新手上路
五星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 24833
- 舊站發表文章數
- 7074
|
發表於 2009-1-17 13:48:01
|
顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 hsindao
[B]
On a side subject, after Mr. A heard my system the first comment he said was something like "a large room really hide a lot of problem". It was like meeting a woman for the first time and burst out "Wow, 一白遮三醜". [ ]
I think what he meant was that he did not hear problems that he had to struggle with at home. It will be very informative if you can share with us what type of problem you did not hear and how would you enlarge your room if cost is not an issue, and why?
[/B]
You talked like I'm a pro, but I'm really far from "knowing a lot". I don't mind to be wrong so I can speak freely, and I think I can always learn from being wrong. [ ]
"Big room effect" is like "Big screen effect", one is awed or satisfied by the quantity of the stimulation to the sense and ignored the minor imperfections of it. In a big room, we can get a better distribution of sound energy coming out of the speakers. Since we listen to music in a narrow range of volume difference, big room do have its advantage of less bounce back and more even reverb.
I consider a room of 15-20 坪 the best for average audiophiles, 'cause most high level speakers have good energy coupling with rooms of this size. The smaller the room size, the greater the need to distribute the energy evenly, thus more struggle with the speaker setup and the wall finish.
In my room, a size of 8 坪 or so, I have to fight with excess energy often and speakers alignment becomes crucial. Due to the smaller room size, I have to sit closer to the speakers, then comes the phase coherence problem of a multi-units speaker design.
Theoretically speaking, each of the speakers should have their own sound field and sound stage, imaging etc. and those two should match seamlessly to created a hologram of the recording scene, whether that was created by the mastering engineer or the performance itself. Losing the stage and focus on one side or both will smear the final scene, the worst, you get no imaging, no sound stage, something less than a single speaker can do.
In a bigger room, the focusing becomes tolerable because you have other things to enjoy, smooth music, even pressure, the full orchestra will not sound edgy as it would in a small room. But on the other hand, too big a room will cost us money to fill in more energy to satisfy our desire.
Maybe I can make an analogy for this, try to think of the size of a basketball field. A standard field is too big for small children, too small for team Samson. Since we have a small degree of height difference, the current size of a standard field is kind of about right. |
|