新手上路
四星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 48
- 舊站發表文章數
- 1154
|
發表於 2007-10-23 20:10:48
|
顯示全部樓層
Harbeth Boss " Mr. Alan Shaw" 在Echoloft 新加玻
Harbeth Lovers Thread裡,於今天 10/23日發表的一篇文章,
提供大家參考:
"BBC buys other speakers"
Well it is true that in 2003/4 another (European) supplier was selected by a certain group inside the BBC to supply their particular monitoring needs. It is not - and could never be - a corporation-wide decision because the BBC is a democracy of sorts and good sound engineers (especially in the Regions, away from London's bureaucracy) simply will not be *told* what speakers, microphones or even coffee machines they *must* use. At the centre - London - decisions can be made and then pushed through as policy and if you don't like it you find yourself another job. In fact, as so many budgets within the BBC are related to specific programs - and programs come and go - studio staff often have to make short term/cheap purchase decisions simply because they don't have the cash to do better. What goes around seems to come around if you give it enough time.
Last Saturday I was invited to attend a BBC outside broadcast where the subject of speakers was raised by a very disgruntled producer. I have not met during the past 3 years one single BBC sound engineer or producer who is happy with the decision for this part of the BBC to move away from the 'traditional BBC sound'. Not one. And I've asked dozens. This particular Producer told me, and I've heard similar before, that he is in a state of constant fear that what he hears and mixes to in the studio is radically different to what he hears at home (on his 'traditional' speakers) and he finds that he is wasting time sweet talking clients/artists along the lines that 'don't worry, it will sound all right when you hear it at home yourself'.
How did this situation come about? First - key point - the BBC has not had a Director of Engineering for about 10 years. That means there is no qualified, identifiable individual driving 'best practice'. If you write a letter to 'The Chief Engineer, BBC' it will be returned to you, address unknown. That in turn means that decisions are made at a lower, operational level by non-experts and normally that is OK for electronic equipment. But speakers and microphones are special cases. They need to be listened to. Then they need to be assessed, graded, and ranked, and that is the work of trained listeners who know the little tricks that speakers can pull on you, not accountants and well intentioned non-specialists.
Looking back, we made three errors of judgement in responding to the BBC's tender.
1. We assumed (wrongly) that when the BBC wrote that they would conduct a listening test they would include behind the black curtain one or more reference speakers. Incredible as it may seem there was, apparently, no reference speaker of any type behind the curtain. There was no switch-over system because there was nothing to switch over to. Speakers were evaluated one at a time, serially, with about 30 minutes between them.
As for what reference speakers to put behind the curtain, I assumed, when I read the Tender and considering how I would construct such a test, that the listener(s) would be able to make instantaneous A-B switch-overs between the known reference speakers widely used - say the elderly LS5/8 or 3/5 of which the BBC then had hundreds - and the speaker under test. That's how I would have arranged things since those speakers whilst not perfect were widely known and had produced millions of hours of broadcast over 25+ years.
We were shocked to discovered some time after the listening session, by accident, that there had been no reference speakers. Anyone professionally associated with loudspeaker design or evaluation would warn that expecting listeners to recall, reliably, the sound of a speaker hours or days apart in unfamiliar surroundings on unfamiliar equipment and just 4 minutes or so of speech/music is really asking a lot. Instantaneous A-B switch over to a reference is MANDATORY for reliable conclusions to be drawn. It would be interesting to see the reaction of the Audio Engineering Society to the presentation of a paper at Conference - knowing what we all do about the dangers of evaluating speakers - which omitted A-B evaluation. I for one wouldn't have the nerve to stand up in front of Conference!
3. I was out of the country at the time and hence did not avail myself of the BBC's offer to all parties to 'set up the speakers for best effect in the listening room'. Some suppliers, went to town and using laptops, microphones, test gear apparently boosted the HF to compensate for the loss through the curtain plus whatever they considered necessary to make a really impressive demonstration. This was all permitted. And without an A-B reference for the listener to compare against, naturally some speakers were then at a psychoacoustic advantage. Others, with a softer, more relaxed sound, sounded as if they were (as they indeed were!) 2m behind the curtain in contrast with the incisive razor edge of some models that subjectively put the performers in front of the curtain. I am told that the final selection was then taken to the BBC's Anechoic chamber and measured, the assumption being that however and whatever they measured the subjective (and purchase) decision had been made.
Ironically, we did caution the BBC that as they moved to an all-glass construction for new generation studios the softer 'traditional' BBC-like sound would actually work with rather than against the lively acoustics but there was 'no interest, no budget' for mocking-up the lively acoustics. The listening tests were conducted in a heavily damped old-school disused studio. Furthermore, as I reported to the Institute of Broadcast Sound at the time, importing the BBC's semi-public document about the selection process into MS Word and then doing a keyword search did not find the words 'fatigue' (testing), 'field' (evaluation) or similar. In other words, based on the BBC's own semi-public document, the binding decision was made based on the brief listening sessions alone in the disused studio. It is also admitted in there (I quote from memory) that 'it is commercially expedient to buy the small, medium and big speakers from just one supplier even though the supplier in question's speakers were not necessarily the best in each size group'.
Although our sales to the BBC temporarily faltered, within 6 months and outside the specialist group I've mentioned in the BBC, they recovered and we never looked back. In fact, last Friday, a day after the BBC announced 2000 job cuts we received an order for another 4 pairs from sound engineers who have ears and the freedom to listen and decide for themselves.
As we have said from the very start .... 'don't believe us - go out and borrow other speakers, set them up in your own studio and A-B them'. To the best of my knowledge we have always won under those proper conditions.
==============================================
該討問串有很多Harbeth愛好者交換心得,
魏醫師的系統也被轉Post在該討論串中,[8D]
有興趣的同學, 可前往溜覽.
http://www.echoloft.com/cgi-bin/ ... 46732&start=705
[ ]
Joseph |
|