新手上路
二星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 90
- 舊站發表文章數
- 316
|
樓主 |
發表於 2010-4-2 11:43:01
|
顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 hsindao
[B]Music is a very personal thing. Pianists have their own interpretations and listeners have their own preferences. I suggest you pick a style either from recordings you already have or go online and listen to excerpts.
Follows are my 外行的 observations on some recordings. I will refer to Amadeus if Mozart was really like what was portrayed in the movie "Amadeus".
Uchida treated those piano sonatas like serious intellectual compositions. They were from Mozart the intellect, not Mozart the genius. Every notes were carefully analyzed, tempo and contrast enhanced. We can hear the intensity and concentration throughout the pieces. They are not how Amadeus would play himself but the Schubertized structures were interesting enough that makes one wants to come back over time. Uchida took that concentration to a new height in her Tokyo Live in Concert recording. It can get one captivated from the very first note to the end. On the other hand, one can argue that Mozart should not be so intense. This is Mozart in the espresso strength.
If Amadeus were to record a set himself, I would imaging that it will sound similar to the Klien set. Lively, straightforward, playful, even a bit naughty in some earlier sonatas. Our genius would jump on the stage just playing and at the same time saying to audiences: "it is so easy, man".
Gieseking played those sonatas in a very concentrated, measured way. it felt as if he were walking on thin ice. Someone might give him a high five at the end of each session, "no mistake!". There might be inner beauty and wisdom in Gieseking's approach that takes a 內行的 to appreciate. However, Amadeus never lived to old age and if you like lots of sex and violence, this one has none.
[/B]
great analysis! Thank you, Hsindao. I will try to listen all the pianists you mentioned! especially Klien. |
|