忘記密碼
 立即註冊
樓主: jcc104

LP唱臂

[複製鏈接]

101

主題

2033

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
2320
舊站發表文章數
1545
發表於 2006-12-2 13:52:32 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 ash2459
[B]好幾十年沒聽到唱頭/唱臂諧振頻率的討論了...[]

Alan Hsu [/B]


恭請版主Alan兄share 好幾十年的經驗,以嘉惠樂友 []

101

主題

2033

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
2320
舊站發表文章數
1545
發表於 2006-12-2 14:50:04 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 jcc104
[B]

ChrisH兄提出共振的問題
查了些資料 也被搞糊塗了
quoted from 山本武夫「
「周波數ft程度選問題。音聲周波信號20Hz程度成分。一方、雜音信號考、1~數Hz低音域偏心雜音成分、25Hz付近雜音振動。、音聲帶域完全、上記雜音振動少10Hz付近周波數選得策。、雜音振動成分多周波數周波數一致,雜音成分大、避。(中略) 
Cb(意味機械反比例)
全體等價質量mt=1/4ππftftCb
Cb平均的25x(106乘)cm/dyne反定周波數ft10Hzmt10g。等價質量質量1.5~2倍、質量5~7g。(實際合計質量平均16g)mt約30g周波數ftft(Hz)=1/2π√mtxCb6Hz。周波數10Hz以上、輕必要。最近、點考慮、暫時輕量輕量出始。(中略) rp(支點等價抵抗)rb(支持部等價抵抗)制動場合、rb制動中音域機械增加、rp制動低音域機械增加。 輕針壓再生、各周波數機械低。、rb高音域周波數特性機械特性適當、rp制動。,rp大、低音域機械增加、偏心、低音域雜音振動追隨必要、偏心場合必要針壓,余分針壓必要。」
UNQUOTE

(A)  ft(Hz)=1/2π√mtxCb公式中的Cb (compliance)是臂管或是唱針的compliance??
(B)而且」Total effective mass(g)=arm effective mass+cart.weight+weight of screws」  cart.weight+weight of screws要計算pick-up等價質量(約是唱頭的1.5-2倍)再加上head shell的重量
(C) 還要考慮唱臂支撐點的等價抵抗 (我和巫會長的Graham2.2系統是有使用油纇來改變阻尼)
光是這3點已經搞得頭昏腦脹 [/B]


jcc104,

Can you translate the following paragraph for me:
"
Cb平均的25x(106乘)cm/dyne反定周波數ft10Hzmt10g。等價質量質量1.5~2倍、質量5~7g。(實際合計質量平均16g)mt約30g周波數ftft(Hz)=1/2π√mtxCb6Hz。周波數10Hz以上、輕必要。最近、點考慮、暫時輕量輕量出始。(中略) rp(支點等價抵抗)rb(支持部等價抵抗)制動場合、rb制動中音域機械增加、rp制動低音域機械"



"Compliance" normally decribes how stiffly or loosely the suspension holds the cantiliever.Also is expressed as a "number" indicating how far the cantiliever moves when a force is applied.

Hope you can understand the following definition or depiction:

**A cartridge's compliance and tonearm's effective mass form a resonant system.**

Compliance is always a "mystery" in the world!It has something in connection with the suspension material,cantiliever material....,etc.
Now here comes the problems:
1.Some cart.makers do not even provide such info.
2.Some provides only a "number" but does not say it's been measured in vertical or lateral?
3.To be more precisely,it should have both "static" and "dynamic" figures.
4.For instance,some cartridge says compliance is "15um/mN",but measured by ? Hz? [}] What about the compliance in conjunction with other frequencies?

Some of info is considered as secrecy and not suitable to open in public.
I'll leave this forum and hope to learn from others(especially the divers)[|)]

67

主題

1萬

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Witch Fly on the Tonearm

舊站積分
7022
舊站發表文章數
12209
 樓主| 發表於 2006-12-2 15:56:48 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 ChrisH
[B]

jcc104,

Can you translate the following paragraph for me:
"
Cb平均的25x(106乘)cm/dyne反定周波數ft10Hzmt10g。等價質量質量1.5~2倍、質量5~7g。(實際合計質量平均16g)mt約30g周波數ftft(Hz)=1/2π√mtxCb6Hz。周波數10Hz以上、輕必要。最近、點考慮、暫時輕量輕量出始。(中略) rp(支點等價抵抗)rb(支持部等價抵抗)制動場合、rb制動中音域機械增加、rp制動低音域機械"



"Compliance" normally decribes how stiffly or loosely the suspension holds the cantiliever.Also is expressed as a "number" indicating how far the cantiliever moves when a force is applied.

Hope you can understand the following definition or depiction:

**A cartridge's compliance and tonearm's effective mass form a resonant system.**

Compliance is always a "mystery" in the world!It has something in connection with the suspension material,cantiliever material....,etc.
Now here comes the problems:
1.Some cart.makers do not even provide such info.
2.Some provides only a "number" but does not say it's been measured in vertical or lateral?
3.To be more precisely,it should have both "static" and "dynamic" figures.
4.For instance,some cartridge says compliance is "15um/mN",but measured by ? Hz? [}] What about the compliance in conjunction with other frequencies?

Some of info is considered as secrecy and not suitable to open in public.
I'll leave this forum and hope to learn from others(especially the divers)[|)] [/B]


Presume average Cb (compliance) is 25*10^(-6) cm/dyne, mt must be kept at 10g, so that arm resonance (ft) can be 10Hz. Because the pick-up等價質量(?) is 1.5-2 times of pick-up head, the head mass must to be 5-7g. (If the actual average head mass<cartridge+shell> is 16g) Mt is about 30g, according to 」 ft(Hz)=1/2π√mtxCb」 , arm resonance will be 6 Hz. If we want to keep the arm resonance above 10 Hz, a lighter cartridge is needed. Recently, such point of view has been taken into consideration, and lighter cartridges or shells begin to emerge. (I can』t translate the follows because I don』t know what it means)

The paragraph quoted above is very old.
站在巨人的肩膀上 我們看得更遠

67

主題

1萬

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Witch Fly on the Tonearm

舊站積分
7022
舊站發表文章數
12209
 樓主| 發表於 2006-12-2 16:09:41 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 ChrisH
[B]

"Compliance" normally decribes how stiffly or loosely the suspension holds the cantiliever.Also is expressed as a "number" indicating how far the cantiliever moves when a force is applied.

Hope you can understand the following definition or depiction:

**A cartridge's compliance and tonearm's effective mass form a resonant system.**

Compliance is always a "mystery" in the world!It has something in connection with the suspension material,cantiliever material....,etc.
Now here comes the problems:
1.Some cart.makers do not even provide such info.
2.Some provides only a "number" but does not say it's been measured in vertical or lateral?
3.To be more precisely,it should have both "static" and "dynamic" figures.
4.For instance,some cartridge says compliance is "15um/mN",but measured by ? Hz? [}] What about the compliance in conjunction with other frequencies?

Some of info is considered as secrecy and not suitable to open in public.
I'll leave this forum and hope to learn from others(especially the divers)[|)] [/B]


Chris,
  We know that different material of arm wand will have different resonance. How to explain this? Because  different material of arm wand has different "effective mass"?
   []
站在巨人的肩膀上 我們看得更遠

67

主題

1萬

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Witch Fly on the Tonearm

舊站積分
7022
舊站發表文章數
12209
 樓主| 發表於 2006-12-2 16:29:14 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 jcc104
[B]

Presume average Cb (compliance) is 25*10^(-6) cm/dyne, mt must be kept at 10g, so that arm resonance (ft) can be 10Hz. Because the pick-up等價質量(?) is 1.5-2 times of pick-up head, the head mass must to be 5-7g. (If the actual average head mass<cartridge+shell> is 16g) Mt is about 30g, according to 」 ft(Hz)=1/2π√mtxCb」 , arm resonance will be 6 Hz. If we want to keep the arm resonance above 10 Hz, a lighter cartridge is needed. Recently, such point of view has been taken into consideration, and lighter cartridges or shells begin to emerge. (I can』t translate the follows because I don』t know what it means)

The paragraph quoted above is very old. [/B]


等價質量"也許"是effective mass
那麼pick up effective mass(mt) 就是(唱頭+唱頭蓋)的1.5-2倍
站在巨人的肩膀上 我們看得更遠

101

主題

2033

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
2320
舊站發表文章數
1545
發表於 2006-12-2 17:58:53 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 jcc104
[B]

Chris,
  We know that different material of arm wand will have different resonance. How to explain this? Because  different material of arm wand has different "effective mass"?
   [] [/B]


Yes,that is one thing for sure.But I would prefer to call it "different mass"instead of "different effective mass".

Too many profound theroies for arm wand design are out of my reach!Therefore,I am not entitled to give them a verdict[]

Some basic concepts are:
1.The longer the arm wand is,the greater mass it has.
2.The heavier arm wand may also have greater mass.
3.The stiffness/density ratio of the arm wand,IMO should also  take it  into account!
I had been trid to study and learn  the material of cantilever in the past,but not for the arm wand.

I have the data of stiffness/density ratio from the web:

Aluminium : 0.27
Beryllium : 1.58 (like Shure V15)
Boron : 1.88
Diamond : 2.88
........

Arm wands made of carbon fiber or ceramic can be the new innovation of some benefits.I encourage everyone who share the comments of comparison.
[]

Finally,
1.Chang the arm wand>>>>> change the effective mass>>> change the arm/cart.resonance>>>>change the sound.

2.Change the mass of headshell,counter weight,adding damping oil or material........they all do the same thing as above.

Cheers,
ChrisH

101

主題

2033

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
2320
舊站發表文章數
1545
發表於 2006-12-2 18:05:15 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 alc
[B]下午爆料李老大看了貼文,來電小小把我訕笑一番,前人的坑洞後人還是躲不掉,從 tracking error 到 諧振處理,都是他們當年奮戰的題目,如今時代前進了一輪,我還是沒能從巨人的肩膀上向前看,又像當兵一樣,乖乖的從新兵訓練開始…

由於他是用正切臂,所以我們從正切臂就天南地北聊到烏魯木齊去了 (我們都有輕微的蒙太奇式幻想症,常常聊著聊著就定格到老夫子式或者是搞笑電影的想像場景,他的秘書或許會覺得李總最近好像不大對…)。 然而,到烏魯木齊之前,我還是有挖到一些巨人肩膀上的經驗,這些,我決定要很小心的、低調的、不露痕跡的,把它暗槓起來,等 Chris 的政論節目停播之後,再選擇高點釋出。   [] [/B]


主教的經驗還不釋出嗎 ?[}] [}] [}]

151

主題

8413

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
24833
舊站發表文章數
7074
發表於 2006-12-2 23:52:19 | 顯示全部樓層
啥? 你們兩個機哩括啦然後稀哩呼嚕,然後嗯嗯啊啊阿里啊豆把一堆數學弄出來,就算高點,現在到底上到哪一課啦?? 喂喂喂 ~~~ 外面這一大幫子人,有誰看懂了,給點心得吧~~。 我對唱臂可是原來認識一點,現在不太認得了... [V]

趁我的記憶還沒有變成張無忌學太極拳時,老大提到的幾件事趕快先說一說。

1.        已經說過,唱頭的重量已漸趨統一,唱頭製造商也瞭解到上面那一堆數學的重要性,少有人跟自己過不去,弄一個只有他自己做的 arm 才能用的唱頭。
2.        不同廠牌的唱針與 mounting 螺絲的前後位置也越來越接近,意味著不同唱頭的螺絲大略會鎖在近似的位置,而不用擔心螺絲孔不夠長,搞得唱頭跟唱臂硬是兜不起來。
3.        這件事 jcc 兄聽了不會太高興,唱臂線掛在外面也有人做過,甚至把線直接焊到唱頭後面那四根接頭上以減少接點。

然後爆料一個關於唱頭阻尼的事情。 溫濕度影響唱頭的阻尼,間接影響聲音的表現,於是乎有某前輩於人客未到之際,以燈具照射唱頭附近,希望能將當天的濕氣儘早排除,得到正常的聲音,也展現自己偉大的待客之道。 老大見了則提醒了他一下,這唱頭的阻尼一下子乾濕變得這麼快,來回個幾次,是否比較容易翹錨? 主人一聽,立時把那待客之道拋開一邊,回去給他的唱頭連聲秀秀… []

462

主題

1萬

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

5星級會員

舊站積分
2081
舊站發表文章數
13120
發表於 2006-12-3 08:52:07 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 alc
[B]


然後爆料一個關於唱頭阻尼的事情。 溫濕度影響唱頭的阻尼,間接影響聲音的表現,於是乎有某前輩於人客未到之際,以燈具照射唱頭附近,希望能將當天的濕氣儘早排除,得到正常的聲音,也展現自己偉大的待客之道。 老大見了則提醒了他一下,這唱頭的阻尼一下子乾濕變得這麼快,來回個幾次,是否比較容易翹錨? 主人一聽,立時把那待客之道拋開一邊,回去給他的唱頭連聲秀秀… [] [/B]

[]  這個叫吹毛求疵過頭..抓不到重點..[8D] [8D] [8D]



設計盡量簡單化..把重點抓到..讓使用者能更輕易入手..
不要祇是為了能提高價格..就做的花俏.多加了些無關緊要的小東西[] []
Carmans audio [COLOR=deeppink]0932-377626.黃先生 新竹市光復路2段882號6F[/COLOR]

67

主題

1萬

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

Witch Fly on the Tonearm

舊站積分
7022
舊站發表文章數
12209
 樓主| 發表於 2006-12-3 11:34:02 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 alc
[B]
趁我的記憶還沒有變成張無忌學太極拳時,老大提到的幾件事趕快先說一說。

3.        這件事 jcc 兄聽了不會太高興,唱臂線掛在外面也有人做過,甚至把線直接焊到唱頭後面那四根接頭上以減少接點。

[] [/B]



Alc兄提出的問題我很樂意回答 一點也不會不高興
前次alc兄(素未謀面)來台中 巫會長有提到要到寒舍來指導
但是因為那時正在研發」獨立唱臂線系統」
整個音響室雜亂像工廠
一方面也因研發過程 模型不宜公開
所以將近有1年多時間」謝絕會客」
(除了2-3位」導師」請他們來鑑定與指導)
現在已經開放 也歡迎兄有空來指教
***
」獨立唱臂線系統」的靈感來自sme309
唱臂底端DIN的接頭處整得我很慘
因為那條唱臂線(DIN>RCA)的位置影響很大
到後來只好整個懸掛起來
之後玩起Clearaudio Max. Solution 配Unify & TQ-I
從TQ-I我學得臂管線不一定要藏在臂管內
我也在TQ-I的訊號線作了很多試驗(當然花了不少錢)
更加肯定臂管線一定要從臂管內」解放」
***
Unify唱臂的訊號線是從唱頭的pin一路到phono stage
我上網定購一些頂級的臂管線來取代Unify的訊號線
從唱頭的pin一路到phono stage
那時我的訊號線就如同」小賴導師」固定在唱臂外殼上
我聽到比原本(Unify的線)更為生動 更有細節的聲音
但是當我把新的訊號線進一步固定在唱臂座時(如同Unify)
那種生動感不見了 如同原本Unify的聲音 只是音質要好些
到此我已經可以確定唱盤轉動時的振動
經由唱臂座對訊號的傳輸影響很大
***
接著我將綁在唱臂上的訊號線進一步」解放」
(當然我要克服訊號線下垂和干擾抗滑的問題)
這時我聽到我追求的真實的聲音
充滿臨場感 生動感 動態 細節 定位精確 音場龐大
我這時才真正體會唱盤轉動引起的回授微振對訊號傳輸的破壞有多大
***
當然那是我的感覺 我必需找人驗証
於是找了巫會長和小賴導師請他們驗證
他們對聲音的要求幾乎接近吹毛求疵
我只要將獨立唱臂線固定在唱臂或唱臂座上1點
聲音就明顯便差
當然也受到他們的肯定
***
當然整個」獨立唱臂線系統」的製造
除了上述原理之外 還牽涉一些細節
我很感謝小張先生和巫會長一再抽空幫我作秘密試聽
讓我的系統能一再改進
我也很欣慰我的phono cable和」獨立唱臂線系統」獲得巫會長採用
能夠和歐美名線並駕齊驅 甚至換下他們
站在巨人的肩膀上 我們看得更遠
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-20 05:17 , Processed in 0.167982 second(s), 41 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表