新手上路
二星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 13
- 舊站發表文章數
- 142
|
發表於 2008-8-28 13:03:21
|
顯示全部樓層
A. Shaw文:
Now that, Rabbit, is an extremely astute observation and one I first observed about 20 years ago. In fact, the entire Harbeth RADIAL cone project directly spun off that observation.
What I suspect you are commenting on is this ... Bass/midrange cone materials have a sonic signature which is somewhat frequency dependent. At two extremes we have, say, a cone made of aluminium = a bright ringy sound with fake clarity i.e. zero damping (of the reproduced sound wave) and at the other extreme say, polypropylene with very high damping.
Counting pieces made and sold, most speaker cones in hifi speakers around the world are made from polypropylene sheet. PP was first patented as a speaker cone material by our founder when at the BBC for reasons of higher damping and avoidance of doping compared to first generation plastic, bextrene.
In the early 1990s, thanks to a Govt. grant we undertook the characterisation of all conceivable cone materials in a jig which shock and bent them across the audio band, still to our knowledge the only time this has been attempted. It slowly became clear that each material did indeed have a characteristic curve and we used to play 'guess the material' for beer money just from examining the material's characteristic graph plots with 100% accuracy.
Polypropylene has an unmistakeable damping curve shape - rather low at low frequencies and at a critical frequency (around 1kHz as I recall) pp 'takes-off' and by 3 or 4kHz, right at the crossover region to the tweeter, it becomes very highly damped. The acoustic consequence of this to my ears was/is that the air or space around the performers - the micro detail - is lost (as heat) inside the pp cone, never to be radiated as sound*. The canny designer hears this subconsciously but doesn't associate this with a fundamental characteristic of the cone, (and go about searching for a better material) but he does appreciate that something is over-damped or missing in the presentation. His solution - a sort of uncomfortable work-around as you've heard - is to drive the bottom end of the tweeter harder in the 3-8kHz region to spice up the lower harmonics that are missing from the bass unit's 1 - 4kHz acoustic output. The tragedy in my opinion is that this game has been played out in hundred or thousands of new speaker that have come to market in the 15 years since we invented RADIAL (a totally new material compound) and nobody, other than my team, not even the multinationals, have bothered to tackle the basic issue: the cone material itself. And extremely few listeners seem to be able to accurately pin-down this coloration issue and intellectualise the component parts down to frequency bands.
I must add that looked at from a point of an investment made by the taxpayer into British manufacturing, the grant we received (and the graduate engineers we could then fund) must rank as one of the best investments by government ever. They've had their money back in corporation tax, VAT, payroll tax and British export value a hundred times over.
* Sound into heat is a one way street. Once acoustic micro detail is dissipated as (converted to) heat in the cone that's the end of that waveform. Heat can not be turned into sound.
-----------------------------------------------------------
Shaw是Harbeth的老闆兼設計者, 文中提到pp(聚丙烯)所做成的單體問題在某些頻率時聲音轉換成熱能就消失了, 無法再轉換回來, 微動態不見了. 這種喇叭成千成百的在市場出現, 狡猾的設計者加強3-8kHz(高音單體底部)做為遮掩. |
|