Digital 448kbps

3. Dolby Digital 640kbps

*使用Sonic Foundry Soft Encode編碼與解碼
4.DTS 768kbps

5.DTS 1536kbps

*使用Surcode編碼, InterVideo Audio decoder解碼.
=======================================
實驗歸納:
1.dts編碼並不會造成低頻增益, 但DTS會較早衰減, 不知會否造成頻率銜接上的問題?(分頻點看來不要超過100Hz比較好)
2.看實驗2~5的matching情形, 還是dts滿檔和原波形最為接近, 且聲音可到達20KHz以上
3.DTS 768Kbps的matching程度比DD448Kbps好, 但DTS 768Kbps只能延伸到19KHz [/B] |
|