忘記密碼
 立即註冊
樓主: alanw168kimo

原來HDMI線也是差粉多的!

[複製鏈接]

38

主題

125

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

一星級會員

舊站積分
0
舊站發表文章數
89
 樓主| 發表於 2009-6-19 13:33:54 | 顯示全部樓層
小弟的觀念原本也是認為數位訊號,只有1和0,但聽過之後覺得真的不樣,而且是滿明顯的,只是希望大家如果有不同的HDMI線,可以換看看,是不是不一樣喔!  (HTPC輸出,真的會不一樣喔! 而且在場的每個人都聽的出來,本人沒有要推任何的HDMI線,希望大家多聽到好的聲音而已。)

5

主題

944

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

三星級會員

舊站積分
7
舊站發表文章數
891
發表於 2009-6-19 16:44:48 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 MyAVDay
[B]嗯! 這篇果然粉熱鬧...[]

小弟粉好奇的想要知道, jitter 這玩意兒, 在較"單芯線方式"為嚴謹多多??的 HDMI 傳輸裡, 還會有嗎???[]

有HDMI高手可以指點指點嗎?? 感謝![|)] [/B]

HDMI ATC認證測試中就會規範眼圖的大小.

73

主題

2082

回帖

50

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
283
舊站發表文章數
1515
發表於 2009-6-21 08:16:51 | 顯示全部樓層

Re: 原來HDMI線也是差粉多的!

ma...基本上,HDMI線的影像和聲音訊號都走同樣的線,要是聲音有差異,影像也會有差異喔。

距離長的話,減少損耗確實會有其優點,短距離的話嘛....

至於Jitter嘛,只要連影像一起傳輸的時候,jitter是非常之低的,單傳聲音就另當別論,不過Pioneer的旗艦機不是敢Audio/Video分開傳嗎?只要高價位的帽子蓋下去....=_=+

光纖傳SPDIF訊號會有光電轉換損失,同軸因為SPDIF的clock傳遞的設計,造成jitter的問題,至於HDMI,就如前面所說的,跟著影像訊號傳時,jitter是很低的;至於眼圖,數位訊號不是0就是1,但是如果準位有問題,就會傳錯,所以眼圖差,是代表資料傳輸錯誤的機率會更高,但不一定會錯,更何況,短距離的時候大概只有黑心線會造成眼圖很難看吧。

您有換了HDMI線後,連影像都變的更飽和更艷麗嗎?有的話音X論壇會很需要您。[]

有一期的音X論壇真的就在比高低價位的HDMI線,結論就是貴的聲音好,便宜的聲音較差,ma......基本上聽了兩百萬的CD Player可以延長壽命,那小弟也沒啥好說的了XD(代理商倒是可以拿去醫院推銷看看,無法延長壽命的話請找音X論壇)

只能說,口袋有餘力的人不妨試試高價線,小弟還是堅持一條NT$80的MIC HDMI線的路線就是了。[]

120

主題

4041

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

頂上雕刻師

舊站積分
261
舊站發表文章數
3097
發表於 2009-6-21 09:12:31 | 顯示全部樓層
堅持是好事,但是鐵齒的話就會有不少的錯過跟遺憾

73

主題

2082

回帖

50

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
283
舊站發表文章數
1515
發表於 2009-6-21 09:46:21 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 rambo
[B]堅持是好事,但是鐵齒的話就會有不少的錯過跟遺憾 [/B]


像是讓商人少賺一些嗎?[]
那確實是很遺憾啊。

87

主題

243

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
5
舊站發表文章數
143
發表於 2009-6-21 10:00:57 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 Zimdy
[B]

像是讓商人少賺一些嗎?[]
那確實是很遺憾啊。 [/B]
唉,沒看到過不代表就沒有.........別小人之心.........[)]

73

主題

2082

回帖

50

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
283
舊站發表文章數
1515
發表於 2009-6-21 12:37:13 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 yjl520915
[B]唉,沒看到過不代表就沒有.........別小人之心.........[)] [/B]


是是~小弟是小人;畢竟擋人財路是會被背刺的,還是節制點好了。(MyAV也到了說點擋人財路的話就會被罵小人的論壇了,真是讓人覺得很歡樂啊;算了,反正聲音是用」聽」的,小弟確實是沒」看過」,就當我是小人吧。)

HDMI線好壞天差地遠,特別是貴的聲音特別讚,高音甜,低音勁,大家快換貴的線吧!
(好聽的程度請用價錢排序,例如十倍價錢就好聽X倍這樣,以此類推。)

這樣您滿意了嗎?[8D]

對了,轉貼一篇AVForum的文章:

How can HDMI avoid jitter?
Submit "How can HDMI avoid jitter?" to Twitter Submit "How can HDMI avoid jitter?" to Digg Submit "How can HDMI avoid jitter?" to del.icio.us Submit "How can HDMI avoid jitter?" to StumbleUpon Submit "How can HDMI avoid jitter?" to Google
Posted 22-10-2008 at 10:40 PM by welwynnick
There's a little known feature of HDMI that was introduced in V1.3a last year. HDMI effectively superceded i-Link as the high definition / multi-channel digital audio interface, but for purely audio purposes it was a great step back. I-Link was effective because it neatly side-stepped the problems associated with getting digital audio from a player to an amp. It did this with a new Audio & Music protocol that kept the digital audio amplitude info transfer from the player to the amp, but now had the timing info transfer the other way - from the amp to the transport.

This was quite revolutionary, and meant that the transport could now become a source of digital ones and zeros, just as many people imagine digital audio does work in its "perfect sound forever" way. Jitter is an unwanted and insidious attribute of the timing info - not the amplitude info. Since this new digital audio replay architecture had the timing info going TO the player, so that the player could be kept in time with the amp, rather than the other way round, there could be no timing info to carry jitter from the player. Does that make sense? We now have an entirely jitter-less transport.

The master audio clock is now in the amp, where it should have been all along (which is why I said "Most audio systems screw up digital audio in one way or another"). The timing info from the master clock is needed at the DACs to regenerate the orignal analogue audio, and if the clock can be co-located with the DAC, and connected with a robust timing interface that doesn't allow data to get anywhere near it, the better chance we have of getting accurate timing to the DAC. Of course, the clock itself still has to be good quality and reasonably jitter-free, but simply not having to make the perilous journey from transport to amp is a huge advantage. There were a number of players and amps released by the major manufacturers a few years ago that had i-Link or (similar) Denon-link interfaces, and these were a great success. Unfortunately, HDMI effectively replaced i-link in the last few years, and that great quality was lost.

The key though, was not the physical interface itself (HDMI TMDS, IEEE 1394 or ethernet or whatever) but the protocol that was run on it. I called it the A&M protocol, which comes from the IEC standard, but each manufactuer had his own name for it, like HAT or PQLS eyc. However, there is no reason in principle why those protocols cannot be run on HDMI as well, and HDMI V1.3 section 7.11 introduces Audio Rate Control (ARC). Different manufactuers still call this HATS or PQLS as before, but the important thing is that this allows the amp to control the transport in the same way that i-Link did. I was the first lay-person to highlight this, in July last year, and now its being introduced by Sony and Pioneer in their latest players and amps. If anyone is interested, there's a good read on this thread, and it covers a few other areas too:
Prospect of better audio with HDMI V1.3a? Pay attention audiophiles - could be good!

原文在這裡:按我

大部分的人看到英文就會略過吧,上面的文章寫出為什麼HDMI單傳Audio會有Jitter,而過去的iLink(IEEE1394)則比較沒此問題,然後寫明了」這不是線的問題」,而是IEC Standard的問題,而且也寫清楚HDMI 1.3規範如何解決這個問題,只是現在必須由廠商自行實做,Pioneer的技術叫做PQLS(Precision Quartz Lock System),而Denon Link 4th也藉由自家的系統越過IEC規範而達到jitter free的效果。

所以,別再拔獅子的毛了....

影音部落格偷來的圖:
[)]

原文:按我

這裡則有原廠日文解說:按我

264

主題

986

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
40
舊站發表文章數
427
發表於 2009-6-21 13:23:43 | 顯示全部樓層
其實該討論的是hdmi這條線到底表現藍光多少的實力.搞不好一般的做不好的線只表現了幾成的實力而已!
心田前人種,福地後人耕

264

主題

986

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
40
舊站發表文章數
427
發表於 2009-6-21 13:59:32 | 顯示全部樓層
版上有許多的焊接高手.應把焊接rca線的熱忱轉嫁於hdmi線.相信會有很大的收穫![8)]
心田前人種,福地後人耕

145

主題

2629

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
793
舊站發表文章數
2157
發表於 2009-6-21 19:17:07 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 Zimdy
[B]

是是~小弟是小人;畢竟擋人財路是會被背刺的,還是節制點好了。(MyAV也到了說點擋人財路的話就會被罵小人的論壇了,真是讓人覺得很歡樂啊;算了,反正聲音是用」聽」的,小弟確實是沒」看過」,就當我是小人吧。)

HDMI線好壞天差地遠,特別是貴的聲音特別讚,高音甜,低音勁,大家快換貴的線吧!
(好聽的程度請用價錢排序,例如十倍價錢就好聽X倍這樣,以此類推。)

這樣您滿意了嗎?[8D]

對了,轉貼一篇AVForum的文章:

How can HDMI avoid jitter?
Submit "How can HDMI avoid jitter?" to Twitter Submit "How can HDMI avoid jitter?" to Digg Submit "How can HDMI avoid jitter?" to del.icio.us Submit "How can HDMI avoid jitter?" to StumbleUpon Submit "How can HDMI avoid jitter?" to Google
Posted 22-10-2008 at 10:40 PM by welwynnick
There's a little known feature of HDMI that was introduced in V1.3a last year. HDMI effectively superceded i-Link as the high definition / multi-channel digital audio interface, but for purely audio purposes it was a great step back. I-Link was effective because it neatly side-stepped the problems associated with getting digital audio from a player to an amp. It did this with a new Audio & Music protocol that kept the digital audio amplitude info transfer from the player to the amp, but now had the timing info transfer the other way - from the amp to the transport.

This was quite revolutionary, and meant that the transport could now become a source of digital ones and zeros, just as many people imagine digital audio does work in its "perfect sound forever" way. Jitter is an unwanted and insidious attribute of the timing info - not the amplitude info. Since this new digital audio replay architecture had the timing info going TO the player, so that the player could be kept in time with the amp, rather than the other way round, there could be no timing info to carry jitter from the player. Does that make sense? We now have an entirely jitter-less transport.

The master audio clock is now in the amp, where it should have been all along (which is why I said "Most audio systems screw up digital audio in one way or another"). The timing info from the master clock is needed at the DACs to regenerate the orignal analogue audio, and if the clock can be co-located with the DAC, and connected with a robust timing interface that doesn't allow data to get anywhere near it, the better chance we have of getting accurate timing to the DAC. Of course, the clock itself still has to be good quality and reasonably jitter-free, but simply not having to make the perilous journey from transport to amp is a huge advantage. There were a number of players and amps released by the major manufacturers a few years ago that had i-Link or (similar) Denon-link interfaces, and these were a great success. Unfortunately, HDMI effectively replaced i-link in the last few years, and that great quality was lost.

The key though, was not the physical interface itself (HDMI TMDS, IEEE 1394 or ethernet or whatever) but the protocol that was run on it. I called it the A&M protocol, which comes from the IEC standard, but each manufactuer had his own name for it, like HAT or PQLS eyc. However, there is no reason in principle why those protocols cannot be run on HDMI as well, and HDMI V1.3 section 7.11 introduces Audio Rate Control (ARC). Different manufactuers still call this HATS or PQLS as before, but the important thing is that this allows the amp to control the transport in the same way that i-Link did. I was the first lay-person to highlight this, in July last year, and now its being introduced by Sony and Pioneer in their latest players and amps. If anyone is interested, there's a good read on this thread, and it covers a few other areas too:
Prospect of better audio with HDMI V1.3a? Pay attention audiophiles - could be good!

原文在這裡:按我

大部分的人看到英文就會略過吧,上面的文章寫出為什麼HDMI單傳Audio會有Jitter,而過去的iLink(IEEE1394)則比較沒此問題,然後寫明了」這不是線的問題」,而是IEC Standard的問題,而且也寫清楚HDMI 1.3規範如何解決這個問題,只是現在必須由廠商自行實做,Pioneer的技術叫做PQLS(Precision Quartz Lock System),而Denon Link 4th也藉由自家的系統越過IEC規範而達到jitter free的效果。

所以,別再拔獅子的毛了....

影音部落格偷來的圖:
[)]

原文:按我

這裡則有原廠日文解說:按我 [/B]



最早不是I-LINK沒這問題

反而最早是 PQLS(PIONEER)  H.A.T.S(SONY)

在I-LINK傳輸裡,才出現這樣的技術
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-20 11:58 , Processed in 0.107142 second(s), 41 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表