新手上路
二星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 20
- 舊站發表文章數
- 117
|
發表於 2006-9-14 09:56:07
|
顯示全部樓層
Re: Beethoven Cello sonatas Starker/Bogin
原發表者是 hsindao
[B]
Starker and Bogin commanded one of the best, if not the best, Beethoven cello sonatas I have heard. Starker's playing usually tended to be on the cool side but he is warm and musical in this set.
The real star is the pianist Abba Bogin though. Piano carries a bigger part than cello in all of Beethoven's cello/piano music. The light and spirited touch of Bogin defined the pace and the mood of this music. The sonata just flows through and before one realized it, one side is over. On the contrary, the Rostropovich/Richter set on Philips was rather cool and mechanical. I grew up with the Rostropovich set but now I rarely even want to open it.
This is a mono recording that was recorded at far field. It has no high, no low but with good natural hall ambiance. The pressing on Period record is slightly noisy but not particularly worse than those early mono Columbia 6-eye pressing. It is also not a collector item from what I have seen on Ebay. I have a 2-record set. A single LP was sold for about USD20 the last time I saw it. [/B]
Hsindao,
Starker's recordings on Period were done in the mid50s before Hi-Fi era, when the mono recording technology was not so good, so his Beethoven sonatas or concertos were no value on Ebay actually, as he did at least two stereo recordings of Beethoven complete cello sonatas, which performance and recordings are much better than his first set.
Anyhow I would recommend you to buy his three most valuable recordings on Period.
Kodaly: unaccompanied cello suite, this one values over USD100 on Ebay. The recording is extremely good with clear cello texture.
Bach: unaccompanied cello suites, but only two records, he did not complete the suites till the well-known Mercury set. Actually this Period recordings are not bad, the cello is bigger and deeper than Mercury. The Ebay price is not as high as Mercury. A good choice out of Mercury. I played these two records more than my Mercury originals. |
|