新手上路
四星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 2007
- 舊站發表文章數
- 1423
|
發表於 2008-2-25 14:49:36
|
顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 hsindao
[B]
Thanks YMW for the response. Good try for the Onassis part and +3 for the Norma. I have never listened to Norma before, is it good? As for Onassis, I think most of the world did not know him until Jacky Kennedy decided to marry him. I would think that he owed the 2 women around him for the fame rather than the other way around.
Oscar is ongoing right now and let me borrow Oscar as example. If there were an award for acting through singing, I would give the best leading actress award to Callas and best supporting actor award to Fisher-Dieskau.
When most people listen to operas , they likely only pay attention to the voices. When they go to the opera or watching DVD, they can watch the actors and follow the story lines through acting. Singing was just part of the sound effect as far as the story goes. However, when those visual effects are taken away and one has to rely on singing alone to picture that Mimi telling Rodolfo that "My name is Mimi ..." in a get acquainted conversation, or Tosca being jealous of the beautiful woman in a portrait that her boy friend was painting and pleaded him to paint her eye black instead of deep blue, it takes a very good singer to convincingly portrait those characters through singing. Callas did those in flying colors while other leading divas like Tebaldi or Sutherland failed miserably.
In my limited experience, there are 2 groups of opera singers. There was the Decca camp: Pavaroti, Sutherland, Tebaldi, that had glorious voices, triumphant high-c but that was all. There was not much soul in those opulence (華麗) singing. Then there was the EMI camp: Callas, Stefano, Serfin that brought souls to each characters. Like in movie, there are Harrison Ford or Tom Cruise that drew big box office or Meryl Streep that does not draw as big crowd but won Oscar many time over. Take your pick. [/B]
Thank you for your generosity!
I do appreciate your commentary on opera singers. And you know my answer to the first question is just a joke. You mentioned "many fat ladies...", and this provides a clue to your first question. Maria Callas is very different from those fleshy divas, she is very beautiful. Beauty makes Maria Callas legendary, I think.
As for Norma, try Youtube to see if it is good for you. [ ]
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SCzsFIIsWuo |
|