新手上路
五星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 24833
- 舊站發表文章數
- 7074
|
發表於 2008-4-8 07:55:21
|
顯示全部樓層
Re: Debbie does mono
原發表者是 hsindao
[B]"Blessed are those who can not hear sound stage, for they will hear more music".
I am a sound stage freak. I regard a true high end system must be able to reproduce a 3-D sound stage with good imaging. However, last year I spent around 60% of the time listening to mono LPs. I will get to that in the future but let's settle one unfinished discussion first.
Debbie wants to do mono. How many speakers does she need? For most people this is an academic question because they will just listen to the music, mono or stereo, with their existing system. It is still worth looking into how that single channel music sounded differently in different setup.
1. I assume the 5.1 channels will be a DSP based system. With DSP generated ambient sound, even those edgy recording will sound pleasant. One will not get the clarity of the original, unprocessed sound though.
2. Three speakers. No experience here. I would think that with three identical speakers, it will have better center focus than 2-channel reproduction. If one does not have 3 identical speakers, or 3 lesser quality speakers, I would rather listen to 2-ch setup.
3. Two speakers. Center image will be larger than 1 speaker but it gives a pleasant big-mono imaging. There were times that I heard images of 2 instruments came from 2 places due to different reactions with the room.
4. Single speaker. This is more interesting. With my Thiel 3.6 pointing straight foward, if I just turn off one speaker and sit on the regular seat, the sound was thin and unpleasant. If I sit in front of one speaker, it has better clarity than the 2-ch setup. There was also nice sense of depth, good toner quality and imaging width although the image is not as large as using 2-ch. After that experiment, I sort of understand why some people said a corner horn makes a nice mono system, and in another case one person built a 10-ft wide mono speaker. [/B]
3 speakers setup is kind of redundant, with probably all of us have experienced, crowding of the instruments in a mono replay, who needs another center channel to "fill up" the "hole"?
And that 5.1 is even more absurd. Most of the mono recordings will be covered by a full range design, so the sub woofer is going to sit there and watch everyone else playing. If 2 channel stereo setup is already enough hard work for speaker placement and tuning, 3 more is just pain in the...
But what would we dream of if a properly setup 5 or even more speakers system to play mono? Huge image? surround? ease and peace? Well, I don't think we can get surround, there is no information there. Huge image, maybe or maybe not, depending on the precision of speaker setup. More precision, less likely the image will be huge, it just comes back to what it should sound as a one speaker setup. Ease and peace is another matter, it's hard to get if you find your 200GBP mono is scratched.
The last sentence of your post is also what I'm thinking of. Listening to mono recording with only one speaker moves my thought to speaker design. What is a better design to reveal the things coming into mics and going through the chain down to our listening room? If there is a good answer to this question, that seem to apply to stereo too.
_ _ _
It's good for Debbie goes mono, stereo is kind of dangerous, speaking of AIDS... |
|