新手上路
Da Man
- 舊站積分
- 1718
- 舊站發表文章數
- 1326
|
樓主 |
發表於 2017-7-23 12:14:05
|
顯示全部樓層
Marc 即將對這次南加州 LA 地區 聆聽/測試 過的反射式產品做總結. ( 迷之音: 2個禮拜前不是就是說過要出報告了... 我等到花也謝了. )
Now that I have re-listened to the Rythmik FV18 (now for the final time) laying horizontally and with @enricoclaudio 's PEQ recommendations I am ready to wrap up my full impressions and put on my flame suit.
Every wonder why every consumer electronics review you read is overwhelmingly positive? Even when a Consumer Reports tries to be objective their qualifications/expertise are called into question and the results invalidated when not matching the agenda of rabid fans. I find myself in the same position as CR. I simply want to help consumers make educated decisions to maximize the satisfaction of their purchases in regards to their expectations. But some think that I have a hidden, ego driven agenda.
The GTG format is great. I can't imagine the backlash there would be if there were not 15 witnesses! I really believe we need the GTGs to really understand the performance of these subwoofers. While CEA-2010 may identify objective limits it really does not tell the story of how a sub performs. From the time this GTG was planned until now I have learned so much. The manufacturers have been so gracious in the giving of their time to explain intricacies of their subwoofer's designs to a me, a neophyte. Brian Ding, Jim Farina, Nathan Funk, Jeff Permanian, and Mark Seaton... all knowledgeable and professional.
I will admit my preference for sealed subs coming into the GTG. For 20 years I have owned nothing but ported subs (from the likes of Klipsch, Energy, and Mirage). I only discovered sealed subs when we moved into a house with a dedicated room and no neighbors to worry about. I had been on hiatus from AVS for ~7 years and found there were more options than just SVS and HSU now. I had been EQ'ing my subs with a BFD, RS SPL meter, and a excel spreadsheet since my first 5.1 system so I knew how important placement flexibility was. I had no idea what cabin vessel gain was or that single digit extension was even possible. My first $1k subs were a pair of PSA S1500s. In my downstairs den I had a pair of ported Energy S12.3s (equivalent to the HSU VTF-3.1). Now that I had no volume constraints I learned how port noises can detract from an experience. I replaced the Energy's with a pair of Seaton Sound MFW-15s which handled the space far better than the Energys.
Once we were able to attract a nice lineup of ported subs, I knew I wanted to include port noise evaluations as a part. Perhaps I let some other members get in my head, but I suspected that the variable tune Rythmik FV18 with its 3.5" ports was not going to fare well (especially not with a port plugged). The PSA V1801 came in as the benchmark in this regard: is it worth $400-500 more than the MFW-15 Turbo and are the Rythmik and JTRs worth $300+ more than the PSA? I did not expect any of these subs to be able have the headroom to fill a 7500^3 ft space with large openings to the rest of the house, so it was to be a torture test from the beginning.
I'm separating each sub into a separate post which I reserve the right to edit and append, starting from #4 to #1
4. Seaton Sound MFW-15 Turbo
3. Power Sound Audio V1801
2. Rythmik FV18
1. JTR Captivator 118HT
I removed the JTR Cap 1400 (2005) from the list as it was basically a 118HT on steroids. I will discuss it in the JTR post. Plus, it was further improved at the beginning of the year (2017).
現在最後排名是
1. JTR Captivator 118HT
2. Rythmik FV18
3. Power Sound Audio V1801
4. Seaton Sound MFW-15 Turbo
JTR Captivator 1400 不列入, 因為它根本是 JTR Captivator 118HT 浩克加強版 [} ] [} ] [} ]... 我們這次聆聽到的是 我的 2015 年份 Cap 1400. 2017 年份的 Cap 1400 Jeff 又有優化過 [8D]. |
|