新手上路
五星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 3604
- 舊站發表文章數
- 5787
|
發表於 2017-3-3 21:08:08
|
顯示全部樓層
關於超低音的設計型式(sealed vs ported..) 這篇avs thread有網友分享與SVS的 Ed Mullen的討論:
http://www.avsforum.com/forum/11 ... 5.html#post48053569
But as I stated I had a Great call with SVS, I spoke with Ed Mullen Director - Technology and Customer Service who was very involved in the development and testing of the new 16 Ultras.
We discussed the PB2000, Ultra 13 SB/PB and Ultra 16 SB/PB as he has had all 5 speakers in his home and has heard them all perform in different employees' homes. Plus as he mentioned, beside Smith Freeman of SVS, no one has more Ground Plane testing experience and info on both versions of the 16 Ultras.
We reviewed the test results on data-bass.com regarding the SB13 and the PB13 and then he told me the improve data points that the SB16 and PB16 had over them. We reviewed frequency response, CEA 2010 max burst, THD, long term output compression, impulse response, waterfall decay, group delay and spectrogram information[/B]. Ed's a real cool guy and extremely knowledgeable, you can tell he lives and breathes this stuff, and having my under grad degree in Electronic Engineering, I had a lot of questions for him.
When it comes to people who prefer sealed subs for music over ported subs, it's the last 3 specs above where sealed subs have an advantage that tend to be most important and show the effects of ringing and transient responses that tend to smear the sound of subs/speakers.
上面是Ed認為超低音的音樂表現在密閉式的優勢重點.
該文還列出幾顆他家的subs 的音樂表現(Ed主觀上的)評分:
he gave the following subjective rating based on all his years of experience and testing with the 3 subs I had in question.
Music
SB16 10/10
SB13 9/10
PB16 Extended mode 8.5/10
PB16 Sealed mode 10/10
**Of course if you're looking at (or including) extension, SPL, max burst, those ranking and rating don't apply.
有興趣可讀一下原討論串 ^^
理論如此, 不同的設計是否真能反映在實際聆聽的經驗呢?
AVS網友自行辦的盲測比較, 結果常是沒辦法達成一致共識的. 或許與調整過程不夠嚴謹或空間因素影響..等等有關, 無論如何總結起來多半是本質夠好的開孔式超低音, 在調整好的狀況下, 音樂表現並不會明顯遜色於密閉式. |
|