忘記密碼
 立即註冊
樓主: chucky7

美國網路直售喇叭和超低音的經營生態和使用觀點

[複製鏈接]

148

主題

3757

回帖

240

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
4615
舊站發表文章數
3354
發表於 2017-2-23 02:04:39 | 顯示全部樓層
小弟不是專家,以下胡說八道請隨便看看就好。


1. 如果希望空氣在管子裡任一處的流動速度儘可能一致、流動路徑的長度儘可能一樣,圓孔和方孔、有轉彎和沒轉彎的差異是可以列入評估比較的。管口、管壁的流體力學優化(噪音、阻力、對稱性)也有影響。


2. 下圖是在 WinISD 現成的單體庫找的兩個不同單體來做模擬,這是一個差異明顯的例子。挖東牆補西牆有沒有可能?只能說音箱設計不是用猜的、聽說的...

單體尺寸一樣、箱體尺寸一樣(含管子佔用的容積)、開孔截面積一樣、擴大機功率一樣(兩單體振幅都推到接近線性衝程,SPL 如圖示)。

音樂性是用音響性釀的酒;電影的現場不在電影院,音樂的現場不在音樂廳

34

主題

1311

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Da Man

舊站積分
1718
舊站發表文章數
1326
 樓主| 發表於 2017-2-23 16:22:33 | 顯示全部樓層
一些 sub porn:

住加拿大, 剛從 SVS SB13-Ultra 升級到 JTR Cap S1 的網友,  左邊是 SVS SB13-Ultra, 右邊是 JTR Captivator S1



另一個網友有點誇張. 目前他有 2 隻 SVS SB13-Ultra, 2 隻 SVS SB16-Ultra, 又入手了一隻 PSA S3601... [:O]

從左到右: SB13-Ultra, SB16-Ultra, PSA S3601.



34

主題

1311

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Da Man

舊站積分
1718
舊站發表文章數
1326
 樓主| 發表於 2017-2-23 16:26:56 | 顯示全部樓層
JTR Captivator 1400 保時捷紅鋼烤:



主人的家庭劇院:

34

主題

1311

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Da Man

舊站積分
1718
舊站發表文章數
1326
 樓主| 發表於 2017-3-1 16:58:20 | 顯示全部樓層
上週日有位熱心的網友 Marc 稍早答應要幫我調整 JTR Captivator 1400. 剛好另一位網友 bulls 也正在考慮要選擇 反射式 還是 封閉式 的超低音. Marc 就把他的封閉式 PSA S3000i 也帶來做個小網聚. bulls 在2月初就已經來我家聽過 Cap 1400 了. 我也想聽聽封閉式重低音.

我的JTR Cap 1400 18吋反射式重低音


Marc 的 PSA S3000i 雙15吋背對背重低音


這兩台的擴大機板剛好都是 SpeakerPower 的 1400W Ice Power Amp.

[B]我的說明: 空間約 10 坪大 [/B]

I have the Cap 1400 gain at 12 o'clock, LF Adjust @ Max ( 2015 Cap 1400 LF Adjust is +/-6 dB, and 2016 Caps are cut only). Sub trim on AVR is +3 dB.

Initially we had the Cap 1400 @ 11 o'clock from the MLP and the PSA 3000i @ 10 o'clock. This is when we roughly level-matched them with REW. Then we replaced the Cap 1400 with the PSA 3000i (9 ft from MLP) and moved the Cap 1400 to the other front 1/4 wall position (11.5 ft from MLP), between center and right channel. We did not run auto calibration for the subs at these spots.

First we played music videos (Eagles - California Live at Sydney and Justin Bieber - Baby) @ -17.5 MV. I did not play any MVs last time when bulls was here. When I was playing Justin Bieber - Baby, both Marc and bulls got up and started walking around the room and even stood behind the MLP. I have been saying that the bass is very potent in this video...

For movies clips we played @ -12.5 MV. First it was the Irene Scene from Black Hawk Down (just for me to see what the fuss was all about, LOL), then the first 40 seconds of Edge of Tomorrow. I was very surprised that from 20~30 Hz, the Cap 1400 was hitting 125 dB and the PSA S3000i was hitting 120 dB. Never did I know I was anywhere near reference level much less above it. This was where we heard the chuffing. To get a better sense of how the subs would handle bass in movies not mixed at crazy levels, we watched the Hulk vs Abomination scene from The Incredible Hulk. Finally, we played the Washington Monument Scene from Olympus Has Fallen and the Grenade scene in World War Z.

Marc was grinning from ear to ear bombarded by the Cap 1400 wind!

[B]Marc 的說明:[/B]

Well, we had a small GTG at Chucky7's house yesterday (@Chucky7, @bulls , and myself). The JTR Cap1400 and the PSA S3000i. To cut to the chase, there was no winner in my mind, only that the two subs have inherent differences. Neither sounded better to me overall, just different.

Chucky runs his LFE +10dB hot & we also ran the volume well over reference. His room is not large and had considerable room gain despite two openings leading to the kitchen and the rest of the house. We ran clips from the Ultimate Bass Demo Discs as well as some music (Hotel California in 5.1 DTS-HD MA sounded great). The JTR had in-room extension to about 14Hz and hit peaks of 125 dB between 20-30Hz w/movie clips. The PSA was no slouch with extension down to 6Hz and hitting peaks of 120dB from 20-30Hz.

We moved the JTR to the other front 1/4 wall position for better FR and placed the PSA in its original place.  At the levels we were playing (~10dB over reference) there was definitely some chuffing on the JTR but it didn't bother me because it had an amazing ability to create wind! Not just a small breeze but strong wind if you were directly in front of the port. We sat about 2m from the front of the JTR. The JTR was also more tactile (except for at 10Hz of course) for the most part. The PSA had a bit more mid-bass. @bulls seemed no closer to making a decision when we left than before. A Cap 2400ULF will hit 20Hz but he can't face it towards the MLP to feel the wind. At regular listening volumes I doubt the chuffing is a big issue. A second Cap 1400 would likely increase chuff free headroom.

Honestly, without the sealed PSA S3000i there and REW RTA we wouldn't know we were missing any content at 10Hz.

Is there something about the JTR Cap 1400 that produces more port wind than other designs?

I personally think the new @Rythmik FV25 should be a consideration for the OP to get a form factor closer to the Cap 1400 and also get 10Hz extension. It should be quite formidable in his size room with room gain.

Because I am a champion of dual subs I believe dual PSA V1801s have a great price, finish, and form factor and would be a better choice than a single Cap 1400 for the OP (giving up on the quest for 10Hz). But oh the Cap 1400 wind!

@chucky I didn't want to out you about the Bieber demo. At least it featured Ludacris!

Honestly though, The Eagles sounded amazing on his system. The trumpets sounded more lifelike on his system than mine (my Mirage OMD-28s excell more with the string instruments). I think many people underestimate the importance of matched (in his case identical) drivers all around. Properly setup 5.1 stomps all over cobbled together 7.1. Also, again the notion that ported is not good for music was debunked. The PSA sounded great too. It was a tad tighter but I have to give the edge to the JTR because of the extra tactile oomph it provided.

Because I have TTs and a small room, sealed was the right choice for me. However, what I have achieved with four sealed 15" drivers I could have with two ported 18"s and not needed the TTs (giving up on 10Hz).

If I had the proper room and the budget, I believe a Cap 1400 combined with a Cap 2400ULF or 4000ULF would provide the best overall experience (including 10Hz though) without needing TTs or TMAs.

My opinion on two subs vs one hasn't changed. Two is better than one… in MOST cases. @bulls I can assist you in dialing in two subs, ported or sealed. @chucky7 I think you are fine with the single in its new position, just add a MiniDSP EQ to tame those peaks.

20

主題

122

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
144
舊站發表文章數
102
發表於 2017-3-1 22:03:55 | 顯示全部樓層
可否請chucky7兄簡述一下這兩個怪獸炮,密閉怪vs開孔怪,聽感或體感上的差異?給在下參考一下!麻煩你了,謝謝!

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
發表於 2017-3-2 00:03:06 | 顯示全部樓層
補充上面小網聚@chucky7's house 原討論串:need 10 hurtz what to buy, WAF post#88

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
發表於 2017-3-2 00:12:41 | 顯示全部樓層
關於追求10Hz與"體感"

前帖post#71 (by Deep Sea Sound)
One question that I don't see mentioned that is an early question I ask of prospective customers is what type of floor you're on. If concrete, it may not make as much sense to try getting the 10 Hz reproduction as it won't have the same impact as on a wood floor. I've measured my 24s in several customer's rooms and all but 1 has been flat to 7 Hz before rolling off (the other one was a single 24 in a corner that didn't start rolling off until 6 Hz). But there is a marked difference between the rooms with concrete floors vs wood floors with the latter providing the additional benefit of being incredibly tactile.

另補充一個圖供參考:

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
發表於 2017-3-2 00:25:42 | 顯示全部樓層
前帖(見此)的post 76# Funk Audio老闆也對於極低頻失真的影響考量作出淺顯易懂的說明

Q:

Does THD REALLY matter at 10hz? The sustained output numbers show a 3-4db advantage from 10-30hz.

A:

It can. But it depends greatly on room gain. Lets say for example a sub can do 92db ground plane with say around 17% 3rd harmonic distortion(CEA 2010 pass), but it can do 98db with 100% 3rd harmonic distortion. This means that when passing with 92db at 10hz it is also producing 77db at 30hz, this coincides well with when you can start to hear it, being about 15db down from the 10hz output, but when producing 98db at 10hz it is also producing 98db at 30hz, this is very audible and sounds quite bad, however once you get into a room if you have a decent amount of gain, say 15db at 10hz, and 0db at 30hz, the room will boost up the 10hz output but not 30hz, so all of the sudden with the sub at max your back to passing CEA distortion level, so the large discrepancy in passing vs non passing output disappears. However in a space with little or no room gain you will not get this benefit so you will want to pay more attention to low end distortion. In general though a sub with the common rising distortion under 30-40hz put in a room with average gain that will be counteracted to a large degree. What really matters most is upper end distortion that is not helped by the room, and up in the 80-100hz range the harmonics are in the very noticeable 160-300hz range, so as little as 3-5 % distortion around 80-100hz can be quite noticeable.

34

主題

1311

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Da Man

舊站積分
1718
舊站發表文章數
1326
 樓主| 發表於 2017-3-2 14:27:22 | 顯示全部樓層


先稍微解釋一下. 我的 JTR Cap 1400 已經放在圖片上的位置有好一段時間了. 跑自動音場設定之前, 重低音的增益是 12 點鐘, LF Adjust 放在正中央 (neutral). AVR 跑完自動音場設定後, 重低音音量是 -6 dB, 我加了 3 dB, 再把 LF Adjust 調到最大.

Marc 帶了 PSA 3000i 來, 我們把它放在上圖左喇叭前面一點點, 用 UMIK-1 在 REW 上調整重低音增益直到音量差不多和 Cap 1400 一樣. 為了方便切換比較, 我們後來就暫時把 Cap 1400 移到電視的右邊了. 接下來我們沒有跑 AVR 的自動音場, 就開始比較. Marc 跑了一下頻譜圖, 發現這新位置頻響有好一點, 所以我等他們離開後, 我再跑了一次 AVR 自動音場設定. 重低音音量是 -3 dB. 我把重低音增益調整到 AVR 自動音場測出來的重低音音量到 -6 dB 為止. 我同樣加了 3 dB, 再把 LF Adjust 開最大.

這樣的話, 測試時 Cap 1400 在舊位置測得的音量應該是比新位置高 3 dB 左右. 新位置 Cap 1400 離座位 3 公尺.

我們看 Music Video ( Engles - Hotel California 和 Justin Bieber - Baby ) 時 AVR音量是 -17.5 dB. 這時我只有感覺 JTR Cap 1400 和 PSA S3000i 聽起來音色不同, 但是無法真正定高下. 我認為音質相差無幾, 有可能是因為 MV -17.5 dB 的音量對兩顆重低音都是小意思吧. 但是量感來說, 反射式的 Cap 1400 多了不少. 我後來才發現當時我竟然忘了放 Bassotronics - Bass I Love You 來比較這兩種不同型式的重低音. 殘念...

我們看低頻示範片段時的音量是 MV -12.5 dB. 上次 bulls 來, 我們只有開 MV -19 dB, 符合他在家聽的音量. 這次音量 MV -12.5 dB, 他下巴快要掉下來了.

在看 Black Hawk Down - Irene 的片段時, 封閉式的 PSA S3000i 可以展現持續的 100 分貝的 7 Hz, JTR Cap 1400 只有 90 分貝左右. 但當時我真的心裡是 OS... 就安捏娘??? 在我的環境 100 分貝的 7 Hz 真的是可有可無. 一定是音壓不夠. 可是在我這水泥地上鋪地毯的視聽環境要 10 Hz 以下有 "感覺", 即使是買性價比高的 ID 重低音, 也至少要花 $3000 以上 (兩台 PSA S3000i, 或是 一台 JTR Cap 4000ULF).

在看 Edge of Tomorrow 前 40 秒時, Marc 測得反射式 JTR Cap 1400 在 20 ~30 Hz 音壓高達 125分貝, 封閉式 PSA S3000i 高達 120 分貝. 但是反射式重低音產生的低頻就是厚實許多. 即使這個量感有可能是2次失真. 體感來說, 如果封閉式重低音像是 3 級地震, 反射式重低音就是 4 級. 再加上 Cap 1400 開孔噴出來的強勁氣流. 這樣, 封閉式重低音好比是看一般電影. 反射式重低音好比是 4D 電影. 所以即使我上一套系統有裝踢屁屁, 我到目前為止都還不會想念它.

後來放 The Incredible Hulk - Hulk vs Abomination, Marc 和 bulls 可樂了. 他們被 Cap 1400 震得七暈八素, 再加上被開孔陰風顏射 ... 這是即使使用封閉式重低音 PSA S3000i 可以達到相同的音量, 加上踢屁屁可以超越震度, 也比不上的. 其實用久了就知道踢屁屁有點虛偽. 踢屁屁是妥協, 不是最佳的解決方案, 也無法取代優良的重低音.

AVS 上也是說, 反射式重低音的體感, 不論是牆壁抖動, 椅子震動, 地上滾動, 再加上風感, 是封閉式重低音難以超越的.

Marc 到現在還是對 Cap 1400 產生陰風的能力念念不忘. 這也難怪, 很多人可能一輩子都沒有看過 18 吋單體的怪物重低音, 更不用說是實際聽過. 在這之前, 他應該還沒有聽過 18 吋的反射式重低音, 因為他的三顆封閉式重低音都是 15 吋的.

持平而論, 在重低音的餘裕度內聽封閉式和反射式重低音真的是有細微的差異, 但是無法以這差異分勝負的 (different but not better). 我因為主要用途和空間增益不確定性的狀況下, 選擇了反射式重低音, 這是較為經濟的做法, 也剛好多了體感的附加價值.

Hope this helps!

20

主題

122

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
144
舊站發表文章數
102
發表於 2017-3-2 15:30:38 | 顯示全部樓層
感謝chucky7及ken大的分享讓小弟的追求有更近一步的認知,下一顆應該傾向找一顆開孔大炮[]
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-18 19:39 , Processed in 0.077913 second(s), 41 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表