新手上路
四星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 4156
- 舊站發表文章數
- 1844
|
樓主 |
發表於 2007-3-31 09:46:51
|
顯示全部樓層
john 925 兄,
仔細想想您是問了一個好問題. 這里許多 Jeff Rowland 用家可能都早已瞭解評估過優劣性, 會購入一定都已經過慎密的思考.
音響這回事, 沒有仔細比較不瞭解差異性.
最好不要比較, 往往在追求極致的過程中要不斷地破財消災.
[ ]
TAS Robert Harley 在 AV guide 上有一篇對 Class D 的探討值得研讀.
http://www.avguide.com/features/class-d/wave-chart.php
In practice, all Class D amplifiers put out some high-frequency noise at their binding posts. This is why many Class D amplifiers interfere with radio reception; the loudspeaker cables act as an antenna, broadcasting this switching noise into the local vicinity. This is another reason that Class D amplifiers can sound different in different systems; ancillary products vary in their susceptible to pollution by this radiated noise.
- 這說明了 Jeff Rowland 喇叭端子為何用緊密 Y 插的設計. 有效地降低隔離 Radio frequency 的干擾, 降低系統的噪音.
喇叭線用有金屬隔離網的較佳, 有效阻絕天線效應 Radio Frequncy 的干擾.
同樣的原因, 過長的訊號線使用隔離金屬網可能也較佳.
There』s also quite a bit of mathematics behind a switching output stage; the popular ICEpower module was the result of four years of research at the Technical University of
Denmark. For these reasons, most amplifier manufacturers buy an 「off-the-shelf 」 output-stage module and driver chip from one of several OEM suppliers. The amplifier manufacturer then designs the surrounding circuitry, power supply, and chassis, and perhaps even modifies the module with higher-quality parts. It』s worth noting that the purity of the DC supply to the switching transistors is of paramount importance. The output transistors effectively connect the DC supply to the loudspeaker terminals; any noise or ripple in the DC will be fed to the loudspeaker. Ripple (a 120Hz modulation of the DC supply caused by imperfect filtering of the incoming 60Hz AC power) on the power supply will cause amplitude modulation of the audio signal.
The ICEpower module, shown above, was developed for Bang & Olufsen, and is used in the Rowland line as well as in the Cary A 306 (among others). Another popular module is the Tripath, used in the Audio Research 300.2. (Tripath calls its technology Class T rather than Class D.) The Kharma MP150 employs a technique developed by Bruno Putzeys when he was at Philips Applied Technologies. (Bruno also designed the entire Kharma MP150. Hear from him in the Class D Designers Roundtable).
- 這說明了市面上買同樣 Ice Power or Tripath Module 的擴大機製造商為何生產的機器聲音表現如此大不同.
Intel Core Duo 2 CPU 可製造許多筆記型電腦 Acer, Apple, Asus, Dell, and HP, 您認為它們配備表現都有一樣嗎?
Jeff Rowland 使用 Ice Power Module 的肇因
Jeff Rowland: Through the '90s we were looking at what the next step in amplification would be, and examined all kinds of different topologies. I approached it with a completely open mind. We looked at a number of platforms, including TriPath and other companies who offered their own PWM modules.
I ran into a company by accident at CES called ICEpower, and thought I』d give it a try. I looked at the module as a building block, the way any designer would look at different transistors or discrete components. It』s fundamentally a power-conversion technology. I tried some of the first-generation modules and was initially impressed by their performance.
After some research, I concluded that the technology was getting to be quite mature. I started adding my own value-added components and techniques and found that the overall performance I could achieve was quite astounding. It fulfilled the promise of higher performance, but also had the advantages of smaller size and higher efficiency. It』s also a 「green」 technology. We achieved increased performance over what could be done in the traditional linear realm.
- Jeff Rowland 認為 Ice Power 是綠能科技.
Harley: Will switching amplifiers one day dominate the high-end market?
Rowland: I don』t think they will dominate so much as become an option, in the same way that solid-state hasn』t dominated vacuum tubes. The nature of high-end audio is that everybody has his own favorite technology, and customers have their own likes and dislikes and prejudices, and that』s the beauty of it. We all have our own pride and prejudice, and that will always exist.
- 這說明了 Jeff Rowland 先生對 Hi-End 音響走向開放的態度. 客戶是最後的選擇者 .
Wayne Garcia: It』s interesting, Neil brought up early transistor designs. Particularly with the Cary, the Red Dragon, and the NuForce, what I was reminded me of was early CD. I think the NuForce, as I wrote in my comment, is probably going to be the most controversial, because I know that Chris is crazy about it, and Robert liked it quite a lot, too. For me, that amplifier sounds very sterile. It lacks microdynamics. If you put on a solo violin piece, for example, the violin didn』t have any poetry; the dynamics were kind of squished. The top end just gave me a headache. It almost had a jittery quality, like early CD. I also found the amp not to sound of a piece. The bottom end, by and large, was exaggerated. The top end was both razor-cut and glassy.
Except for the Kharma, I couldn』t live with any of these Class D amps, personally. I agree that it』s an exciting technology, but for me a lot of the current crop just isn』t ready for prime time.
- Wayne Garcia 這段話很有意思, 這也是我最近聽音響的進境. Wayne 說 Nuforce 很乾淨, 但微動感 (micro dynamics) 付之闕如. 如果您的音響傳真到一定程度, 這些細微的微動感也就是音樂性的最重要因素之一, 不幸的是這常被誤認為雜訊而在某些音響器材上被刻意的濾除而少了最重要的音樂性.
Chris Martens 說
I found that the better Class D units tended to win when compared to like-priced or even a fair amount of more expensive Class AB amps.
- Chris 說如果不是與 MBL 9011 等級產品比較. Class D 與相等或較貴的產品比較應有較大的機會勝出.
Chris Martens: One thing I observed with at least a couple of the Class D amps was that they seemed to be much more sensitive to both interconnect cabling and speaker cabling than most of the Class AB amps. I was able to make that jittery quality in the treble go away by picking cables carefully, and, in particular, in some cases by picking power cables carefully.
- Chris Marten 所言與這裡 Jeff Rowland 許多用家經驗不謀而合. 慎選線材搭配使用.
下回再探說您所在意的 Jeff Rowland 高頻表現. 這也是一個好問題.
原發表者是 john925
[B]dcba兄:
有道是三人成虎阿!
一篇評論這麼講,或許可以歸類為搭配不當或是評論員的主觀偏好所導致的落差
但是,兩篇三篇都提到這個問題,就不能不謹慎以待!
然而,與其相信評論,倒不如上來請教各位前輩們的現身說法
至少在台灣聆聽環境應該類似,比較不容易會多空間這個變數(歐美軟調空間居多,不利高頻?)
雖然,所有的評價還是要等親耳聽過之後才能論定,
但是在視聽之前,先做足功課,我想也是一位愛樂者所應該保有的公允態度,以免誤殺忠良
從第一頁讀下來,似乎沒有網兄反應JRDG的D類有高頻被截的現象,不曉得這是D類本身仍能再生高品質的高頻段,還是Jeff Rowland的調音技術克服了D類在先天上的劣勢?
[/B] |
|