忘記密碼
 立即註冊
樓主: lwc

Harbeth同學會

[複製鏈接]

1

主題

1332

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
48
舊站發表文章數
1154
發表於 2007-4-16 22:48:30 | 顯示全部樓層

Different brands, different sounds. Why?

我將完整轉貼此討論串ifferent brands, different sounds. Why?
及個人一些簡單的看法與心得. 所有文章 皆經原廠同意轉載.


原始發文:
Originally Posted by LD31

I am home listening to my M30's and to a pair of Spendor S8e's : the S8e's are very good, but the M30's are better in any aspect! How can a speaker be so good? After just a few seconds it has become evident that the M30's bass, medium and treble are better. More definition, more slam in the bass, while easy to listen, not agressive. And both speakers cost approximately the same price ... Congratulations for building such a good speaker! Laurent.

用家主要提到M30的表現及
恭喜Alan能生產如此好的喇叭.

我也很好奇 這兩對喇叭的國際售價, 到Audiogon搜尋如下,
提供參考:
Ebony特別版 & Eucalyptus M30  USD4,700
http://cls.audiogon.com/cgi-bin/cls.pl?spkrmoni&1180659968
http://cls.audiogon.com/cgi-bin/cls.pl?spkrmoni&1181533720
Cherry M30  USD4,300
http://cls.audiogon.com/cgi-bin/cls.pl?spkrfull&1179896905

S8e USD3,200
http://cls.audiogon.com/cgi-bin/cls.pl?spkrfull&1181591843
http://cls.audiogon.com/cgi-bin/cls.pl?spkrfull&1181251326

多少還是有些價差, 至於台灣售價, 就有賴讀者自行搜尋比較.
   絕代好聲 ~☆ HARBETH ☆~ 新湖科技 試聽預約-0928226657

1

主題

1332

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
48
舊站發表文章數
1154
發表於 2007-4-16 23:02:13 | 顯示全部樓層
#1:Alan的回答:

Thank you for your kind comments.

I can't recall if I have heard those speakers, so I'll just comment generally, but I think you make an interesting point that neither styling, cabinet size, number of drive units nor marketing can disguise the sonic signature (or not) of a speaker system.

The (expensive) engineering software tools to create cabinets and design crossovers have been available for many years to speaker designers. I assume that all speaker designers are familiar with these tools and know how to drive them to avoid garbage-in, garbage-out. Yet the differences in sound quality between even ostensibly similar brands with, on the face of it similar heritage is as great or greater than ever. Why is that? Is it an engineering issue or something else?

To answer that we need to really get into the mind of the designer - or design team - and to understand exactly what sort of sonic picture they were attempting to paint in sound with their design. This is exactly what we see with fine art painting: take a look at the attached Picasso1 and Turner jpg's. Neither painting is a photographic rendition, neither are completely faithful to life, both are, as it were, a mirror held up to the original. Which is more accurate? Which one communicates more to you? Which one do you prefer? Or would you prefer a pin-sharp photograph to remind you of what you observed actually being there?

Personally I'd say that compared with the image we'd see were we actually at the scene, the Turner is closer to reality and in that sense more 'accurate', more of a concert hall experience. Clearly Picasso was capable of painting in a more 'accurate' style (see Picasso2 picture) but he chose not to. Why? What was he trying to communicate? How could this duality of style exist in one mind? Why do many prefer to own an 'inaccurate' Picasso rather than an accurate photograph? Answer this and we begin to understand why there are so many speaker models available.

My design objective is clear and simple: I wish to present a photograph in sound of the original recording with as accurate colour, focus and resolution as technology (and my skills) allow 'nothing added, nothing taken away'. Of course, you may prefer the Picasso experience, but I'm not capable of giving it to you!

=======================================

此文提到3張照片, 不知同學能否幫忙轉貼, 可能更易瞭解.
翻譯我不是很在行, 而且我可能比新同學spottyhamster還懶.
還是有請李兄幫忙翻譯.
PS:神秘禮物即將揭曉.[] []
   絕代好聲 ~☆ HARBETH ☆~ 新湖科技 試聽預約-0928226657

1

主題

1332

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
48
舊站發表文章數
1154
發表於 2007-4-16 23:07:21 | 顯示全部樓層
#2  Posted by LD31

Hi Alan,

You wrote: "My design objective is clear and simple: I wish to present a photograph in sound...":

I am afraid that this was also the objective of the designers of the S8e's and of most speakers!
   絕代好聲 ~☆ HARBETH ☆~ 新湖科技 試聽預約-0928226657

1

主題

1332

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
48
舊站發表文章數
1154
發表於 2007-4-16 23:12:45 | 顯示全部樓層
#3 Posted by Alan


Maybe or maybe not. Again, looking across the whole global industry, there are substantial differences between the way we work here inside Harbeth and inside other well known brands. Let's call it 'Pressure From On High'. Here, there is no PFOH on me. I'm the boss. I own the company. I don't have to answer to shareholders. Or co-designers or co-directors. I answer, daily, year in year out, to customers who demand and expect us to perform acoustic miracles and who are willing to invest their hard earned cash my Harbeth products.*

I shoulder total responsibility - alone - for conception and design. No other person listens to my new design between the fleeting first idea right through to production commencing. I do not want or need the reassurance of others as the design progresses because I am my own most savage, uncompromising, brutal critic. Also during the design process I do not have the time or patience to unravel the complexities of its 3D mental jigsaw puzzle and to explain it piecemeal, day by day to others for approval. This is not art. Or it shouldn't be!

I only undertake the design of a loudspeaker system if I'm absolutely confident in advance that it will sell, that it genuinely moves the audio frontier forward, is a taxing and testing intellectual challenge for me and that it will successfully stand up to external objective evaluation against my design objective. The fun bit comes from teasing the last drops of performance - running faster than the pack. I have stated that I am trying to paint a photographic image in sound so it is inappropriate to compare my approach with say, a Daliesque rendition, fine and attractive though that may be. We know what we are good at.

The business culture inside other speaker companies is totally different. Their salaried designers are kept on a short lead and a narrow brief and suffer constant and contradictory interference from other departments: marketing, cost control, sales, production etc. etc.. You'd be amazed how many amateur speaker designers there are in these departments! This design-by-group reflects in the final feel and styling of such products and also in their sonic signature which is always compromised. It would take a bold marketing man to stand up in such a political environment and say 'our new speaker just doesn't sound right ....' and a fearless designer to add '... yes, I agree, but with all the pressures and constraints you've put upon me, what do you expect?' In reality what happens is that the marketing department puts a positive spin on whatever has dropped out of the design process - good, bad or indifferent.

There is one possible downside to the way we work here depending on your perspective: I am - indeed I have to be - innately conservative. I'm not a risk taker because I treasure and appreciate what we together (we here, you there) have built these past thirty years. Is conservatism a successful business model for the modern fast-moving world? It is, but only if the scale of operation is relatively small and the product performance is exemplary from the start.

* Many of our customers save cash from their wages every week over 3-4 years to be able to afford a Harbeth. They live in a cash economy where credit is not available. When they buy, they buy carefully. And they buy for keeps.
__________________
Alan A. Shaw

====================================
此文之前李同學首次轉貼 也翻譯的很好
大意可看之前的討論串. []
   絕代好聲 ~☆ HARBETH ☆~ 新湖科技 試聽預約-0928226657

1

主題

1332

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
48
舊站發表文章數
1154
發表於 2007-4-16 23:21:10 | 顯示全部樓層
#4 Posted by LD31


Alan,

I understand, it is as clear as the music coming out of my M30's!

It reminds me my own experience of last year: I have published a book "Himalayan Trails"

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Himala-Y ... ie=UTF8&s=books

I am not at all a publisher nor a professional book designer of photograph.

I have worked hard and done everything myself (like you for the speakers): trekking 11 times in the Himalayas, taking 6000+ photographs, designing the book cover, maps, layout etc., writing the text in French and in English, finding a good printer, finding a good reseller etc.

I thought: "your book will be ridiculous, nobody will buy it; you will be competing with many renowned publishers with skilled designers, writers etc., and with famous professional writers or alpinists who climbed Everest by difficult faces without oxygen etc."

Surprisingly, the book has been highly acclaimed, and most copies have been sold in a few months, although I was totally unknown to the public, as I am not a star!

Like you, I could take decisions quickly, mastering completely my project, buying good equipement (such as a good 24 inches monitor), not wasting time in meetings etc.


BTW, I have just purchased the issue 171 of "The Absolute Sound", it contains an extremely positive paper on the HL Compact 7ES-3, congratulations!

Here is their conclusion: "Indeed, with respect to its class and design type— compact two-way in a box—this speaker sets, in my experience, a new benchmark in neutrality and natural tonal balance over its usable range, regardless of price."

Wow!
=================================

原來這位M30同學是Traveller, 同時也是位Author.
跋涉喜瑪拉雅山11次, 照了超過6000張照片.
而且已經出書. [:O] [:O]
   絕代好聲 ~☆ HARBETH ☆~ 新湖科技 試聽預約-0928226657

1

主題

1332

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
48
舊站發表文章數
1154
發表於 2007-4-16 23:30:53 | 顯示全部樓層
#5  Posted by Danrubin


Alan, your painting/photograph analogy (or is it a metaphor) is absolutely brilliant.

I have thought for some time that a clever reviewer could assemble a collection of visual images (photos, paintings, etc.) to use as a standard reference for describing the sonic character of components. Some are abstract but beautiful paintings, some are hyperdetailed photographs, some are overexposed photographs, etc. This visual analogy works very well for me... but that's me.
   絕代好聲 ~☆ HARBETH ☆~ 新湖科技 試聽預約-0928226657

1

主題

1332

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
48
舊站發表文章數
1154
發表於 2007-4-16 23:32:59 | 顯示全部樓層
#6 Posted by Alan

Designing by committee - more, more, more ...

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Thanks.

I've been mulling over in more detail the process of 'design by committee' based upon my own experience in a previous life within a large corporation. I've been recalling interminable meetings in (then) smoke filled rooms going round in circles about the specification of new products.

What I now see is that in a group discussion product-planning situation the outcome is always product embellishement ... everyone involved want to stamp their own mark on the product and they do this by adding features. This is precisely the situation in car design or mobile phones. The basic model becomes loaded-up with features and gizmos and often the manufacturing costs (and durability) are hammered down. Cars have to go faster, have bigger tyres, stop quicker, corner better.

In loudspeakers this probably translates into fancy curvy cabinetwork, more drive units, exotic finishes and especially - more bass and/or more middle and/or more top. After all, more must surely be better?
__________________
Alan A. Shaw
   絕代好聲 ~☆ HARBETH ☆~ 新湖科技 試聽預約-0928226657

1

主題

1332

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
48
舊站發表文章數
1154
發表於 2007-4-16 23:35:42 | 顯示全部樓層
#7 Posted by Danrubin

You might enjoy the little video parody link below. Although it relates to packaging and not to the actual product, it reflects the same well-intentioned but ultimately misguided corporate phenomenon. [I am having deja-vu about posting this before. If so, apologies.]

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=36099539665548298
   絕代好聲 ~☆ HARBETH ☆~ 新湖科技 試聽預約-0928226657

1

主題

1332

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
48
舊站發表文章數
1154
發表於 2007-4-16 23:39:20 | 顯示全部樓層
#8 Posted by Alan

Quote:
Originally Posted by danrubin
http://video.google.com/videoplay?do...99539665548298
=============================================


Depressingly believable. It makes a valuable point that it is much more difficult to market less than to market more. Is Harbeth the Apple of the speaker world where less is very definitely more?

(My 19 year old , studying Marketing at University is Apple mad and dreams of working for them!)
__________________
   絕代好聲 ~☆ HARBETH ☆~ 新湖科技 試聽預約-0928226657

1

主題

1332

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
48
舊站發表文章數
1154
發表於 2007-4-16 23:43:19 | 顯示全部樓層
#9 Posted by Alan

Trekking in the Himalayas - alone.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Quote:
Originally Posted by LD31
It reminds me my own experience of last year: I have published a book "Himalayan Trails"

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Himala-Y ... ie=UTF8&s=books

I have worked hard and done everything myself (like you for the speakers) trekking 11 times in the Himalayas, taking 6000+ photographs

=============================================

I have followed your link and I am astonished by your comittment and professionalism. You deserve to be highly successful with your book. Your hard work puts me to shame!

__________________
Alan A. Shaw
   絕代好聲 ~☆ HARBETH ☆~ 新湖科技 試聽預約-0928226657
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-22 04:58 , Processed in 0.123408 second(s), 40 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表