新手上路
五星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 3604
- 舊站發表文章數
- 5787
|
發表於 2020-1-1 22:26:41
|
顯示全部樓層
該AVS討論串有網兄提問超低音的設計形式無論開孔密閉或有無伺服設計, 有沒有什麼喜好度上的共識, Dr. Toole的回應:
I don't think there is a debate to be had with respect to sealed vs. vented designs. Nowadays it is all predictable from computer modeling programs.
The amount of time-domain misbehavior between them is below the threshold of detectability, BUT, the differences in amplitude response is not. Even my original research published in 1985-86 showed that bass extension, by itself, was correlated with overall sound quality ratings. The lower roll-off rate of closed boxes is an advantage.
(現今的超低音性能進步多, 時域的問題多數不大, 而有意義的性能表現差異主要在發聲能量上.)
..
Given the powerful modes in small rooms the real challenge is allowing the subwoofer to communicate to the listener (preferably more than one) without both amplitude and time-domain corruptions that far exceed those in subwoofers themselves - reflex or sealed, passive, active or servo.
(空間對低頻的扭曲常遠大於超低音本身)
I suspect the only place where one could conduct meaningful comparisons of the factors you list is outdoors - avoiding the corrupting listening room.
The main purpose of servo woofers is to reduce non-linear distortions at high sound levels. The "impulse response" of subs is determined by their frequency responses (they are minimum phase devices) and that can be changed with equalization whether external to the sub or internal.
As I said in an earlier post (#832), when the air flow in reflex ports becomes turbulent, the design is corrupted.
Closed box subs do not have this problem, but producing the same quantity of bass requires greater diaphragm excursions - risking non-linear distortion - which was the motivation for servos many years ago - as I recall.
Nowadays, much improved subwoofer motor and suspension designs are adequate for most needs. Non-linear distortions at low frequencies are difficult to hear because of simultaneous masking.
(近年來的超低音的進步比以前顯著地降低了失真, 在設計夠好的前題下..)
FYI, significant recent research has shown that humans are remarkably tolerant of low-frequency ringing.
The dominant factor is steady-state frequency response at the listening location - See Section 8.3 "Do we hear the spectral bump, the temporal ringing, or both?"
(低頻部分的頻響主宰聽感, 時域的ringing 聽覺上不敏感 )
A single subwoofer has a big job cut out for itself - room modes can only be attenuated by optimized parametric equalization, and that only works for a single mic location.
Automated EQ schemes may or may not provide optimum solutions.
The most practical solutions, from the research I know of employ multiple subwoofers, usually two or four.
Because of the physics of small rooms at low frequencies, there is a substantial overall efficiency gain with multiple subs, meaning that smaller subs can be used; an advantage not everyone is aware of.
After proper installation of a multiple sub scheme, many of the room modes cease to be audible problems, simple EQ is adequate, and multiple listeners get to hear similar and similarly good bass. It is eerie to walk around a room and the bass is constant, tight and deep.
(應用多顆超低音的優勢..)
As for a single setting of bass level being desirable, it is, but that can only happen in an ideal world where professionals and consumers subscribe to the same definitive performance standards.
I call it the circle of confusion; it's in the book, and I cannot see it going away. Pity.
(低頻的量能表現有無統一的標準可依循? 希望專業人士與消費者的喜好一致? 看來很難) |
|