新手上路
四星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 1058
- 舊站發表文章數
- 1174
|
發表於 2013-9-28 11:59:04
|
顯示全部樓層
這裡有一段 SFB/3 vs. Quad ESL 57
SFB/3 vs. Quad ESL 57[/COLOR] [/SIZE]
In a blacked out listening session, with Sugden C51/P51 pre/power combi, bass performance immediately became the distinguishing factor. The slam, transient immediacy and control of the SFB/3 was frightening! I know the ESL 57 can do dynamic extremes well especially in stacked pairs but it is different. The ESL 57 moves air and breathes the stroke of a bow on a cello or a violin, the SFB/3 extends the physical feel of the instrument - the wood, the sinuses of the bow, the rasp and grip. The SFB/3 sounded faster than a single ESL 57 but not as imposing or holographic as stacked ESL 57s.
The SFB/3』s soundstage enables the listener to measure the relative positions of performers from the listener, to be aware of the distance to the source of the sound. The ESL 57, instead, projects the performance so that the listener is with the players. This is delightful but confusing in reference to how we experience the sound in a live performance, and it is here that the SFB/3 excels - especially on female vocals and violin. There were no digital artifacts to remind you that this was Hi Fi, just soaring emotional crescendos - a vastness as big as a cathedral if demanded. As a performer moved so the SFB/3 would not be shaken off; it always had more to give seamlessly across the sound. Also, maximum/realistic sound levels came more alive with the SFB/3s. If the Quad ESL 57 is a fragile enigma, the SFB/3 is solid, dependable and has a unquestionable 'presence' and control over musical reproduction.
SFB/3 vs. Klipsch[/COLOR] [/SIZE]
In the 50s and 60s, the SFB/3 was usually paired with QUAD IIs producing 15 watts. The 60 watts on call from the Audio Research D70 (circa 1984) was a chance to hear the full unrestrained-by-amp sound of the SFB/3 in comparison to its creators muse, the mighty 104 dB sensitive Klipschorn (1980 model)!
Listening first to the Klipschorns reminded me of what this business is all about! Being there! Whether in the studio or stadium, the music flowed rising and falling like a stormy ocean, carrying the magnitude of emotional, transient pieces of music as an encounter, an experience. It was obviously here that the SFB/3 met its match. The SFB/3 could not shift the air in the room in the same way as the Klipschorns did, in a sense of unforced authority of colossal grandeur. The SFB/3s were also more selective in terms of the music: e.g. Led Zeppelin was really meant for the ARC/Klipschorn system. In comparison, the response coming from the SFB/3s even at a slightly higher wattage was rather polite.
With respect to the delicate midrange tonalities, the speakers were closer in nature, both revealing and transitionally smooth. Remember that the SFB/3 by nature was a midrange specific design with upper bass accuracy prevailing over an attempt to produce deep bass. Vocals to my mind did have a more 'living' presence from the Klipschorns but nuances of various drum sounds - tabla, tom-tom, etc. - sounded more identifiable from the SFB/3s.
In the frequency extremes of the treble both speakers were right but different. The SFB/3』s Super 3 tweeter, a past master of control and naturalness, never became harsh or splashy. The horn loaded tweeter in the Klipsch was not incorrect either being balanced in its incisiveness by the greater extension in the bass.
In conclusion, the SFB/3s - Briggs statement speakers in the pantheon of greats - are honest and impressive speakers. They do not totally disappear as the Quads can do given the right circumstance. They might not be as transparent as the ELS 57s, nor emulate the sound of the concert like the Klipschorns do, but they do many things well, very well. They can convey what it feels like to 「be there」 without resorting to 「how」 it feels like with a big box! Just shut your eyes and be amazed at Briggs' vision of what moving coils can achieve.
參考網址
我英文不好,大概也不太知道在說什麼?!
<img src="http://imageshack.us/a/img32/4275/ifav.jpg" width="640" height="362" />
↑↑↑
另外 一型號 wharfedale aeredale
aeredale ,他是被動三分音架構,與SFB3不同
使用單體,接改為長衝程;故璇邊"非"羊毛懸邊
據資深玩家說明:
wharfedale aeredale 單體很多,也有人找不到SFB3配置單體,改而用aeredale單體取代
那這樣可不可以取代SFB3?
我想答案應該不行,SFB3單體串並聯,單體阻抗需匹配?!
aeredale 單體偏近代生產,阻抗大多是8,這樣串並單體,聲音會有問題。
wharfedale aeredale 箱體,蠻拉風的
以上資料,如有不正確;還請資深玩家更正 |
|