忘記密碼
 立即註冊
樓主: hsindao

VTA

[複製鏈接]

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2010-12-20 12:02:58 | 顯示全部樓層
Lyyong's view point of SRA likely is shared by most LP users so let me address some of it.

SRA likely is one of the less, if not the least, understood factor in LP playback.  Most people don't have much experience with it, and dismiss the importance of it like how cables were dismissed 10-15 years ago.  Just like cables, you likely will think differently if someone has demonstrated the differences to you.  

The sound of a cartridge can be tuned by VTF, anti-skating and SRA.  Tonality can be affected by all 3, for example, but details and attack can not be addressed by VTF or anti-skating alone.  One example is the trade-off between violin and piano that people often talked about.  The only way to get both violin and piano right at the same time is to have the correct SRA.

---------------
I am also one that adjust SRA from LP to LP so let me explain how does it work.

If I play LPs on a FR-64fx tonearm, I don't bother with SRA these days.  I may tweak it a bit after several weeks of listening to different LPs.  Sounds like a normal person, right?

If I play LPs on a Graham tonearm, capable of SRA-on-the-fly adjustment, I don't do anything if it sounded fine.  Only when I think something is wrong will I adjust SRA without stopping the music.  I know exactly how SRA should be corrected, the whole process takes about 5-10 seconds, and I can go back to enjoy the rest of the entire LP.  It is not more difficult than changing volume from LP to LP.  

Sound does not equal music. However, like a friend said recently, the sound quality of a recording often affect how we perceive that performance.  I am quite willing to spend 10 seconds making each recording presented in its best way and make the following 45 minutes thoroughly enjoyable.  

17

主題

802

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

三星級會員

舊站積分
302
舊站發表文章數
522
發表於 2010-12-20 13:13:01 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 hsindao
[B]

......

If I play LPs on a Graham tonearm, capable of SRA-on-the-fly adjustment, I don't do anything if it sounded fine.  Only when I think something is wrong will I adjust SRA without stopping the music.  I know exactly how SRA should be corrected, the whole process takes about 5-10 seconds, and I can go back to enjoy the rest of the entire LP.  It is not more difficult than changing volume from LP to LP.  

Sound does not equal music. However, like a friend said recently, the sound quality of a recording often affect how we perceive that performance.  I am quite willing to spend 10 seconds making each recording presented in its best way and make the following 45 minutes thoroughly enjoyable.  
[/B]


唱片的厚度就那幾種,我相信有經驗的高手,可以在5 – 10秒鐘內,在基準點上下,做好最佳的微調。

我想    Fred謝兄還要經驗一陣子才有這種功力,小弟可不是這種人才。

70

主題

1054

回帖

50

積分

新手上路

三星級會員

舊站積分
345
舊站發表文章數
534
發表於 2010-12-20 13:15:50 | 顯示全部樓層
以我自己系統的設定,一點點想法說明如下,如有以偏概全,請大老們海涵:

1.我一直在尋找的是一種可以讓入門者可以明確依循的調整方法,hsindao兄提到的第3種方法對大多數的人來說,是最困難的。所以我想如果「看」的到一個準則,再來微調,或許會比較好。我們當然可以看到唱臂的水平與否,也可用針桿簡易觀察VTA,但是針尖實際的SRA是否如廠家宣稱的就會是在正確的位置?聽起來又如何?這就是我想知道的。

2.用適當倍數的放大鏡及手電筒打光來看針尖角度,雖然無法明確量測角度,但角度的變化還是可以明確的「看」出來。

3.如果唱臂水平,大部份的唱頭SRA大於90°,大幾度?我們來算算看:我把針尖調到與倒影成一直線時(EMT JSD 5,雷老re-tip過),唱臂支點約下降1.3㎝,所以SRA約變化2.5°。換言之,唱臂水平時的SRA約92.5°,與Michael Framer宣稱的92°相近,也證明雷老re-tip的功夫還不錯。

4.實際聆聽時,變數很多,為了簡化,就僅用SRA 92.5°及90°二分法比較:SRA= 92.5°的確比SRA= 90°高頻多了很多色彩,或許在SRA= 90°時高頻減少了,讓此時的低頻變得「雄壯」一些。

5.高頻多了,有時候會有點緊、尖銳,但不可否認的,的確增加了許多空氣感、活生感,對於音場的定位也較明確。

6.SRA= 90°時,則溫和多了,不疾不徐的聲音,是穩定的「老灰阿聲」,不是最好但也不出惡聲的選擇。

7.對於聽力好的網兄來說,SRA從90°變化到92.5°(甚至≧92.5°),會有無限個變化值,但單就90及92.5°兩者之間,我自己也來回游移不決,我想LCL0401兄一定會殺了我,因為我目前又回到SRA=92.5°的設定。所以我修正我先前的觀念,而傾向支持JCC兄說的:「我堅信VTA(OR SRA)是個約略值,還有其他因素影響不下於VTA(OR SRA),這必須靠個人長期經驗的累積。」,但這又讓我原本想找的準則變得沒準則,而且我相信在不同的唱臂下,聲音的變化會因為物理特性變得不一樣。

8.另外輕針壓利用降低支點或碳纖墊片來彌補懸吊及針桿變位不足的角度,所以我用標準針壓下限2.2g及1.2g觀察針尖角度的變化,發現兩者並沒有明顯差異。我大膽假設低針壓派的SRA都會趨近90°,但是因為低針壓使唱針變得非常敏感,實際聆聽並不會出現標準針壓時的「老灰阿聲」,其中可以玩味的地方很多,但我這種耳力不強的,玩到撞斷5號頭還是無法出師,只得做罷。

70

主題

1054

回帖

50

積分

新手上路

三星級會員

舊站積分
345
舊站發表文章數
534
發表於 2010-12-20 13:21:10 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 LCL0401
[B]

唱片的厚度就那幾種,我相信有經驗的高手,可以在5 – 10秒鐘內,在基準點上下,做好最佳的微調。

我想    Fred謝兄還要經驗一陣子才有這種功力,小弟可不是這種人才。 [/B]

hsindao兄使用FR-64fx 時,也會先聽幾天再調整,用graham才可邊聽邊調.
我當然不行啦!意志尚未堅定.[]

17

主題

802

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

三星級會員

舊站積分
302
舊站發表文章數
522
發表於 2010-12-20 13:29:23 | 顯示全部樓層
想了一下,
92°似乎也不難調整。
在唱針垂直的情況下,VTA往上提高約 8mm(9寸臂)、10.5mm(12寸臂),再稍微調。

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2010-12-22 02:29:20 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 fredhsieh
[B]
4.實際聆聽時,變數很多,為了簡化,就僅用SRA 92.5°及90°二分法比較:SRA= 92.5°的確比SRA= 90°高頻多了很多色彩,或許在SRA= 90°時高頻減少了,讓此時的低頻變得「雄壯」一些。

5.高頻多了,有時候會有點緊、尖銳,但不可否認的,的確增加了許多空氣感、活生感,對於音場的定位也較明確。

6.SRA= 90°時,則溫和多了,不疾不徐的聲音,是穩定的「老灰阿聲」,不是最好但也不出惡聲的選擇。
[/B]

What Fred described was the result of 2 different ways of solving the same problem.  Let's use violin as an example.

When we hear a dry violin sound, one approach is to roll off the high frequency, like reducing SRA or using tube amps, 厚聲 cables, etc.  The result is 老灰阿聲.

Another approach is add more harmonics by extending high frequency response.  A most common example people can relate with is like adding super tweeter.  Increasing SRA has similar effect.  Strings become silky and realistic when they get all the  harmonics that should be there.  Orchestral music will come to life, and piano will have the characteristic brilliance when hammers hit the metal strings.  This is the direction where one gets all the instruments right.  It is also a state that can not easily be accomplished by just tweaking VTF or anti-skating.

26

主題

1689

回帖

100

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
3261
舊站發表文章數
1711
 樓主| 發表於 2010-12-22 03:48:43 | 顯示全部樓層
I have been using Fidelity Research FR64fx for around 2 years. Whatever were mounted on it all seem to sound a bid muddy.  I had thought problem was with cartridges.  

FR64fx has spring loaded VTF mechanism.  Yesterday at a hunch I set spring scale to 0 and used  counterweight to set VTF instead.  Instant clarity, I was saved.

Do springs in those old tonearms need to be serviced once in a while or was FR64fx just a bad design?  I am happy using only counterweight.  Just curious if anyone has experience on that.

167

主題

8萬

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
32767
舊站發表文章數
11966
發表於 2010-12-22 08:32:16 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 hsindao
[B]
FR64fx has spring loaded VTF mechanism.  Yesterday at a hunch I set spring scale to 0 and used  counterweight to set VTF instead.  Instant clarity, I was saved.

Do springs in those old tonearms need to be serviced once in a while or was FR64fx just a bad design?  I am happy using only counterweight.  Just curious if anyone has experience on that. [/B]


以前以為動態平衡比較好

其實最新的潮流,發現還是靜態平衡比較好

彈簧會老化,而且結構越複雜,只是更衰聲

70

主題

1054

回帖

50

積分

新手上路

三星級會員

舊站積分
345
舊站發表文章數
534
發表於 2010-12-22 08:35:16 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 hsindao
[B]
What Fred described was the result of 2 different ways of solving the same problem.  Let's use violin as an example.

When we hear a dry violin sound, one approach is to roll off the high frequency, like reducing SRA or using tube amps, 厚聲 cables, etc.  The result is 老灰阿聲.

Another approach is add more harmonics by extending high frequency response.  A most common example people can relate with is like adding super tweeter.  Increasing SRA has similar effect.  Strings become silky and realistic when they get all the  harmonics that should be there.  Orchestral music will come to life, and piano will have the characteristic brilliance when hammers hit the metal strings.  This is the direction where one gets all the instruments right.  It is also a state that can not easily be accomplished by just tweaking VTF or anti-skating.
[/B]


對我而言,有時候太多的high frequency response,會使聲音變的不耐聽,這是最難拿捏的.

90

主題

3690

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

四星級會員

舊站積分
661
舊站發表文章數
2595
發表於 2010-12-22 09:15:15 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 fredhsieh
[B]

對我而言,有時候太多的high frequency response,會使聲音變的不耐聽,這是最難拿捏的. [/B]


嚐試拿掉一些尖錐!

當訊息量足夠(高音)且平衡時,尖錐盡量少用會是好主意!

其他比較偏解析的調整如線材,也是如此!

唱頭是訊息源頭,則要訊息量愈大愈好!
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-19 07:19 , Processed in 0.104616 second(s), 41 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表