新手上路
五星級會員
- 舊站積分
- 3604
- 舊站發表文章數
- 5787
|
發表於 2018-8-4 04:03:57
|
顯示全部樓層
Re: Re: Re: 關於atoms請問?
原發表者是 jackyamg
[B]
看來影院的混音跟家用的混音還是有很大的不同,atmos物件的數量,家用的大幅縮水為最多12個,並非如原本文宣上的最大64個!
另一個重點是因為家用空間的局限,就算給予超多的物件,就算可裝那麼多喇叭,可以解那麼多物件,家裡還是無法呈現如影院般的3D感
我想!在影院裡的經驗,大廳跟小廳的聽感應該也以拿來對照吧? [/B]
相關討論: https://www.avsforum.com/forum/1 ... e.html#post34987345
Just to clarify somethings Brian said....
1. Theatrical Atmos supports 118 objects, not 128.
2. Home Atmos can have a maximum of 20 objects. The encoder defaults to 12.
As mentioned, Dolby uses spectral coding to combine objects when they are co located, share frequency spectrum, etc.
3. If the bed is 7.1 (and for the great majority of time moving forward mixes will be reliant on beds since that is a necessity in commercial theaters) the following is true..
Atmos at its default can provide 7.1 + 12 objects.
補充該串下方的Filmixer 關於nearfield mix的看法:
The SPL reference at home is completely different. Which changes the specral balance in significant ways. That is the whole point of doing these mixes.
Trust me.... If you took our theatrical mix of "Fury" vs what we delivered on BR (which I did alongside Brian for Sony) you would have a difficult time understanding the dialog without blowing yourself out of your room when the action kicked in without constantly riding the volume. While I appreciate your and Mr Grimani's idealistic craving for purity and simplicity, IMO it is a naive point of view that lacks real world experience to back it up.
Cost, effort and time aren't what is holding up the roll out of Dolby Atmos BRs.... IMO many studios are holding off at this point until UHD comes to market.
Regardless, you must spend the time to master Atmos for the home... Same will be the case as DTS:X rolls out.... It's a great deal more involved than taking a 5.1 or 7.1 PCM master and crunching it with a lossless encoder. Object number reduction and other considerations require mixer supervision. Lossless encoding does not.
但還是有許多仁兄從實聽經驗上發現某些nearfield mix的問題, 不少人還是希望無論如何能多一條戲院用的原音軌,
據稱有些從LD,DVD時代一路過來到BD, UHD的音效都能聽到不同的表現.
近來很多討論到關於Disney包括旗下購併的 Marvel , Lucasfilm (Star Wars..)等家用BD, UHD許多出現混音音量過低, 或動態範圍, 低頻量感與延伸相對保守等情況,
例如超人特攻隊據稱在BD上的DTS-HD表現好過UHD 的Atmos 就有落落長的討論, 即使也有人持不同意見:
http://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread.php?t=303602
從這幾年觀察下來的相關問題, 甚至已經有請願活動在進行中:
Improve Audio (Dynamic EQ, LFE (Bass) Levels) in Disney Home Video Releases
後續如何也還有待觀察. |
|