新手上路
Da Man
- 舊站積分
- 1718
- 舊站發表文章數
- 1326
|
樓主 |
發表於 2017-8-3 11:08:27
|
顯示全部樓層
Seaton Sound MFW-15 Turbo SS
Seaton Sound's MFW-15 Turbo SS is a subwoofer originally designed by Mark Seaton for the now defunct AV123. AV123 made many mistakes, taking shortcuts along the way and never fully implemented Mark's original design. Mark treats his designs like children and has been supporting these original AV123 subs with driver and/or amplifier upgrades over the years. At the end of 2015 Mark Seaton revealed that he had possession of new-old-stock cabinets from AV123. By that time his vision of a complete Turbo kit upgrade for the MFW-15 was complete with custom-fit Speakerpower IcePower 700W amplifiers and high-excursion, heavy-duty 15" drivers from car audio house Fi. I believe it is fair to say that the MFW-15 Turbo kit far exceeds Mark』s original vision. The new-old-stock wood veneer cabinets were refinished including custom, black faceplates to fit the new Fi driver (without spacers) and loaded with brand new Turbo kits.
以下是有關 Seaton Sound MFW-15 Turbo SS 的產品介紹: http://www.seaton-sound-forum.com/po...binets-7812317
[B]Seaton Sound MFW-15 Turbo SS[/B]
Based on the costs involved with the woofer used, full packing, US assembled amplifier, new cover panels, and new magnetic grill, the completed unit should be selling for $1395, even with the old stock cabinets. For comparison, if I produced similarly attractive, new cabinets, I would sell these for around $1695.
Any still around past July 1st will sell with magnetic grill for $995 each + shipping, which is still a great deal on the performance and package. Consider we have roughly double the capability of the original MFW-15, much smoother response, XLR/RCA inputs with auto-sensing and 12V trigger, 30-200Hz 24dB/oct crossover, LF EQ for room size and house curve adjustment, a delay control for front/rear subs, and a 3 year warranty. Note most other vented 15" subs on the market are significantly larger, not tuned as low without plugging ports, or have very long lead times.
Frequency response: 16-200Hz +/-3dB
Dimensions are 18" wide x 24" tall x 22.5" deep
Optional magnetic grill adds $50 and 1/2" to depth
Included and removable rubber feet at 3/4" to height spikes can be upgraded using the M6 threaded inserts.
Pricing for the remaining units in stock:
MFW-15 Turbo SS with magnetic grill: $895 + shipping
2x MFW-15 Turbo SS with magnetic grill: $1695 + shipping
Don't need grills? -$50 each
--------------------------------------------
Last I spoke to Mark Seaton he still has B-stock cabinets available w/minor cosmetic defects (practically invisible from a few feet away IME). He is down to his last few Fi drivers, but is awaiting a batch of newer drivers featuring similar performance and lower distortion.
The MFW-15 Turbo SS is part of this comparison of ported subs because: a) I own a pair and b) I wanted to know how wide the gap between a 15" and 18" sub would be. I am not breaking any new ground here as the trusted @JimWilson aka theJman, admin at Home Theater Shack thoroughly reviewed this unit. In fact, one of the subs I received from Mark Seaton was the exact sub reviewed/abused by Jim. It is no worse for wear which convinces me that this sub as a bulletproof as they come. Jim Wilson 評論的聯結: http://www.hometheatershack.com/foru...ss-review.html
Listening Impressions
The comparison between the V1801 and MFW-15 Turbo turned out to be much closer than I expected. It did not start out close in my mind. The first clip I listened to on all the subs was the opening scene of Disney's Bolt. I am very familiar with this scene as I have a [recently turned] 4-year-old. This was the first movie he ever sat all the way through. The opening scene has great variety of effects, so it's what I always play for him we he wants to "subwoof"! It is filled with helicopters, motorcycles, impacts, and explosions. This is not an Ultra-Low-Frequency (ULF) test clip as there is not much content below 30Hz. What there is is a ton of content above 30 Hz all the way up through 100Hz, with the strongest being between 30-50Hz. The MFW-15 sounds and feels great with this clip. However, the V1801 was about equal to two MFW-15s. PSA subs historically are powerhouses above 40Hz and the V1801 is no exception. While the MAX SPL numbers at 40Hz and up are very good, distortion (especially odd-ordered) is much higher than the Rythmik and JTR 18" subs. This differences in distortion are audible when comparing directly to the Rythmik and JTR 18" ported subs.
As expected, the single MFW-15 Turbo was pushing its limits on its own (which I why I have two). While it is quite well behaved (very little port noise) and has good tactile impact, it just doesn』t have enough output to keep up with all of the soundtracks at reference. However, one may never know it if you had never heard any other subs with more headroom (or in my case, dual MFW-15Ts). Mark Seaton has dialed in the Speakerpower IcePower DSP so that the sub never lets you know it has run out of gas. He lets the port chuff a bit, but not to the point that it was ever really audible during movie clips. There is distortion, but it is somehow mostly all 2nd-order which is quite acceptable (especially for movies). The limiter kicks in before 3rd-order distortion gets excessive.
The tables turned during the ULF torture testing. The ULF torture test scenes were played on only 3 of the 4 ported subs at the GTG on the 17th. [Unfortunately, the driver on the Rythmik FV18 was damaged the week prior and the replacement was not delivered in time. I learned that Servo + limiter does not equal bulletproof (Sorry Brian Ding).]
Edge of Tomorrow - First 40 Seconds
Olympus Has Fallen - Washington Monument Scene
World War Z – Grenade
Pulse - Control Room
The Edge of Tomorrow and the Pulse scenes are examples of half-baked, nonsensical soundtrack mixing, in my opinion. They are simply out of place in their respective movies (maybe it adds to Pulse, which I consider just a horrible movie all around based on the little I could tolerate).
The MFW-15T performed quite well with the ULF clips. The sub produced a passing CEA-2010 score at 12.5Hz! While it can be driven to chuffing the actual sound of that chuffing was not overly distracting or loud. The DSP limiter kicks in before it gets to that point. During the torture testing, much of the chuffing was covered up by the 2nd-order harmonic distortion (20Hz during the 10Hz tone on the E0T intro). Out of the ported subs, only the JTRs performed better than the MFW-15T.
This is where the tables turned as the PSA V1801 failed the ULF tests miserably. The CEA-2010 testing showed that the MFW-15T has more output between 16-31.5Hz while the PSA V1801 catches up and pulls away from 40Hz and up. The ULF output numbers may have been surprising but the chuffing was a shocker. Here is why. PSA ported subs have a history of not chuffing. Not only does it chuff with all the ULF scenes, the sound of the chuffing was quite disappointing. It sounded like a real horse chuffing & snorting. Utilizing CEA-2010 burst tones in room the chuffing was both longer and louder than the other subs by a wide margin (even the Rythmik FV18 was better behaved in its 12.5Hz mode). The chuffing obfuscated the fundamental tone itself at 25Hz both in my room and outside. PSA would not comment directly or discuss with me. My hypothesis is that this behavior simply seems to be a result of the new, higher excursion driver in the V1801. Forum member @Sekosche owns dual V1800 and dual V1801. He confirmed that the chuffing starts at the same frequencies/levels on both, but the sound of the chuffing on the V1800 is much less noticeable.
以下是一位擁有 PSA V1800 和 V1801 網友的感想:
In my opinion, port noise in real world use with these subs (movie/music playback) is so rare it's essentially non existent, or it's not discernible from other soundtrack elements when approaching reference level and beyond. Aside from three movie scenes (Pulse, EOT, SW: TFA), that caused noticeable chuffing, out of the thousands that I've heard, the subs have been stellar. I'm obviously very fond of my PSA gear, or I wouldn't have an entire system composed of their speakers and subs.
This is for the people that are curious or are more sensitive to objectionable port sounds during very deep bass playback. Does this mean the ULF quality is in some way muddied by said noise at high volumes and I simply cannot resolve the difference? That's a possibility.
The new V1801 definitely moves more air at and below 25Hz than the V1800. For both subs, 25Hz is the point I could detect any port noise over the fundamental tone at 110dB with an in room noise floor of approximately 50dB. Playing a short sine wave in 1Hz increments, I measured and listened from 1 meter to the port; and the V1800 chuffing I definitely considered more pleasant compared to the V1801. It's hard to describe, other than the V1800 produces a softer sound with reduced port airflow at all frequencies where vent noise is concerned.
For both models, backing the volume down 8 or 10dB eliminated any port noise from creeping through. Though not designed to be a ULF monster, the V1801 had significantly greater cone movement and decent in room SPL all the way down to 10-11Hz compared to the V1800, which appeared to hit its Xmax around 17Hz at the same playback level (didn't take it any further).
Although ported subwoofers produce some added noise around tune, proper setup and adequate headroom go a long way to mitigate any unwanted sounds coming through. Just one opinion from a guy that likes a little bit of bass.
-------------------------------------------------
I don't feel like this makes the V1801 any less of a sub. Several more knowledgeable than I modeled 18" subs the size of the V1801 and state the modeling agrees with the observed behavior. I have read and spoken to several owners of both the 00 and 01 series and they all believe there is a better SQ as well as better tactile feedback with the 01 driver vs the 00. Any better port performance would require a bigger box. Chuffing will occur on any ported sub at some point (unless limited by DSP). Chuffing is a common complaint of ported subs owners with less than adequate subs for the room and listening habits (which was the case in these tests). Lowering the Room Size knob should be a way to mitigate the chuffing behavior if experienced. Upgrading or adding subs is another way.
I am slightly disappointed because the PSA utilizes the 700W IcePower amplifier module from Speakerpower. Same as the Seaton Sound MFW-15 Turbo and the JTR Captivator 118HT (The Cap 1400 uses two of the 700W modules). PSA has access to the same DSP tools to mitigate untoward port noises (unlike the Rythmik which has no such DSP). The V1801 chuffing behavior could be mitigated by DSP programming. I hope this was not knowingly left unchecked by PSA to bolster the CEA-2010 numbers.
I hope that PSA considers re-tuning the DSP limiters on the ported 01 series subs to mitigate chuffing even it results in reduced CEA-2010 numbers. I invite @Tom Vodhanel to comment here regarding these observations.
Since CEA-2010 does not account for port noises (unless they fall into the harmonic noise bands). If we were to amend our own versions citing port noise as a limiting factor, the MAX SPL results at 16, 20, 25, & 31.5Hz would be reduced between 6dB – 11dB which is significant.
I do believe the PSA V1801 and MFW-15T subs are great choices for most living rooms. Due to their distortion characteristics, I do believe their are better choices for music-only applications. Those with dedicated media rooms should consider sealed subs or moving up to the Rythmik or JTR ported subs (detailed impressions upcoming).
In full disclosure, I am running (4) Seaton F18+ in my dedicated, upstairs media room. I am looking to sell the Seaton MFW-15 Turbos to allow me to purchase a single JTR Captivator 2400 for my downstairs den.
I will attach and discuss measurements of the V1801 and MFW-15T in more detail in the following post. |
|