新手上路
二星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 13
- 舊站發表文章數
- 142
|
發表於 2008-11-15 17:20:44
|
顯示全部樓層
A. Shaw文:
Just to clarify ....
1. The SHL5 has a 'generous'. warm bass as you say.
2. No amount of substitution of cables, stands, electronics will change the basic fact that the SHL5 produces more low frequency energy. You're wasting your time and money chasing that one.
3. That extra low frequency energy is at the heart of the SHL5s sound. You may find that in an absorptive room the speakers energy and the room's absorption are in perfect harmony.
4. There are really three approaches if you wish to reduce the low frequency energy in a room. a) increase the absorption of LF in the room (more soft furnishings) and/or b) turn down the volume or c) reduce the amount of bass energy being delivered to the speaker.
c) implies some sort of graphic equaliser or tone control. Almost every real room in the real world with real speakers could benefit from a little EQ at low frequencies. One of the greatest mysteries and acts of insanity in the audio business was the deletion of tone controls from hifi amplifiers from about the 1980s with some utterly discreditable mumbo jumbo that 'tone controls are no part of a hifi system'. I can categorically assure you that a properly designed and executed tone control circuit does not degrade the signal quality and never has done; this is extremely easy to prove under blind listening conditions*. Tone controls were deleted from hifi amps as a marketing gimmick to attract a new 'minimalist' consumer away from amps laden with buttons and controls.
Perhaps the greatest intellect in amplifier design was the late Peter Walker of QUAD. Key point: he was an expert on both amplifiers and loudspeakers, and designed for real rooms. He knew from measurement and listening how real rooms corrupted even the most carefully designed speaker response at low frequencies and obviously, putting high fidelity first, made sure that his amplifiers always gave the user the ability to tune the speaker to the room - via the tone or tilt control. How many amplifier designers know anything about speakers? How many actually measure speakers in real domestic rooms? How many are obsessed with chasing ludicrously (and needlessly) low noise and distortion figures to 0.0000% when the room corrupts the low frequencies by 50-500%?
As I live in the real world and know only too well from measurement how all rooms disturb my designed nice smooth low frequency response, I can say that personally, the only amplifier I would myself be really happy to use in my untreated room at home would be fitted with a bypassable tone (or better, tilt) control. Those controls would, in practice, give me a sporting chance that I could make any speaker work in just about any room. They'd save me the inconvenience and cost of treating the room. They are 100% wife friendly. However, handicapped by the fact that 'audiophiles' consider tone control to be anathema, I have to listen during the design stage with bypassed tone controls to represent what most users experience.
* I would also suggest that if you realise just how much 'eq' is applied to every LP, broadcast, DVD, CD you've ever heard (are there any which are not twiddled in some way?) it would put the angst concerning amplifier tone controls into proper perspective. In short: if your amp has a tone control you are more likely to get the best overall fidelity because you can tune the speaker/room interface to suit you. Tone controls empower you not some marketeer who has decided on your behalf that tone controls are evil.
Attached two adverts from 1956 for amplifiers featuring tone controls. The physics of real speakers in real rooms have not changed in fifty years so why have tone controls been deleted from all but a few domestic hifi amplifiers? What is the engineering logic behind that? This has always seemed to me the act of the greatest illogicality in our industry.
--------------------------------------------
SHL5轟轟叫?
Shaw對80年代以來擴大機設計取消 tone control 提出批評. 設計良好的 tone control 不會降低訊號品質, Shaw以QUAD 的Peter Walker 為例, 因為他同時是擴大機和喇叭的專家, 他知道再好的喇叭設計也不能解決真實房間裡低頻問題, 所有他設計的擴大機都有讓用家調整的tone 或 tilt control 功能.
簡單的說,假如你的擴大機有 tone control, 你更有可能得到更傳真的聲音. |
|