新手上路
學習者
- 舊站積分
- 77
- 舊站發表文章數
- 726
|
發表於 2008-5-31 13:33:02
|
顯示全部樓層
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Boettcher Concert Hall
原發表者是 hojuiyang111
[B]
我可以先明白您的想法嗎?
那又有什麼全然不同的呢? [/B]
Just to share....
For me I would think that concept hall acoustic and small hifi room acoustic are totally 2 different subject that should not be discuss together for those new on acoustic subject .... its just like if when discuss about bicycle, IMHO we should not use too much of the example/picture/concept of motorbike or car to newbie as well...
Take most important RT60 for example, in concert hall we have to deal with very long Reverberation of up to 4 seconds or more , while in small room no matter how live is it it will not exceed 2 sec......
you can ask why dont we just use concert hall RT divided in to scale of 10 ? say instead of 4 sec we use 400 msec as a reference...but..
If we reduce a RT60 of concert hall from 4 sec to 3.5 sec there will be a big impact to sound, where in a small room if we reduce form 400msec to 350 msec the different is very little and some might not notice the different at all...
and what about the RT60 graph curve? in concert hall we would prefer to have a raise in lower frequency and a slight shorter high frequency reverberation to add in warmness but in small HiFi room, it is prefer to have a straighter RT60 response to control the Q of 1L room mode....
there are many many other factor that is different between concert hall and hifi room as well, in concert hall we are dealing with acoustic instrument, and we want it to be loud with long reverberation , but in HiFi room we are using the speaker to produce not only the musical instrument but also the ambience's during recording as well , so the requirement is totally different.... and in concert we want it to sound good in most of the seat but in hifi room usually we would want the best sound from 2 or 3 spot...and many many more...
Given so many differents between concert hall and small room , I really cant think of much thing in concert hall concept, that can be use in small room acoustic...
.....but I will not surprise to see some of the newbie in this subject , following the concert hall treatment in the photo, you have post in this thread at their small room..... I have been to lot of audiophile place where they claim they have done a proper sound acoustic treatment in the room , but end up they only follow what they saw in concert hall or other audiophile place, and it sound crap and measured crap than room without those "acoustic treatment" ...... [ ] |
|