忘記密碼
 立即註冊
查看: 612|回覆: 0

分享唱臂廠商對唱臂角度的看法,之二

[複製鏈接]

44

主題

164

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

二星級會員

舊站積分
461
舊站發表文章數
208
發表於 2016-12-30 07:41:19 | 顯示全部樓層 |閱讀模式
首先說明,Allen Perkins 是 Immedia/Sprial Groove 的主腦。他以前在 SOTA 做過一段時間,後來離開,自己創了 Immedia。 1996年左右時,我以評論員身份,買了他的唱盤與唱臂,RPM2,寫了評論登載於那時的音響論壇。以下的對話,當初我去他在 Oakland, CA 的公司時,就有過類似的交談。這次我是特別再和他確認,關於他的意見,我的理解否正確。

內容有點長,沒時間看完的讀者,可以專注於最上面的部分,那是他給了最明確的回答, 說他設計的唱臂,25年來沒有發生過因為臂管不水平而產生的問題。底下的部分,我也問了其它唱臂在類似情況下,如要將臂管調斜,才能得到正確的VTA/SRA時,他認為是應該以臂管水平為優先,還是反之。他的回答很有意思:

If you prefer to know your arm is working "correctly", while your system sounds wrong, its your choice.

然後我還再度和他確認。
我問:
>
>> Just to clarify, you believe that, even for an arm that must alter
> its
>> bearing height significantly to make the cartridge's VTA more
>> accurate, the sonic benefits of a better tracking angle still
> outweigh
>> the downsides from increased torsional irregularities, etc.
>>
>> Is my understanding correct?

他答:
> Hello Bing,
>
> Yes, that is my opinion.
>
> Allen


*******另外,為了避免「洋槍洋砲」的質疑,我還與一位國內的知名唱臂設計者,討論了類似的問題。所得到的回答,會找時間整理出來。


=========================

Hi Bing,

No, you should have no concern about the tonearm angle. No problems with
this design in several models for 25 years.

Allen

> Thank you for clarifying, Allen!
>
> Just to bother you with one more: in your design, if the arm has to be
> raised or lowered significantly away from level position (let's say 3
> degrees) to make the cartridge's VTA acceptable, is there any ill
> effect because of the slanted arm tube, etc.? From "uneven stress" on
> the bearing? Any other issue you can think of?
>
> Bing
>



> -------------------------
>  FROM: "aperkins@immediasound.com" <aperkins@immediasound.com>
> TO: BING-RUNG TSAI
> SENT: Thursday, December 29, 2016 8:10 AM
> SUBJECT: Re: Asking a question for your input

>
> Hello Bing,
>
> Yes, that is my opinion.
>
> Allen
>
>> Just to clarify, you believe that, even for an arm that must alter
> its
>> bearing height significantly to make the cartridge's VTA more
>> accurate, the sonic benefits of a better tracking angle still
> outweigh
>> the downsides from increased torsional irregularities, etc.
>>
>> Is my understanding correct?
>>
>>> On Dec 29, 2016, at 9:51 AM, aperkins@immediasound.com wrote:
>>>
>>> Hello Bing,
>>>
>>> It is my opinion that the having the bearing on the same plane as
> the
>>> stylus causes less torsional forces during playback. That is why my
>
>>> bearing is fixed and the VTA adjustment lifts the arm without
> changing
>>> the bearing height.
>>>
>>> For arms that aren't designed to work that way, you have to change
> the
>>> bearing location to adjust VTA. If you prefer to know your arm is
>>> working "correctly", while your system sounds wrong, its your
> choice.
>>>
>>> I hope that helps. Happy New Year,
>>>
>>> Allen
>>>
>>>
>>>> Allen,
>>>> Thanks again for helping out on the missing bearing of my RPM arm!
>>>> Here I'd like to solicit your input on the following debate I had
>>>> with
>>>> a friend:
>>>> He insists that the arm tube of any arm should be kept level, for
> it
>>>> to function "correctly", even when this means the cartridge
> VTA/SRA
>>>> is
>>>> far out of norm. For most cartridges, this won't be an issue since
> a
>>>> parallel arm tube means the VTA/SRA will be in range. However,
> I've
>>>> encountered several cartridges that, when the arm tube is level,
> the
>>>> VTA/SRA is more than 10 degrees higher than normal. In such cases,
>>>> would you recommend keeping the arm level, or lower the arm base
> for
>>>> a
>>>> correct SRA? If a general answer is impossible, could you comment
>>>> based on your design?
>>>> Thank you in advance for your response!
>>>> Bing
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-19 20:46 , Processed in 0.878265 second(s), 25 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表