忘記密碼
 立即註冊
樓主: Brachy

Ekta DIY 筆記

[複製鏈接]

20

主題

4368

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
508
舊站發表文章數
4372
發表於 2011-1-17 20:16:56 | 顯示全部樓層
對於mic的要求有一個人是這麼回答的
...there is a DIN requirement for positive pressure to present positive voltage on pin 2, however, not all manufacturers follow this rule...

看您的量測:
If this is a sub woofer driver only, it seems that the cone is not very stiff, and there is not sufficient control in the 50~Hz region.  I tend to think your measurement is done with driver + enclosure.  The low pass filter would probably need to cross over low enough so that the high slew preringing is as small as possible preferably 40db below the hump.  If the measurement was done with the enclosure, the enclosure needs redesigning.[8D]
[url="http://augene.blogspot.com"]Hear The REAL Thing[/url] [url="http://www.augene-audio.com.tw"]感受藝人的心靈[/url]

197

主題

3310

回帖

50

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
1198
舊站發表文章數
2511
 樓主| 發表於 2011-1-17 22:15:32 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 soongsc
[B]對於mic的要求有一個人是這麼回答的
...there is a DIN requirement for positive pressure to present positive voltage on pin 2, however, not all manufacturers follow this rule...

看您的量測:
If this is a sub woofer driver only, it seems that the cone is not very stiff, and there is not sufficient control in the 50~Hz region.  I tend to think your measurement is done with driver + enclosure.  The low pass filter would probably need to cross over low enough so that the high slew preringing is as small as possible preferably 40db below the hump.  If the measurement was done with the enclosure, the enclosure needs redesigning.[8D] [/B]


Thank you for your comment!

First of all, this subwoofer is not designed by me. I'm not the

distributor of this subwoofer nor I could not benefit from this post

or the sale of this subwoofer. This forum is just for fun not for

conmercial purpose! From my measurement, this subwoofer can

easily beat many conmercial products in the market. As I

mentioned before, the more nearly so called "standard"

measurement for this subwoofer was not posted in this forum but

post in other forum.  (http://www.myav.com.tw/bbs/showt ... 12&pagenumber=5)

I believe the designer will be very happy that you provided all this

thought.

On the contrary, you are a founder of a speaker company.

However, you don't have any similar product could show to all of

us. To criticize a product is a relative easy job but to manufacture

a good product is an another thing.


Finally, back to our talk. You begin with a uncertainty phase

measurement. I provided the evidence that my measurement was

correct judged by compared 0, 180 and 90 degree of phase

measurement. Then you suspected that my microphone may not

has correct phase. I answered that my microphone is not just a

conmercial product but a professional measurement tool. I tried to

answer your comment or question by evidence but not my

personal though. If you did not like my post or this forum, please

just speak out. If you think this enclusure need re-designed,

please show me your talent and tell me what's wrong with this

enclosure. Please don't just leave a simple message that this

enclosure need to redesign. This kind of talk could not provide

any useful information to me or to other person but a question

that you really know this subwoofer or not. [] []


Correct me if I was wrong! []
聲音, 自己喜歡就好! 幸福, 就是有好老師! [:)]

20

主題

4368

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
508
舊站發表文章數
4372
發表於 2011-1-17 23:36:04 | 顯示全部樓層
First of all, I don't know what product the data is for, nor do I care.  I just look at the data and provide my point of view as anyone else can provide theirs.  Certainly, there are many other factors involved with a good design, so unless I see other data, I really cannot comment on how it sounds or whether it's better than anything else.  I think since you have listened to it, certainly you can provide your listening impressions.

Second, I do not believe that a separate subwoofer yeilds the performance I am looking for.  As a matter of fact, it's very difficult to even find adequate drivers that I feel acceptable.

Third, bear in mind that I am designing audio equipment because, as an audiophile, I feel the desire to design something that I feel acceptable without costing and arm and a leg.

Fourth, it is not my duty to provide instructions on how to improve a product in this forum.  I have provided opinions on subwoofer configuration, there are also other different views.  I have posted an example of a more ideal step response per your request.  So it's really up to you what you want to do.  There is also a good example on how to integrate a sub into main system.
http://www.linkwitzlab.com/thor-orion.htm
This site also documents 90% of what is necessary to take into consideration in speaker design, and Mr. Linkwitz does not consider himself a proffesional.  I do not consider myself a proffesional either.

It is my understanding that you are posting data because you want different opinions.  If you are not interested in technical opinions, don't post data.  Otherwise, it's best to focus on the technical issues rather than worry about who's product it is.  If you ask me an optinion that requires better understanding of the measurement and setup, I will ask for it.

As for your 90 deg measurement, exactly how that 90deg is accomplished will effect how you interpret data.  If you are referring to a phase shift knob on a subwoofer, then it's really necessary to see a frequency/phase response to see exactly what we are up against.  0 and 180 deg I assumed were just a polarity flip, but looking at the data, this is not the case.  The data seems to show an analog phase shift filter which is only effective in a very limited range centered around a design frequency.  Normally this is used to help smooth transition from the mains to the sub at the crossover frequency.  If you are not time aligning the sub with the mains, then this adjustment is really not so useful.  So just be careful with what is concluded.
[url="http://augene.blogspot.com"]Hear The REAL Thing[/url] [url="http://www.augene-audio.com.tw"]感受藝人的心靈[/url]

197

主題

3310

回帖

50

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
1198
舊站發表文章數
2511
 樓主| 發表於 2011-1-18 14:04:14 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 soongsc
[B]對於mic的要求有一個人是這麼回答的
...there is a DIN requirement for positive pressure to present positive voltage on pin 2, however, not all manufacturers follow this rule...

看您的量測:
If this is a sub woofer driver only, it seems that the cone is not very stiff, and there is not sufficient control in the 50~Hz region.  I tend to think your measurement is done with driver + enclosure.  The low pass filter would probably need to cross over low enough so that the high slew preringing is as small as possible preferably 40db below the hump.  If the measurement was done with the enclosure, the enclosure needs redesigning.[8D] [/B]


mic的問題不再與您談了, 因為我們有點雞同鴉講. 但事實勝於雄辯, 關於mic的

討論弟前面已經充分表達並附比較測試. 在下與非我本行的討論溝通中, 從不會r

先假設對方是錯的, 而是先仔細聽對方的描述與論點, 這樣才能避免溝通無效與

文不對題或建議錯誤! []



回到喇叭測量, 從您以上的回應就知道其實您並沒有仔細看弟的測試物與測試

內容就妄下自己的推論!! 若是連對方如何測與測什麼都還搞不清楚, 說實話,

弟也很難去相信接下來的評論有多少可信度!! 不管這意見是否來自專家[]

請問什麼樣的單體可以不裝箱, 卻可延伸超過20Hz?


只回應您對弟""重新設計喇叭箱""的意見, 超低音的喇叭箱算起來是最單純的

箱子設計. 先要主觀的決定採反射式或密閉式, 這兩者確實可以自測量數據看

的出來. 前面第一次post的是Rythmik F12頻響圖:


很明顯這是密閉式音箱, 下面是F15頻響圖:


自低頻平緩的衰減當然看的出是密閉式音箱! 以音箱設計來說, 弟看不出F12與

F15有何音箱設計不良的任何蛛絲馬跡. 若要說設計不良, 其實您必須先取得

該單體的T/S數據, 再核對密閉音湘採用的Q值, 最後看看F3是否有達成預定的

延伸, 這才能說出那個環節設計不良, 而非隨便丟一句破壞性的意見卻無法提供

證據. 若有朋友隨意就丟一句指稱soongsc設計喇叭的音箱要重新設計, 卻不

須提出數據或證據, 不知您會作何感想??


況且喇叭箱子設計變數本來就很多, 我喜歡Q=0.7, 但有人說不定喜歡Q=1.2,

這樣就要別人重設計, 可能只有自己適合卻不一定適合別人!


再者, 您自己說的您都是測試設計寬頻小單體喇叭, 不知您知不知道小單體與

中高頻訊號測量起來與超低音單體與低頻訊號, 其impulse response與

step response差多少? 若不知道, 沒關係, 小弟有空再post讓您看看.

就算小弟測量sub的impulase/step response不理想, 但更換測量方式已經

有趨近理想的趨勢. 這代表什麼? 這代表前面測得數據不漂亮是與測試環境有

關而非您的想法 - 喇叭箱要重設計! 若測試環境不改, 我保證您設計一千次,

還是得不到漂亮的數據的!


以上直言, 得罪處請見諒!
[]
聲音, 自己喜歡就好! 幸福, 就是有好老師! [:)]

20

主題

4368

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
508
舊站發表文章數
4372
發表於 2011-1-18 16:00:48 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 Brachy
[B]

mic的問題不再與您談了, 因為我們有點雞同鴉講. 但事實勝於雄辯, 關於mic的

討論弟前面已經充分表達並附比較測試. 在下與非我本行的討論溝通中, 從不會r

先假設對方是錯的, 而是先仔細聽對方的描述與論點, 這樣才能避免溝通無效與

文不對題或建議錯誤! []



回到喇叭測量, 從您以上的回應就知道其實您並沒有仔細看弟的測試物與測試

內容就妄下自己的推論!! 若是連對方如何測與測什麼都還搞不清楚, 說實話,

弟也很難去相信接下來的評論有多少可信度!! 不管這意見是否來自專家[]

請問什麼樣的單體可以不裝箱, 卻可延伸超過20Hz?


只回應您對弟""重新設計喇叭箱""的意見, 超低音的喇叭箱算起來是最單純的

箱子設計. 先要主觀的決定採反射式或密閉式, 這兩者確實可以自測量數據看

的出來. 前面第一次post的是Rythmik F12頻響圖:


很明顯這是密閉式音箱, 下面是F15頻響圖:


自低頻平緩的衰減當然看的出是密閉式音箱! 以音箱設計來說, 弟看不出F12與

F15有何音箱設計不良的任何蛛絲馬跡. 若要說設計不良, 其實您必須先取得

該單體的T/S數據, 再核對密閉音湘採用的Q值, 最後看看F3是否有達成預定的

延伸, 這才能說出那個環節設計不良, 而非隨便丟一句破壞性的意見卻無法提供

證據. 若有朋友隨意就丟一句指稱soongsc設計喇叭的音箱要重新設計, 卻不

須提出數據或證據, 不知您會作何感想??


況且喇叭箱子設計變數本來就很多, 我喜歡Q=0.7, 但有人說不定喜歡Q=1.2,

這樣就要別人重設計, 可能只有自己適合卻不一定適合別人!


再者, 您自己說的您都是測試設計寬頻小單體喇叭, 不知您知不知道小單體與

中高頻訊號測量起來與超低音單體與低頻訊號, 其impulse response與

step response差多少? 若不知道, 沒關係, 小弟有空再post讓您看看.

就算小弟測量sub的impulase/step response不理想, 但更換測量方式已經

有趨近理想的趨勢. 這代表什麼? 這代表前面測得數據不漂亮是與測試環境有

關而非您的想法 - 喇叭箱要重設計! 若測試環境不改, 我保證您設計一千次,

還是得不到漂亮的數據的!


以上直言, 得罪處請見諒!
[] [/B]

我是看數據說話
您是不爽對人攻擊
基本上我從未說你mic極性不對
我只是說看不出來是甚麼極性
您認為是正的我也假設是正的說明了
由於你是近場量測
最高峰之前的振盪是振膜某部分剛性不太好的現相
而由於這段約在50Hz剛好又似乎近裝箱的共振點Fs
所以認為箱子該重新設計
至於您所講0, 90, 180的量測我也提了並非全工作範圍的變化
對於我的判斷如果不對
所有資料都在你手上
儘管提出來證明我錯沒關係(我也幹過這種事)
但是只憑我公佈的東西就指控我沒經驗好像風度不是很好
你不同意我的看法我也不在意
多年前我第一次找人提供意見時也是意見很多
這些都是我成長的動力[]
我也花了很多時間去體會他們真正聽到的與量測數據的關連性
我已誠心表達了我的見解
我認為在不知品牌型號所提的評鑑較客觀
要動手改善的人瞭解這些細節比較重要
系統Q值只是在Fs 點不知您是指這個還是filter截止頻率的Q
問題點在這超低音的low pass端而不是high pass端
[url="http://augene.blogspot.com"]Hear The REAL Thing[/url] [url="http://www.augene-audio.com.tw"]感受藝人的心靈[/url]

62

主題

2361

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
742
舊站發表文章數
2367
發表於 2011-1-18 16:21:03 | 顯示全部樓層
兩位老大哥,小弟亂入插嘴一下,可能也文不對題,雞同鴨講,但可能就是就於網路文字的簡短與資訊的不完整,因此可能難免有所誤會與誤解.

Brachy兄對於量測很用心,礙於空間等因素,可能無法進行好的戶外量測或是無響室量測,因此可能採行近場量測(也似乎有採行遠場,不過似乎與較趨於標準化的遠場量測差異較大了些,因此小弟曾建議採戶外量測較方便),可是近場量測對於聲壓位準而言,只能說其趨勢尚可參.

soongsc兄可能是要提醒mic相位的問題,這是有趣的,不過一般若對於spk電聲量測有經驗者,這應該不是問題,往往這部分的問題多出現在錄音工程上.

OK.
那除了戶外可以量測低頻外,無響室能嗎?該如何做呢?

每個無響室本身都有它的截止頻率,當量測聲源的頻率低於截止頻率時將會造成誤差,所以在以無響室測低頻時,就是兩種解決方法為主,一是找一個具有很低截止頻率的無響室,二是用相減法.

20

主題

4368

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
508
舊站發表文章數
4372
發表於 2011-1-18 16:27:26 | 顯示全部樓層
Brachy是近場量測
我從數據看房間影響幾乎看不到
而這種量法能凸顯某些單體本身的問題
[url="http://augene.blogspot.com"]Hear The REAL Thing[/url] [url="http://www.augene-audio.com.tw"]感受藝人的心靈[/url]

62

主題

2361

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
742
舊站發表文章數
2367
發表於 2011-1-18 16:34:19 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 soongsc
[B]Brachy是近場量測
我從數據看房間影響幾乎看不到 [/B]


soongsc兄,沒關係.
小弟比較保守,寧請Brachy兄述明採用的量測法,暫不臆斷.

20

主題

4368

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
508
舊站發表文章數
4372
發表於 2011-1-18 16:36:08 | 顯示全部樓層
他已說是5cm處
[url="http://augene.blogspot.com"]Hear The REAL Thing[/url] [url="http://www.augene-audio.com.tw"]感受藝人的心靈[/url]

62

主題

2361

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
742
舊站發表文章數
2367
發表於 2011-1-18 16:57:34 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 soongsc
[B]他已說是5cm處 [/B]


喔!這樣呀!?那小弟可能沒注意看到,或看到已忘了.
近來煩務較多,sorry.
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-19 04:44 , Processed in 0.109138 second(s), 41 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表