忘記密碼
 立即註冊
樓主: hsindao

VTA

[複製鏈接]

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2009-1-21 13:09:49 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 alc
I don't quite follow your point of fixed angle between cutter edge and line connecting the pivot. My point is, if we use an Ikeda 9 to track an LP cut with a Neumann, the up and down arc will not be precisely picked up with the straight motion Ikeda. Likewise, if the Neumann cutter shaft is long and I use a very short shaft DV 17Karat to play what comes out of the Neumann, theoretically, it won't fit exactly.


Indeed, an Ikeda 9 will not follow the VERTICAL MODULATION ARC of any modern LPs that were cut with 15 or 20 degree angle.  However, most more credible articles stated that VTA deviation is not easily audible unless there is a gross mismatch.  When we adjust the tonearm height, we are actually changing SRA and change VTA accordingly by a small amount.  My guess is that we are more sensitive to SRA deviation than VTA deviation.  There is a fine difference between the two.

A stylus with shorter cantilever will move along an arc with larger curvature while one with longer cantilever will move along an arc with smaller curvature.  Both curvatures will be much larger than the one created by the cutting stylus.  However, since the modulation level on the LP is quite small comparing to the length of most cantilevers, we can consider both recording and playback stylus to move in a straight line as far as record/replay  is concerned.


About the IEC VMA, can you or anybody think of a reasonable explanation that why they want a non 0 degree cutting? Of all the turmoil of different VMA, why they want to change it, say from 15 to 22? What's the possible benefit of changing the angle that outweight the difficulty of getting proper playback?


It is difficult to make a phono cartridge with stylus moving at vertical direction.  Ikeda and Decca are only two I can think of.  Both are very expensive, fragile (Dr. Chen of Ping-Dong said he has damaged his Ikeda 3 times when cleaning it), and alignment will be challenging.    Since majority of cartridges need a cantilever, a non-zero degree VMA is required.

I don't know the exact reason to move from 15 degree VTA to 20 degree.  It seemed like the move was lead by cartridge makers and  the LP cutters followed suit.   I can think of some advantages moving to higher VTA:

1. Cartridges can use shorter cantilever thus improving signal transfer and reduce cost, if any.
2. It is less prone to bottom out with warped records.
3. More flexibility in choices of suspension material.

211

主題

2萬

回帖

150

積分

新手上路

燒膠級會員

舊站積分
9685
舊站發表文章數
21982
發表於 2009-1-21 13:26:28 | 顯示全部樓層

VTA

增加 cutting head VTA, 15 到 23 度

我想到的原因 just for reference )

1.因為唱針 VTA 不可能為0以下,

  23度的 cutting head VTA ,不太會因 spring back 而成為0以下.

2. VTA大,阻尼要更耐用.材質的進步有助VTA的提高.
[url=http://www.myav.com.tw/bbs/showthread.php?s=&threadid=272190&perpage=12&pagenumber=290]LP 資料庫索引[/url] [url=https://www.facebook.com/%E4%BD%95%E6%B4%8B%E6%B4%8B%E7%9A%84%E9%9F%B3%E9%9F%BF%E5%AF%A6%E9%A9%97%E5%AE%A4-1147636695299945]何洋洋的音響實驗室[/url]

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2009-1-21 13:52:03 | 顯示全部樓層

Re: VTA

原發表者是 hojuiyang111
[B]增加 cutting head VTA, 15 到 23 度

1.因為唱針 VTA 不可能為0以下,

  23度的 cutting head VTA ,不太會因 spring back 而成為0以下.
[/B]

That is not quite the reason.  Just to give you a bit of history.  CBS started cutting LP using 23 degree cutting angle and Bauer found out that the effective VMA they got was around 0 degree after springback.  To achieve the IEC specified target of 15 degree VMA, Bauer had to increate the cutting angle to 37 degree.  

The current IEC standard of 20 degree  is the final VMA after springback. Cartridges should be tracking it at around 20 degree VTA.

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2009-1-24 06:24:39 | 顯示全部樓層

Someone high in the food chain pointed out the following thread from VinylAsymlum, which can be a good lead-in to the subject : VTA/SRA  for mono LPs.    However, Let's do the basic first.

Helikon mono vs stereo cartridges

TomB said:

"The Lyra Mono Helikon is just about best. I've had one now for 7 years or more. When playing a single channel recording, the Helikon is a warm and full bodied catridge that only reads in the horizontal plane with all the vertical noise simply vanishing. The records come across as muscular, and a certain weight that neither of my three stereo cartridges can convey.

Whenever I do play a Mono album with a stereo cartridge, the music sounds very thin with no evidence of it's weight and muscularity. Which is sad, because I realize most vinyl lovers will never get around to listening to the way these old pressings REALLY sound. Its a pity, considering the huge number of single channel pressings out there."


Do you agree with that?  What are experiences of vinylphiles here?

151

主題

8413

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
24833
舊站發表文章數
7074
發表於 2009-1-24 12:58:35 | 顯示全部樓層
I do not agree. However, I see this as his personal findings and current experience, not a definitive comment. Some cartridge adjustment and speaker phase coherence might be needed to further improve the stereo result.

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2009-1-31 04:24:11 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 alc
[B]I do not agree. However, I see this as his personal findings and current experience, not a definitive comment. Some cartridge adjustment and speaker phase coherence might be needed to further improve the stereo result. [/B]

I don't agree either but there have been quite a few posts around giving impression that magic happens when one plays mono LPs with mono cartridges.  Let's see if it is a myth or justified.

My initial exposure to stereo/mono cartridge comparisons were at 2  friend's houses, both compared MC cartridges to Ortofon SPU mono using solo violin LP as demonstration material. Indeed the violin sounded shrilled with the stereo cartridge, mellow and full bodied with the SPU mono.  Many here likely have the same experience and it surely confirm the legend that mono LPs sounded much better with mono cartridges.

Why is that so?  I have been tempted to get a mono cartridge for a few years but never did it.  The key reservation was: will a USD 300 mono cartrdige really sound better than an USD 1000 stereo cartridge?  Will I get a colored mid-range that hides the problem and looses the resolution?  If a stereo cartridge can sound smooth and transparent on stereo LPs, why should it sound dry and shrill when left and right channels are identical?  

Stylus of a modern mono cartridge can move in both vertical and horizontal direction like a stereo cartridge but its coil only respond to horizontal movements.  Which has the following advanges when playing mono LPs:

1. It will be quieter when playing a worn mono record.  This is nice but I only buy LPs in good condition.

2. With L and R channels being exactly the same, the center image will be better focused.

The same effect can be achived if there is a mono switch on the preamp.  My preamp does not have the mono switch so I experimented by shorting the L/R channel at the Denon 103 output pins with a very thin wire.  With L/R channels shorted, the center image narrowed a bit but I prefer the fatter image when L and R are separated.

Those were the only advantages that a mono cartridge has.  Why should a mono LP sounds great with a mono cartridge and poorly with a stereo cartridge?  The answer, I believe, is in VTA.

Many people likely set the VTA of their stereo cartridge to get the maximum perceived dynamic,  loudest KIANG from the piano, for example.  Those settings might be too high for mono LPs.  Almost all mono cartridges under USD 1000 uses spherical stylus so they are not that sensitive to VTA.  Stereo cartridges with line contacts are far more sensitive to VTA setting and the shrill sound I heard or people described can be explained by VTA being set too high.  So, I experimented with different VTA settings for mono LPs and they all sounded excellent with any stereo cartridges I played with.  The biggest difference I noticed was with mono red Angels.  I don't mean to say that VTA should be set lower for all mono LPs but rather that VTA in some systems were set too high for mono LPs.

In June 2008 alc came to Dallas and brought Lyra Helicon mono with him.  The Lyra was installed on a Graham 2.2 by alc himself.  I have never seen anyone so 龜毛 when installing a cartridge.  Every lead needs to be 惜惜 for a while so that they are stress free when the leads were connected to the pins.  Anyway, the Helicon mono sounded very airy and created a larger and more recessed sound field compared to my ZYX R-1000s AIRY.  The ZYX is more forward and more focused than the Helicon.  If one does not know which cartridge was playing, he will likely think the ZYX being the mono cartridge while the Helicon is the stereo one.  They sounded different but both sounded very good.  It was hard to say which was better.  The Helicon has not been broken in as I understand so it may sound different later.

In conclusion, I don't think there is any inherent magic in mono cartridge when playing mono LPs.  With proper VTA a stereo cartridge can sound very good also.   The sad part is that I have not found a single VTA that makes all LPs sound good even if  not picky.  There is a VTA setting that I am happy with most LPs except red Angels, both stereo and mono.    More about this later.

211

主題

2萬

回帖

150

積分

新手上路

燒膠級會員

舊站積分
9685
舊站發表文章數
21982
發表於 2009-1-31 19:36:50 | 顯示全部樓層

mono catridge

我短暫用過 ortofon mono ,

我也不贊同 magic happens when one plays mono LPs with mono

cartridges.

不過大多數的 mono cartridges 是圓針,也多為 1mil styli,

styli 也較大.這應也是造成差別的原因.


那如何把 mono 弄好聲?

我以為單 speaker,小空間,小系統較有機會.

另外有些老 mono 可能也要試試不同的等化曲線.

mono cartridges 對phonostage 的阻抗也很敏感,亂調阻抗有時更好聽.
[url=http://www.myav.com.tw/bbs/showthread.php?s=&threadid=272190&perpage=12&pagenumber=290]LP 資料庫索引[/url] [url=https://www.facebook.com/%E4%BD%95%E6%B4%8B%E6%B4%8B%E7%9A%84%E9%9F%B3%E9%9F%BF%E5%AF%A6%E9%A9%97%E5%AE%A4-1147636695299945]何洋洋的音響實驗室[/url]

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2009-2-10 00:42:01 | 顯示全部樓層

Width vs depth


Changing subject for a while.  

A friend was experimenting with record clamp recently and he observed that one clamp gave him wider but shallower soundstage while another one gave him deeper  but narrower soundstage.  Which is more correct and why?

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2009-5-28 10:43:13 | 顯示全部樓層

VTA on the fly [Part 1]


If you have a tonearm that allows you to adjust VTA on the fly, do you set VTA to certain setting and lock it or do you adjust it when going through your collections?  If you set and forget, you might be missing a great tool that let you hear one great recording after another.  Let me explain it in Q&A format.

Q.  What is the effect of changing VTA?

A. No one knows for sure what is the correct VTA/SRA for each record but one fact is commonly accepted: raising VTA will increase treble while lowing VTA will reduce treble.  At around the optimum VTA point, toner change is quite noticeable when the height of tonearm is raised/lowered by only 1/8 - 1/4 mm.

Other than VTA, many other factors such as record weight/clamp, turntable mat, VTF, gain of phono stage, etc, can all have similar effect on tonality.  However, except some phono stages equipped with VR adjustable gain setting, VTA is the only way  that one can tweak tonality while record is playing.  There are tone equalizers but that is a totally different story.

Q. I just want to listen to music and not worrying about VTA from LP to LP.

A. Think of changing VTA like changing volume: change it only on a needed base.  Put on the LP and listen to it.  If it sounded fine, enjoy it.  If you think it can use some improvement, walk over to the turntable and spend 10-20 seconds raise it or lower it.  You may have to fine tune it one more time but that is pretty much it if you know what you are doing.  The key thing is not  to worry whether the VTA is correct or not but rather if it sounded good to you.

Q. How should I change VTA based on what I am hearing?

A. Simple.  Think if you want it brighter or darker.  For examples,

1. If the sound stage seems too narrow and distant, raise VTA will bring sound stage forward and wider.  If the sound stage seems to be forming along the line between speakers ( very common in Taiwan), lower VTA until you start hearing depth.

2. If you want piano to sound more like a tank, raise VTA.  Violin sounded edgy?  Lower VTA.  How about violin sonatas?  Set it to a point where both violin and piano sounded best.

Q. How do I know I have reached the optimum point?

A. It will be easier if your system is balanced and can recreate sound stage.  You will hear maximum sound stage width and depth.  There will  be a feeling of liveliness that you hear a good balance of direct sound and the air surrounding those instruments/voices.  You should at least be able to hear the depth variation when you change VTA through its adjustable range.  If not, the rest of your system is either too bright or too dark.

167

主題

8萬

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
32767
舊站發表文章數
11966
發表於 2009-5-28 10:56:43 | 顯示全部樓層

Re: VTA on the fly [Part 1]

原發表者是 hsindao
[B] At around the optimum VTA point, toner change is quite noticeable when the height of tonearm is raised/lowered by only 1/8 - 1/4 mm.
[/B]


VTA 的靈敏度應該可輕易達到 1/80 mm

所有的人都聽得出明顯的差異

無論任何針壓

[] []
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-20 10:34 , Processed in 0.086512 second(s), 41 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表