忘記密碼
 立即註冊
樓主: chucky7

美國網路直售喇叭和超低音的經營生態和使用觀點

[複製鏈接]

34

主題

1311

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Da Man

舊站積分
1718
舊站發表文章數
1326
 樓主| 發表於 2017-6-19 11:27:32 | 顯示全部樓層
本來 Marc 打算在 網聚之前要把目前他家裡所有的重低音都測試 CEA 2010 Max Burst 完畢. 但他截至目前為止只 "正確" 測試了:

網友的 DIY L-Horn (就是那台大隻老),
JTR Captivator 118HT,
PSA V1801,
Rythmik FV18,

我看他有可能不會測試以下的...

JTR Captivator 1400,
PSA S1500,
PSA S3000i,
Seaton F18 Master + Slave,
Seaton Submersive HP,
Seaton MFW-15 Turbo,

綜合上個禮拜聽過的, 這次我們聆聽了:

JTR Captivator 118HT,
JTR Captivator 1400,
PSA V1801,
Rythmik FV18,
Seaton MFW-15 Turbo,
Seaton F18 Master + Slave,
L-Horn.

還好現在市面上所有 $2000 以內 18 吋反射式重低音我們都聽過了.

6月10號測試過的, 很可惜的, 因為設備設定錯誤, 數據有問題.

34

主題

1311

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Da Man

舊站積分
1718
舊站發表文章數
1326
 樓主| 發表於 2017-6-19 13:09:00 | 顯示全部樓層
以下是目前 Mark 的評論:

http://www.avsforum.com/forum/61 ... 2.html#post53567121

We were able to get the Submersive, JL F113, & FV18 tested. In the middle of the Captivator 118 testing it got too windy so we went inside and played clips.

Most impressive to me? Easily the Cap 1400 and F18+!

chucky7 is going to help me with more outdoor testing this morning. @asarose247 will drop off his DIY creation as well today.

I have to speak to Brian Ding about the FV18 as there were some problems outdoors and indoors.

http://www.avsforum.com/forum/11 ... 6.html#post53590537

Right now I have both the F18+ and 2400W Submersive HP downstairs in the den (along with several other subs). Because this is an open concept room with multiple wide openings ported subs have a distinct advantage (no cabin gain down low). The ported subs I have can output more than the PB16 with @chucky7 's JTR Captivator 1400 (2015) being the decisive favorite.

The Submersive HP was very clean but lacked the wallop of the ported subs. The F18+ on the other hand was a force to be reckoned with (I didn't even connect the slave!). The extra low end provided the cleanest, most detailed bass of the day IMO. The Cap 1400 still has the advantage in brute force but the F18+ was no slouch.

When the F18s go upstairs to my sealed media room (3020 ft³) they are going to be most impressive!

For next week's GTG I will have the slave connected and we will see what the F18s can really do. I also now have one of @asarose247 's horns (it's bigger than Shaq O'Neil, literally).

Long story short I would talk to Mark Seaton about the room. The 4000W Submersive amp has the LF Adjust to bolster the low-end and likely give you more of what I experienced with a single F18+. The HP master+slave is going to give ~9dB more headroom than your original Submersive.

I do have the MFW-15 Turbos but it looks like I have to add a third-party​. They are so good nearfield in the den that my wife wants one behind her chair too! I feel like the MFW gives the V1801 a run for its money. I hoping to complete measurements between them soon (stay tuned). It would be a good idea to discuss them with Mark S. as well.

http://www.avsforum.com/forum/61 ... 4.html#post53717817

Well, the GTG was successful. We did no blind, ABX, or any such testing so read no further if that is all you care about. We did have fun and most specifically compared the ported subs chuffing characteristics. Something generally ignored by CEA-2010 numbers.

I learned a lot through this entire process. It was great being able to pick the brains of the greats: Brian Ding, Nathan Funk, Jeff Permanian, and Mark Seaton. The numbers for the JTR Captivator 118HT are surprisingly close to Ricci's at DB. The numbers at and below 20Hz are a bit off due to what I believe is either microphone noise, my neighbor's swimming pool pump, or a combination of both. I have attached the CSL report for the calibrated Dayton EMM-6 mic which has a measured noise level of 30 dBA which I believe to be high. A profile of that noise is also attached. I need to capture the noise levels inside of my media room to determine what is environmental and what is the mic itself.

I will be posting more details and numbers Sunday morning. I will say the best sub overall was easily @asarose247 's L-Horn which rendered the most perfect versions of the Tron Legacy and Interstellar clips (above 20 Hz) at 15dB hot! The best ported sub there was easily the JTR Captivator 1400 (2015). Ok, not fair and not what everyone really wants to know. Stay tuned for the rest as I need to get some rest!

34

主題

1311

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Da Man

舊站積分
1718
舊站發表文章數
1326
 樓主| 發表於 2017-6-19 13:14:04 | 顯示全部樓層
網友 DIY L-Horn 的數據:



http://www.avsforum.com/forum/61 ... 4.html#post53730017

Marc 的評論:

Ok, it is time for some numbers and my personal impressions. I am going to start with my top choice for overall SQ. @asarose247 's L-Horn (powered by an INuke 6000DSP). This is the first horn loaded sub I have heard and I am impressed! While it doesn't have much output below 20Hz, it was so incredibly detailed in its pass-band. There is good tactile feel as the horn moves some air but their is no turbulence noise of chuffing like a ported sub. Did I mention gobs of headroom? We listened to all subs at +10dB above reference except for the L-Horn. +15dB seemed more appropriate. After hearing the Tron Legacy and Interstellar clips on the L-Horn I was sold. We did miss a chance to hear how the EoT intro was handled. It was the end of the day and this was the last sub we listened to before packing up.

I am reattaching the 2m groud plane measurements as originally I reported peak values and not RMS. I have subtracted 3dB for 2m RMS GP. The limiters in the INuke were set conservatively so this beast is capable of even more. It was also significantly hotter outside when the measurements were taken vs the other subs. I really should have taken sweeps outdoors so that William can investigate the significant decrease at 40Hz. It's on the to-do list.

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
發表於 2017-6-20 17:53:57 | 顯示全部樓層
最近發現了這篇Audioholics的文:
History of Multi-Sub & Sound Field Management (SFM) for Small Room Acoustics  
by  Dr. Floyd Toole


裡面有不少關於這位大師的早期聲學發現與新的發展, 像是雙超低音~多超低音的概念, 到新的低頻處理研究(SFM)等, 很不錯的資訊提供參考.

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
發表於 2017-6-21 02:34:26 | 顯示全部樓層
Youtube有這段 Dr. Toole接受錄音的訪談,主題是 Get your music listening right

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/7vn6hQHRgzk" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

11'10"  全向發聲喇叭的看法.

12'30"  空間大小在重播上的不同

15'30"  家中的重播跟現場音樂會 最大的鴻溝是包圍感自然度 愈多的數量比較有機會接近但..

18'10" 重播上讓小空間有大空間的感受比較做得到,大空間重播上聽起來像小空間幾乎不可能.
像是小空間的親密感就很難在大空間感受到.

19'40"  空間大vs小..另一個大差異是bass. 小空間侷限度大處理難度也大.


在大約22'~ 講到有關多顆超低音, 跟前帖提到的連結文有類似的說明.

23'30"~ 他的自家空間的多顆超低音使用經驗與好處; 當初如何發現用多顆超低音的想法(據稱是第一位在論文上公開發表此作法者).

25'~ Center (real) speakers vs phantom imaging ( 2ch stereo)

28'30"~ 多顆超低音的應用可減低EQ的使用需求度等.

36'50"~ 論"SFM" Sound Field Management 亦可參考前文

39'30"~ 近場擺法

41'40"~ Sub Crawl works esp for single sub

43'~ 長方形空間的黃金比例不見得都很靈光? 正方形空間不見得藥石罔效..

59'~ 從知名的長方形(鞋盒狀)音樂廳的聽感體驗談側方環繞, 前側方環繞(wide spk)對聽/看音樂會的應用

1hr 15'~ Predicting listener preferences based on scientific measurement 主觀聽感與客觀測量種種

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
發表於 2017-6-21 02:52:20 | 顯示全部樓層
另外提供這篇也是youtube上的影音, 很豐富的內容:

Floyd Toole - Sound reproduction – art and science/opinions and facts

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/zrpUDuUtxPM" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>



前篇的錄音訪談有某些地方跟這篇是重複的, 尤其是最後那部份.

為方便觀看且順便作功課,還花了時間將裡面大部分的的幻燈片截圖, 在某些slide 中加上少許的
中文簡述心得, 有興趣不妨點進去看看, 如果發現問題請不吝交流指教.

<a data-flickr-embed="true"  href="https://www.flickr.com/photos/kenwulandlord/albums/72157682403037043" title="F. Toole&#x27;s Sound Reproduction slides"><img src="https://c1.staticflickr.com/5/4213/35380455256_3410e3db88_c.jpg" width="800" height="450" alt="F. Toole&#x27;s Sound Reproduction slides"></a><script async src="//embedr.flickr.com/assets/client-code.js" charset="utf-8"></script>



===============================

補充此影音片段內容/時間碼
(討論來源: http://forums.slimdevices.com/sh ... -opinions-and-facts )



12:00 - chart of blind test vs. sighted test
14:00 - more influence from sighted listening
16:30 - "imagined differences between speaker wires", "complete marketing"
21:00 - ability to listen "through" rooms; differentiate room from speaker contributions
28:00 - importance of off-axis performance (KEF 105.2) and room
32:00 - importance of position and "corruption of all bass frequencies in small rooms"
34:30 - importance of better loudspeaker (rather than just EQ)
36:30 - "cold scientific measures" can correlate numbers with perceived quality
38:00 - interesting comments on "room equalization", transition frequency, contributions of speakers vs. room
42:00 - complexity of measurements of rooms - live production vs. reproduction, importance of hardware & software
44:00 - "Science in the service of art is our business."
45:30 - "Variable recordings" due to "circle of confusion" with poor speakers in control rooms.
48:00 - Consumer Reports reviews meaningless - "doing it wrong"
50:00 - 0.86 correlation between objective anechoic data and subjective evaluation of 70 speakers
51:00 - Consumer Reports vs. their tests!
52:00 - "Audiophile" $2000 speakers put through the test... Flatter and smoother better.
53:30 - "Whose opinion can we trust" - only selected with normal hearing then trained, then retail sales people, then audio reviewers
56:00 - Relative ranking between groups still good (so long as we know what we're listening to)
57:00 - "Olive's predictive algorithm" - flat, constant radiation pattern, no resonance, 1/20-octave better than 1/3-octave, bass performance 30% of subjective
1:00:00 - can we predict quality from manufacturer's specs?
1:02:00 - speakers are minimum phase devices - explanation. Active speakers is the "future".
1:03:00 - point of diminishing returns in speaker quality, example of $1800 good and $11,000 bad electrostatic speaker
1:05:00 - $24000/pair example... "Meets spec but no prizes", "Disappointing at the price"; then $16000 +/- 1dB speaker (discussion about consistency, esp small companies)
1:09:00 - sound today "way better" than 10 years ago and certainly 20 years ago... due to measurements, standardization
1:10:00 - importance of the recording, measuring neutrality
1:12:00 - measurement of JBL M2 in different rooms (transition zone 200Hz)

34

主題

1311

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Da Man

舊站積分
1718
舊站發表文章數
1326
 樓主| 發表於 2017-6-21 10:00:18 | 顯示全部樓層
以下是一個曾經擁有 JTR 喇叭和重低音的同好 現在的家庭劇院...  [:O] [:O] [:O]



看了只能說... 叔叔有練過, 小孩子不要亂學...

美國這種的同好還真不少... 從市面上買得到的品牌喇叭畢業, 投入 DIY...

34

主題

1311

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Da Man

舊站積分
1718
舊站發表文章數
1326
 樓主| 發表於 2017-6-21 12:08:09 | 顯示全部樓層

洛杉磯網聚隨筆報導 1:

我本來以為參加的網友會有提供詳盡的評比, 現在看起來好像不會了... [8)] 到目前為止, Mark 已經表示了他的感想, 其他就只有兩位網友對當天的重低音表示意見...

我就從 5 月中知道有網聚開始說起來龍去脈好了. 我會盡量就我所知的陳述, 也盡量按照時間順序. 這次活動當然是有贏家也有輸家...

自 Marc 宣佈要辦網聚後, Rythmik 和 JTR 都很有意思的寄了一台重低音給 Marc 測試. Marc 是在 5 月十幾號收到 Rythmik 的 FV18. 他也在家庭房內跑過了極限音壓圖:





他認為 FV18 還挺不賴的, 最大輸出也符合它的身價. 設定正確的話, 15Hz 頻率以上的失真不會超過10%. 這是非常正面的評語, 因為 Marc 比較喜歡封閉式重低音. 之前專屬視聽室10坪大小, 也是用 PSA 封閉式喇叭, 過了幾天, 他也收到了 JTR Captivator 118HT. 我等到 6 月初, 他應該夠時間 run in 後, 問他這兩台的感想.

34

主題

1311

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Da Man

舊站積分
1718
舊站發表文章數
1326
 樓主| 發表於 2017-6-22 02:00:57 | 顯示全部樓層
緊急插播一下...

在6月17號的網聚後, 有不少網友對音質表現傑出的 Seaton Sound 封閉式重低音 F18系統有興趣. Mark Seaton 決定延長特價優惠期限至 6月 26 號. 原本優惠在 6月15 號已經截止.

對封閉式重低音情有獨鍾的同好們可以參考看看.

Seaton Sound F18+, 18 吋單體, 4000 瓦擴大機板. 若是沒有接僕人則只有 1400 瓦. 最多可以接 3 台 僕人, 這樣每一台功率是 1400 瓦. 尺寸是 24.25" 高 x 23.5" 寬 x 18" 深, 重量是 115 磅. 標準外觀為黑楓木原木貼皮, 原價是 美金 $2,295, 特價是 $2,195. 運費外加.

Seaton Sound F18, 18 吋單體. 尺寸同主人. 接主人時每一台功率是 1400 瓦. 標準外觀為黑楓木原木貼皮, 原價是美金 $1,095, 特價是 $995. 運費外加.

以下為黑橡木原木貼皮 (加價 $100) 外表:









聯結有更多美圖: https://www.seaton-sound-forum.com/post/f18-f18slave-8044371

更多詳情: http://seatonsound.net/

226

主題

6231

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3604
舊站發表文章數
5787
發表於 2017-6-22 02:13:31 | 顯示全部樓層
Marc的分享已經很豐富了, 當天參與者大概是沒找到什麼可補充的了. 感謝舉辦者與參與者提供一個網上觀摩的機會.
其實我還蠻期待那位Sanjay ( sdurani )的分享, 多年來常看到他的文.
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-18 23:39 , Processed in 0.219247 second(s), 41 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表