新手上路
四星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 3261
- 舊站發表文章數
- 1711
|
發表於 2007-7-28 00:10:08
|
顯示全部樓層
Re: 合唱版1812年黑膠
原發表者是 lvt2006
[B]
ML 5392, mono最末期的錄音
...
再回Ormandy版後頭的管絃樂管奏也比RCA好很多. 好的錄音就是有這好處, 音樂的鮮活與脈動都在那裡...一邊聽, 一邊可想像到譜上的音符到那裡了..那是這樣的錄音到處都是, 甚至如過江之鯽, 隨便拿一張都有如此聲效, 那此張CBS的賣點是什麼??? 好歹它也是名曲三百的榜單...合唱?? RCA版已有了, 不稀奇!!卡拉揚也有啊!!!那阿卡就排第三名, 為什麼它是第一, RCA是第二??(20年前音樂與音響開始登第一版的名曲三百, 此三張分別為1, 2, 3, 可有人有第一版三百再確認一次??)
[/B]
Lenny, I have the stereo 6-eye version of this Ormandy 1812, MS 6073, so it is not a "mono最末期的錄音'.
I am confused about which one ranked 1, 2, 3 from your description. I have been doing survey of all the 6-eye recordings I have and this one ranked the top sonically. It has a silky and extended string sound similar to Walter/Beethoven sym 6 but was recorded at a closer perspective that showed the sound stage better.
One 1812 recording that was not in your survey was Mehta's recording on London. I sort of recall a story that the sound of cannons caused damage to the church where it was recorded at, the church refused to lend itself to Mehta afterward. |
|