新手上路
四星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 715
- 舊站發表文章數
- 2969
|
發表於 2008-7-2 13:19:48
|
顯示全部樓層
不過此作者也是一個非常主觀的人, 文章寫得又臭又長,..
文章中刻意標揚特定少許指揮, 如Kubelik, Horenstein, Barbirolli...
但一些指揮不錯的錄音就被忽略, 如在4, 5, 6,9及大地之歌的卡拉揚...
卡拉揚畢竟也是在維也納長大, 也見識過奧匈帝國華麗的年代.. 馬勒的音樂除表現個人的風格外, 其色彩的華麗也多多少少反映當時分離主義的風格, 去過維也納的人都會被其金色的雕飾所吸引. 就算沒去過維也納也看過電視上的金廳吧!! 而卡拉揚的馬勒也正是此種金色文化的翹楚之一...
不管喜不喜歡卡拉揚, 他的馬勒也是必聽的參考之一.. 雖然他一直不被認為是馬勒指揮家, 但卻也呈現另一種精緻的馬勒..
作者完全不提堂堂在維也納歌劇院, 一出來劇院大門就是身受奧匈帝國榮景的指揮, 倒是提一大堆菜市場賣藝的指揮???
Mentioning Rattle and the Berlin Philharmonic reminds me that I am sure I will again receive e-mails pointing out that I have not mentioned the DG recording of this work by Herbert Von Karajan. Well now I have mentioned it and so I will pass on to Giuseppe Sinopoli』s version also on DG. This is not far short of greatness but that falling short is all it takes to rule out a recording of this work. He can bring out the contrasts well but this is at the expense of being too languid in too many of the intimate passages which I think interrupts the symphonic flow too much.
寫什麼碗糕?? 隨便寫寫, 隨便看看...
推薦的冷門錄音還是先聽過再說... |
|