新手上路
五星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 4615
- 舊站發表文章數
- 3354
|
發表於 2025-10-14 15:35:36
|
顯示全部樓層
引述兩個傳輸式喇叭的評論供參考,分別是 Jean-Marie Reynaud Twin Mk.III loudspeaker Measurements 和 PMC IB-1S loudspeaker Measurements @stereophile.com
Some of the JM Reynaud's measured performance is excellent—the even lateral dispersion, the clean waterfall plot, the smoothly balanced midrange and low treble. It will also be an easy amplifier load. However, looking at the lower-frequency behavior, the woofer's twin-coil arrangement doesn't seem to extend the bass to any useful extent. I can only assume that, yet again, a designer has been betrayed by the empty promises of a so-called "transmission line" woofer alignment into producing a version of a reflex design that doesn't go particularly low in frequency yet suffers from resonances in the upper bass and midband.
The PMC's measured performance in the midrange and treble are both excellent, throwing into sharp relief its relative lack of achievement in the bass. As Kal notes in his Sidebar on transmission lines, I am somewhat skeptical of the concept. Unfortunately, the PMC IB-1S doesn't mitigate my prejudice against the concept, its low-frequency idiosyncrasies being due, in my opinion, to its TL design. I feel that a more conventional reflex, or even sealed-box, alignment would have produced a better all-around speaker design. |
|