忘記密碼
 立即註冊
樓主: Platform

CD rip 至硬碟的集體實驗

[複製鏈接]

110

主題

2921

回帖

150

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
21141
舊站發表文章數
1729
發表於 2009-9-8 11:44:32 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 Weron
[B]

沒有想要說服任何人,只是單純從我的角度來呈述事實。
我前面也回覆過,我完全相信聽起來會有差,你們花的錢也值得。 [/B]


到現在為止
還是不知道為何會這樣
也無法想像怎會這樣

只是
知道了這個事實
並且照這樣下去作

曾有人問過某位高手並回饋回來
大致是說
CDDA要轉成WAV
這個過程非常不科學
如同要RIP LP一樣的不科學
據說
CDDA要轉成WAV很難達成100%
問題在那不知道
應該是CDDA及WAV是完全不同的格式

那為何
比對相同的檔案
聽起來會不同
這問題最弔詭
無人可回答
只是既然知道了
就照這樣作
Speaker: Avantgarde Duo Omega Amp: ASR luna 6 CD:NAS+Cary DMS700 LP: Air Force III+Thales Simplicity II,Graham Phantom Elite 唱頭: Clearaudio Statement V2 唱頭放大: ASR basis exclusive

110

主題

2921

回帖

150

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
21141
舊站發表文章數
1729
發表於 2009-9-8 12:06:59 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 dcba
[B]

版上數位先進的研究, 讓 drkao 等數位觀望甚久資深音響迷去換電腦來 rip 及重播其數位格式, 一定有其價值.  以目前挑選電腦交換電源組成一部系統, 音效卡等級費用不論, 已與一般 DIY 電腦花費相去不遠. 對廣大音響迷來說, 這值得投入.

[/B]


目前已經投降的有platform, P900, martinon, jlee, dcba, ivanmchp,
alc及我drkao

當中從事電子產業有platform, P900, martinon, jlee, dcba, ivanmchp
而且都是高階主管

已有線性電源的有platform, P900, martinon, ivanmchp
當中ivanmchp上週才完成

在苦苦等待線性電源的有alc及我drkao

當中martinon忍辱負重
堅持理想
直到以上這些人
一個個投降
Speaker: Avantgarde Duo Omega Amp: ASR luna 6 CD:NAS+Cary DMS700 LP: Air Force III+Thales Simplicity II,Graham Phantom Elite 唱頭: Clearaudio Statement V2 唱頭放大: ASR basis exclusive

2

主題

5

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

初級會員

舊站積分
0
舊站發表文章數
6
發表於 2009-9-10 18:52:33 | 顯示全部樓層
這個討論實在讓我獲益良多阿~ 本來想找出 CDA 紅皮書 KK看是否能多懂一點,卻找到以下的討論串解釋了一些原本我沒搞懂的東西~ 希望對各位也有幫助,請參考以下連結的討論二的部分~原連結

********************************
In essence it is quite possible to create a WAV file that is a bit perfect replication of the digital data on a CD. Exact Audio Copy is a free program that attempts to do just that.

However a bit perfect WAV copy may still sound slightly different to the original CD. That's usually because the software and hardware involved when you play a WAV file is different to that involved when you play a CD. The digital data may be perfect but the performance of the equipment that reproduces that data is far from perfect.

More intriguing is the oft-reported differences between bit perfect copied CDs and the original CD when played back through the same equipment.

Some hard core engineers claim that these differences are imagined. The differences are certainly small and I can't hear any difference between an original and copied CD when played through my PC speakers.

However with a high resolution hi-fi I can definitely hear differences, albeit small.

Various theories have been put forward why two bit perfect copies of a CD can sound different. These include differences in the shape and depth of the pits burned into the CD or differences in the CD reflective coating.

Another possible explanation is differences in the amount of "digital jitter" embedded in the CD and its copy. That is, very small timing variations in the delivery of the digital data.

These timing differences are possible because digital samples of audio data do not contain the timing data in the sample itself but rely on the use of an external clock to provide the timing reference.

So with a CD recorded at the standard 44,000 samples per second these samples are extracted at a rate determined by an external clock. This equates to one sample every one 44000th of a second so you can see the clock need to be very precise.

Well electronic clock circuits are precise but not perfect so it is possible for very small variations in the clock accuracy to effect the timing of the delivery of the digital data stream. These small variations may show up as a distortion of the original audio signal. This is called digital jitter.

Digital jitter can become embedded in a digital signal at many different point during a CD copy operation and this certainly opens the possibility that two otherwise bit perfect CDs may sound different.

Some engineers believe clocks are so accurate that the resultant digital jitter is too small to be audible. Other engineers believe it to be an important variable in the quality of digital audio reproduction and a major cause of the hard, metallic quality often present in digitally recorded audio material. It is a contentious issue.

Contentious or not it is a subject well outside of the scope of this article or indeed this website. If you want to talk more about this issue I suggest this is best done on an engineering or audiophile forum or website.
****************************************

15

主題

400

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
543
舊站發表文章數
314
 樓主| 發表於 2009-9-10 21:39:43 | 顯示全部樓層
自從 jitter 在數位音響界被開始廣泛討論後,所有相關不同聲音表現的都找他來算帳

可不可能 JITTER 似乎背負一些不該有的罵名?

CDDA 沒有 ECC 故而非常不精確,那存放在硬碟中的檔案甚麼嚴謹的檢查機制沒有?

你可以換一條 SATA 線、或是包幾層隔離防震材質後,看看聲音表現不同是不是JITTER造成的?

0

主題

58

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

一星級會員

舊站積分
44
舊站發表文章數
58
發表於 2009-9-10 23:26:40 | 顯示全部樓層
CD-DA 有 CIRC 的保護,別再誤會它沒有 ECC  了。
另外會主張 CD-DA 與 CD-R 的聲音一樣是因為 播放時 Clock Source 是另外產生的,跟燒錄時的 Clock 根本一點關係都沒有。
碟片上的訊號只提供資料,不提供時脈。不過這離題很遠了。

15

主題

400

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
543
舊站發表文章數
314
 樓主| 發表於 2009-9-11 00:47:44 | 顯示全部樓層
是的,據紅皮書上說 CD-DA 的確有驗證碼

Sub-code channels、 index points 及 CIRC ( Cross-Interleaved Reed-
Solomon Code)

我想說的是:
連硬碟的WAV檔都無法擔保聲音會相同
更別說CD-DA 這種對於讀取、 Rip 時變數特多的格式
CIRC 依舊無法提供令人滿意的保證
若把所有的因素全推給 JITTER 個人覺得不以為然

1

主題

1

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

初級會員

舊站積分
0
舊站發表文章數
1
發表於 2009-9-21 00:40:31 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 Stephen
[B]這個討論實在讓我獲益良多阿~ 本來想找出 CDA 紅皮書 KK看是否能多懂一點,卻找到以下的討論串解釋了一些原本我沒搞懂的東西~ 希望對各位也有幫助,請參考以下連結的討論二的部分~原連結 ... [/B]



感謝Stephen大分享,我想我來重點整理一下好了。

1. CD完美轉檔(wav),本質來說是非常有可能達成的,例如 EAC就試圖要這麼做。
In essence it is quite possible to create a WAV file that is a bit perfect replication of the digital data on a CD. Exact Audio Copy is a free program that attempts to do just that.

2. 完美的WAV檔播放,與原本CD播放不同,原因大約如下解說。(因與本串無關故略過)
However a bit perfect WAV copy may still sound slightly different to the original CD. That's usually because the software and hardware involved when you play a WAV file is different to that involved when you play a CD. The digital data may be perfect but the performance of the equipment that reproduces that data is far from perfect.

3. 完美複製的CD和原本CD,在同一系統播放時的不同。(因與本串無關故略過)
More intriguing is the oft-reported differences between bit perfect copied CDs and the original CD when played back through the same equipment.
Some hard core engineers claim that these differences are imagined. The differences are certainly small and I can't hear any difference between an original and copied CD when played through my PC speakers.
However with a high resolution hi-fi I can definitely hear differences, albeit small.

3.1 完美複製的CD和原本CD播放時有差異的理論探討。燒錄和數位時基差異。(因與本串無關故略過)
Various theories have been put forward why two bit perfect copies of a CD can sound different. These include differences in the shape and depth of the pits burned into the CD or differences in the CD reflective coating.
Another possible explanation is differences in the amount of "digital jitter" embedded in the CD and its copy. That is, very small timing variations in the delivery of the digital data.

3.2 此作者認為「數位時基差異」所提出的時間差是很有可能的,因為[B]聲音資料的數位取樣並無包含時間資料,而且這樣的數位取樣本身必須倚賴外部時鐘來提供時間資料。[/B]所以...CD取樣的時鐘必須非常精確。
These timing differences are possible because digital samples of audio data do not contain the timing data in the sample itself but rely on the use of an external clock to provide the timing reference.
So with a CD recorded at the standard 44,000 samples per second these samples are extracted at a rate determined by an external clock. This equates to one sample every one 44000th of a second so you can see the clock need to be very precise.

3.3 時鐘電路是精確,卻非完美無暇。所以...造成「數位時基差異」。因此...CD複製過程中造成聽感的差異。
Well electronic clock circuits are precise but not perfect so it is possible for very small variations in the clock accuracy to effect the timing of the delivery of the digital data stream. These small variations may show up as a distortion of the original audio signal. This is called digital jitter.
Digital jitter can become embedded in a digital signal at many different point during a CD copy operation and this certainly opens the possibility that two otherwise bit perfect CDs may sound different.

3.4 有些工程師[B]相信[/B]時鐘可以準確到數位時基差異可以聽不出來差異。而另一些工程師則[B]相信[/B]數位時基差異是一個重要的變數,密切相關於數位聲響的再現,而且是主要導致數位錄音普遍發出金屬、硬聲底的原因。
這是一個爭論不休的議題。...
Some engineers believe clocks are so accurate that the resultant digital jitter is too small to be audible. Other engineers believe it to be an important variable in the quality of digital audio reproduction and a major cause of the hard, metallic quality often present in digitally recorded audio material. It is a contentious issue.
Contentious or not it is a subject well outside of the scope of this article or indeed this website. If you want to talk more about this issue I suggest this is best done on an engineering or audiophile forum or website.
****************************************

174

主題

8491

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

猩猩級會員

舊站積分
14228
舊站發表文章數
3171
發表於 2009-9-27 13:06:22 | 顯示全部樓層

昨天在David家,聽了這張CD的Rip


聲音的輕鬆, 細節與活生感
完全不輸去年在音響展聽到的三件式訊源
跟David重複之前的感想
CD的實體存在感已經越來越稀薄了
最近一批, 一批的Rip結果
似乎CAT的電源, 電源線, DVD-driver都有break-in的需要
每一次新的Rip,聲音都還在進步著
最後還有些小感想
這種diy的玩法下,好聲的要件似乎都在解決電源, 振動與干擾等基本問題




[/FOnt]

49

主題

1552

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
32767
舊站發表文章數
1548
發表於 2009-9-27 21:59:55 | 顯示全部樓層
說的也是,聽硬碟hiend久了,不需要起身挑片換片,不自覺會專心在音樂曲目聆聽上,都忘了有實體CD這回事。

213

主題

5065

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Honey!! honey!!

舊站積分
1085
舊站發表文章數
2715
發表於 2009-9-28 20:06:24 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 P900
[B]說的也是,聽硬碟hiend久了,不需要起身挑片換片,不自覺會專心在音樂曲目聆聽上,都忘了有實體CD這回事。 [/B]


P900兄您的信箱滿了…
小弟有事請教。
沒錢看圖就好,不要亂花 [URL=https://www.facebook.com/stereoJP]日本代標[/URL]
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-19 06:45 , Processed in 0.080175 second(s), 41 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表