忘記密碼
 立即註冊
查看: 19750|回覆: 32

十四種 6DJ8 之 評 鑑 !!

[複製鏈接]

149

主題

2465

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

黃花崗第73烈士

舊站積分
6801
舊站發表文章數
282
發表於 2008-8-10 12:08:19 | 顯示全部樓層 |閱讀模式
Best of 6DJ8  ((  摘錄  ))

There are 14 candidates chosen for the evaluation and they are divided into three groups :

Group 1 (5 types) - All Telefunken
Group 2 (5 types) - All UK made
Group 3 (4 types) - German/US made

Although I have 5 more types of 6DJ8 from Holland include the famous "Bugle Boy", none, in my opinion, can match the performance of the tubes above apart from maybe the square getter "Bugle Boy". But as I only have one such tube, it cannot make the match this time. Another noticeable omission is the Mullard "pinched bottle" 6922 made by Amperex/Philips Holland, which has been described as "Best of the best" by Audiophile. I have been looking for this tube around the world (through the net) for the last 6 months and still without any success. Would welcome if anyone can tell me where to find a pair of these.

The game rule we used is, firstly, to identify the best tube out of each of the three groups. The 3 winner will then be compared against each other to find out which one is the "Best of the best".

Blind testing is performed and all judges have no idea what tube is in which group and what is the order of each. Code name is used for each tube and the model/type is only disclosed after the completion of each group test.

A score sheet is used but it is more as a decision aid. Score is to be given for each tube on 5 categories :

- Treble
- Mid-range
- Bass
- Transience
- Resolution

At the request of the judges, we added another column for "Musicality". A total score is required from each tube but the judges are reminded that the sum of the score does not need to be equal to the sum of scores in the 6 categories. The goal is to identify the best tube in each group and the overall winner.

2 x each type of tubes are used. Most are matched pairs but this is actually not too critical in the testing setup which is as follows :

CD : Sony S7000 + Theta TLC + Adcom GDA 600 + WE93F
Pre-amp : ARC LS-7
Power Amp : 2 x Audion Sterling (in monoblock single EL34 mode)
Speaker : KEF LS3/5a (Piano)

Each pair of tube is used on the input buffer of the Audion Sterling. This is, in my opinion, the most sensitive to tube change compare to used in the pre-amp or as driver.

The Audion Sterling is with Valve Art EL34 and Raytheon square getter 5687 for the group test. Telefunken metal base EL34 were used for final.

There is significant shortcoming of this setup, namely, the lack of bass impact. But I think we still were able to distinguish the bass performance from one tube to the other.

Software used for the test are :

1. Jekyll and Hyde - 1st track
2. David Oistraich - 2nd track
3. Passion of Classics (HDCD version) - 2nd track
4. Cafe Blue - 3rd track



Group 1 - Telefunken

There are 5 types of tube in this group and they are all made by the famous Telefunken with <> marking at bottom :

1. ECC88
2. E88CC (gold pin)
3. E188CC (gold pin)
4. CCa (gold pin)
5. CCa (old type)

Some of you might know that there is also a E288CC from Telefunken. But this is, in fact, not made by Telefunken but Siemens. And it is represented in Group 3.

We are all surprised by the difference in performance with the tubes made by the same firm - Telefunken.

But the result is, in a way, not surprising at all. The most expensive ($1,500 each) of all these tubes, the E188CC won. The runner-up is the old type CCa. The winning margin from the rest of the group is VERY significant. According to some of the judges, it is like changing to a completely different set of hifi with this tube. We very nearly declare this to be the "best of the best" without testing the others.

Group 2 – Tubes from UK

The tubes in Group 2 are all made in UK. They are :

Mullard E88CC (wrinkle glass, "British Made")
Ediswan 6DJ8/CV5358 (a special low-noise 6DJ8 made by Mullard)
Brimar E88CC
GEC CV2492 (blue label)
GEC E88CC (light green label)
This proves to be a "bloody" match as they are much closer in performance. The greatest disappointment is with the wrinkle glass Mullard. This is an expensive tube (about $1,000) and was judged to be the "best of the best 6DJ8" by Audiophile before. But in terms of performance, it comes at the bottom of this group.

Some of you might ask why the Brimar E88CC is included as this tube is not particularly well known and costs only $250. Well, the reason is because this tube is completely identical to the GEC CV2492, which is selling for $1,500 in Hong Kong at present! I am sure no one can tell the difference between the internal and external structure of these two tubes even when looking through a microscope. I am sure the GEC CV2492 was, in fact, made by Brimar. But the result is quite a revelation to me…

The GEC CV2492 came out as the winner of this group where the Brimar was rated as the second worst in the group. This proves that selection is a far more important factor than the construction of the tube itself. And the tube market is actually rather efficient in term of pricing.

Having said that, the GEC 2492 actually beat the GEC E88CC (light green label), which is actually more expensive (around $2,000 each), even though it is only by a very very narrow margin.

Although the GEC 6DJ8 has proved to be one of the best such tube in the world, I would like to warn any person who is looking to buy this tube as there are more than 6 types of GEC 6DJ8/6922 that I have seen and that are all different. The price of them is from $200 to $2000 each. The reason is because GEC has never made a 6DJ8/6922 and was buying from Mullard, Brimar and other tube makers over the years. So they are all different and the performance varies a great deal. If you really want to look for this GEC CV2492 that won the UK group test, you would probably need to buy a Brimar E88CC first and look for a GEC CV2492 with internal structure that look exactly the same.



Group 3 – Germany/USA

3 of the tubes from Group 3 are made by Siemens and the last one is from USA :

Siemens E288CC/8223 (old type)
Siemens E188CC/7308
Siemens CCa (old type)
Amperex 7308 "Q"
I think some of you might know that the E288CC/8223 is the highest spec in the 6DJ8 family. But it proves to be the worst sounding tube in this group. Bear in mind that this is already the old version of the E288CC which cost over $600 each.

The Amperex gave a very good performance and proved to be a best-buy given its price is only around $400. But it still came second after the Siemens CCa, which came out as a clear winner of this group.



BEST OF THE BEST

After over 4 hours of testing, we finally came to the Grand Final – of finding out which one is indeed, the BEST OF THE BEST 6DJ8 in the world.

In order to erase previous memory of which tube is which by the sound, I have change the output tube to the Telefunken metal base EL34, one of the best EL34 ever made, and put the Telefunken E188CC, GEC CV2492 and Siemens CCa to the final test.

Same test is used but we change one of the test track, Passion of Classics-2nd track, to the piano music of Chopin – Naum Starkman – 2nd track..

The final proved to be extremely close and we actually have to retest the first tube again to try to determine the result (by eliminating the disadvantage of testing it when the Telefunken EL34 was at its lowest temperature).

The result was actually so close that the overall winner won by, literally, decimal point over the other two. And we also found out each of the 3 finalist has at least one strength that is better than the other two, and they are :

Telefunken E188CC - Best Transience

GEC CV2492 - Best Dynamics

Siemens CCa - Best Resolution

At the end of the day, we concluded that the Siemens CCa is the overall winner and won the title of "BEST OF THE BEST 6DJ8 IN THE WORLD". It has the highest resolution power of all of the 14 tubes and also the best total score when everything is counted.

But before you rush out to the nearest tube shop and buy every Siemens CCa in sight. Another word of warning :

The overall winner is the "early type" of Siemens CCa. The later production types are much worse and nowhere near any of the 14 tubes tested here. The early type of CCa has a slightly different structure compare to the later types. If you look at the plates between the two plate insulators, make sure every plate is grey with NO shiny metal plate on the two sides support the upper structure. The box should be in yellow/blue color instead of white/orange/blue or orange/blue. The price varies by a huge amount. I bought a pair with no box for $300 each but another NIB I saw in another shop is selling for $1,600 each.

譯文後補[/COLOR]

149

主題

2465

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

黃花崗第73烈士

舊站積分
6801
舊站發表文章數
282
 樓主| 發表於 2008-8-10 13:14:06 | 顯示全部樓層

十四種 6DJ8 之 評 鑑 譯文 !!

最好6DJ8

有14 名候選人被選擇為評估並且他們被劃分成三個小組:

小組1 (5 型) - 所有Telefunken
小組2 (5 型) - 所有英國做了
小組3 (4 型) - German/US 做了

雖然我安排5 另外類型6DJ8 從荷蘭包括著名"軍號男孩", 無, 以我所見, 能匹配管的表現上面除可能方形的吸瓦斯劑"軍號男孩之外" 。但是當我只有一支這樣的管, 它無法做比賽這時候。其它引人注目的遺漏是Mullard "捏的瓶" 6922 做了由Amperex/Philips 荷蘭, 被描述了作為"最好最佳" 由Audiophile 。我尋找這支管在世界(通過網) 為前6 個月和仍然沒有任一成功。會歡迎如果任何人可能告訴我在哪裡發現這些的一對。

我們過去常的遊戲規則是, 首先, 辨認最佳的管在每個三個小組外面。3 你是"最好最佳" 。的優勝者然後與比較互相反對發現

盲目測試進行並且所有法官沒有想法什麼管是在哪個小組和什麼是每個的命令。代號被使用為各支管並且model/type 只被透露在各個小組測試的完成以後。

比分板料被使用但它是更多作為決定援助。比分將被給為各支管在5 個類別:

- 高音
- 中等長度範圍
- 低音
- 瞬間
- 決議

應法官請求, 我們增加了其它專欄為"Musicality" 。一個總比分必需從各支管但比分的總和不需要是相等的與比分的總和在6 個類別的法官被提醒。目標是辨認最佳的管在各個小組和整體優勝者。

2 x 各類型管被使用。多數是被匹配的對但這實際上不是太重要的在是的測試的設定如下:

CD: 索尼S7000 + 希臘字母的第八字TLC + Adcom GDA 600 + WE93F
前置放大器: 弧LS-7
力量安培: 2 x 三極管英鎊(在monoblock 唯一EL34 方式下)
報告人: KEF LS3/5.a (鋼琴)

各對管被使用在三極管英鎊的輸入緩衝區。這對管變動是, 以我所見, 最敏感的與使用比較在前置放大器或作為司機。

三極管英鎊是與閥門藝術EL34 和Raytheon 方形的吸瓦斯劑5687 為小組測試。Telefunken 金屬基地EL34 被使用了為決賽。

有這個設定, 即, 缺乏重大缺點低音衝擊。但我認為我們仍然能與一支管區別低音表現對其他。

軟體被使用為測試是:

1. Jekyll 和海德- 第1 條軌道
2. 大衛Oistraich - 第2 條軌道
3. 經典之作(HDCD 版本) 激情- 第2 條軌道
4. 咖啡館藍色- 第3 條軌道



小組1 - Telefunken

有5 類型管在這個小組並且他們是全部做了由著名Telefunken 以< > 標記在底層:

1. ECC88
2. E88CC (金別針)
3. E188CC (金別針)
4. CCa (金別針)
5. CCa (老型)

你們也許知道, 有並且E288CC 從Telefunken 。但這由Telefunken 而是西門子, 實際上, 不做。並且它代表在小組3 。

我們全部由在表現上的區別驚奇與管由同樣企業- Telefunken 做。

但結果是, 在某一方面, 不驚奇根本。最昂貴($1,500 每) 所有這些管, E188CC 贏取了。亞軍是老型CCa 。贏取的邊際從小組的剩餘是非常重大的。根據一些法官, 它是像變成完全地另外套hifi 與這支管。我們非常宣稱這是"最好最佳" 沒有測試其他。

小組2 - 管從英國

管在小組2 是全部做了在英國。他們是:

Mullard E88CC (皺痕玻璃, "英國被製作")
Ediswan 6DJ8/CV5358 (特別低噪聲6DJ8 由Mullard 做)
Brimar E88CC
GEC CV2492 (藍色標籤)
GEC E88CC (淺綠色的標籤)
這被證明是"血淋淋的" 比賽因為他們是接近的在表現。最巨大的失望是與皺痕玻璃Mullard 。這是一支昂貴的管(大約$1,000) 並且由Audiophile 判斷是"最好最佳的6DJ8" 以前。但根據表現, 它來在這個小組底部。

你們也許問為什麼Brimar E88CC 包括因為這支管不是特別知名的和不花費只$250 。很好, 原因是因為這支管與GEC 是完全地相同的CV2492, 當前賣為$1,500 在香港! 我是肯定的沒人能告訴區別在這兩支管之間內部和外在結構既使當看通過顯微鏡。我是肯定的GEC CV2492 由Brimar, 實際上, 做了。但結果是相當揭示對我...

GEC CV2492 出來了作為Brimar 對估計作為第二壞在小組這個小組的優勝者。這證明, 選擇比管的建築是一個更加重要的因素。並且管市場實際上是相當高效率的用定價的期限。

實際上說那, GEC 2492 敲打GEC E88CC (淺綠色的標籤), 實際上是更加昂貴的(大約$2,000 每), 即使它是只由非常非常窄邊。

雖然GEC 6DJ8 被證明是一個最佳這樣的管在世界上, 我希望警告看買這支管的任何人儘管有超過我看見了並且是所有不同的6 類型GEC 6DJ8/6922 。價格的他們是從$200 到$2000 每。原因是因為GEC 從未做了6DJ8/6922 並且多年來是購買從Mullard 、Brimar 和其它管製作商。如此他們是所有不同的並且表現非常變化。如果您真正地想要尋找贏取英國小組測試的這GEC CV2492, 您大概會需要首先買Brimar E88CC 和尋找GEC 確切地看同樣的CV2492 以內部結構。



小組3 - Germany/USA

3 管從小組3 由西門子做並且最後你來自美國:

西門子E288CC/8223 (老型)
西門子E188CC/7308
西門子CCa (老型)
Amperex 7308 "Q"
我認為你們也許知道E288CC/8223 是最高的spec 在6DJ8 家庭。但它被證明是最壞的聽起來管在這個小組。記住, 這已經是花費$600 每E288CC 的老版本。

Amperex 給了非常好表現並且被證明是佳買給它的價格是只大約$400 。但它其次仍然來了在西門子以後CCa, 出來作為這個小組的一個清楚的優勝者。



最好最佳

以後4 個小時測試, 我們最後來了到盛大決賽- 發現在哪些之外你的確是, 最佳最佳的6DJ8 在世界上。

為了刪掉管是的早先記憶哪些由聲音, 我把變動產品管對Telefunken 金屬基地EL34, 最佳的EL34 的當中一個曾經被做, 和投入了Telefunken E188CC 、GEC CV2492 和西門子CCa 對最後的測試。

同樣測試被使用但我們改變一測試軌道, 經典之作2 nd 軌道激情 , 到蕭邦- Naum Starkman 鋼琴音樂- 2nd 軌道。

決賽證明極端接近的並且我們必須再實際上再實驗第一管設法確定結果(由消滅不利測試它當Telefunken EL34 是在它的低溫) 。

結果, 逐字地, 實際上是很接近, 整體優勝者贏取了小數點其它二。並且我們並且發現了每個3 決賽選手有至少一力量比其它二好, 並且他們是:

Telefunken E188CC - 最佳的瞬間

GEC CV2492 - 最佳的動力學

西門子CCa - 最佳的決議

當晚, 我們認為, 西門子CCa 是整體優勝者並且獲得了稱號的"最好的最佳的6DJ8 在世界上" 。它有所有的最高的決議力量14 支管和並且最佳的總比分當一切評分計數。

但在您之前衝對最近的管商店和買每西門子CCa 在視線內。其它警告的詞:

整體優勝者是"早期類型" 西門子CCa 。最新生產類型更壞和無處在任何14 支管附近被測試這裡。早期類型CCa 安排一個輕微地另外結構與最新型比較。如果您看板材在二板材insulators 之間, 確定每塊板材是灰色的沒有發光的金屬板材在雙方支持上部結構。箱子應該是在yellow/blue 顏色代替white/orange/blue 或orange/blue 。價格變化由巨大的數額。我每買了對沒有箱子為$300 但我看見在其它商店的其它鳥嘴賣為$1,600 每。

195

主題

1萬

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3607
舊站發表文章數
4416
發表於 2008-8-10 17:19:45 | 顯示全部樓層
給您拍手並加分![]
Yamaha A-2000a + Yamaha NS-1000M + (Sony TA-E88/Denon POA-4400) CDP + DAT(當成D/A), Micro Seiki DD-5

93

主題

541

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

一星級會員

舊站積分
63
舊站發表文章數
81
發表於 2008-8-10 17:57:54 | 顯示全部樓層
譯文由翻譯軟體直翻,看起來很奇怪!

149

主題

2465

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

黃花崗第73烈士

舊站積分
6801
舊站發表文章數
282
 樓主| 發表於 2008-8-10 22:01:59 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 jackpoun
[B]給您拍手並加分![] [/B]


感恩您ㄉ加分   其實偶ㄝ考慮好一陣子   只怕此文一經披露    國內店家師出有名

開始提高售價     何況躉物皆高居不下狀況下     難免膽管一族受到波及   國外大

公司ㄉ賣價    Seimens  CCA  已漲到   NTD $12000 一對  NIB   偶還回函說

牠賣20對   就能等同買一部  TOYOTA    放不下膽管    沉迷飽滿   柔順膽機朋友

伸頭一刀    將來縮頭也一刀    難逃ㄉ劫數    趁早存各種戰備存糧   以作為因應之道

因為ㄝ無跌價顧慮   當作膽管基金作定存      萬一哪天棄保潛逃音響樂友    好歹

也還有一些逃亡費用   作為支應   []

更可怕ㄉ是  ~   ~   一但熱炒之餘    不肖人等     馬上下單翻版複製    尤其當

今   所賣 NIBㄉ紙盒   像剛出爐ㄉ麵包    周邊新折盒子    無受潮ㄉ蓬鬆   凹陷痕

跡   +   管身印刷    字體 都清晰ㄉ不得了    想想  30  40年前ㄉ古物    完美無暇

疵     拼老命去認定那紙盒    還要多花費  3000  ~ 4000元ㄉ代價    偶只能

說  :  這人一定是膽管連同紙盒    一起上機聽ㄉ              []

樹大招風ㄉ TELEFUNKAN  CCa   假貨尤其多    反不如膽管真正第一大廠  

西門子    也別再被誤導   TFK  是王者之說詞     每個人器材ㄝ不一    多一項選擇

同時擁有  趙飛燕    西施   陳圓圓    意淫一下   總不為過ㄉ  [}]

149

主題

2465

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

黃花崗第73烈士

舊站積分
6801
舊站發表文章數
282
 樓主| 發表於 2008-8-10 22:04:01 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 jackpoun
[B]給您拍手並加分![] [/B]


感恩您ㄉ加分   其實偶ㄝ考慮好一陣子   只怕此文一經披露    國內店家師出有名

開始提高售價     何況躉物皆高居不下狀況下     難免膽管一族受到波及   國外大

公司ㄉ賣價    Seimens  CCA  已漲到   NTD $12000 一對  NIB   偶還回函說

牠賣20對   就能等同買一部  TOYOTA    放不下膽管    沉迷飽滿   柔順膽機朋友

伸頭一刀    將來縮頭也一刀    難逃ㄉ劫數    趁早存各種戰備存糧   以作為因應之道

因為ㄝ無跌價顧慮   當作膽管基金作定存      萬一哪天棄保潛逃音響樂友    好歹

也還有一些逃亡費用   作為支應   []

更可怕ㄉ是  ~   ~   一但熱炒之餘    不肖人等     馬上下單翻版複製    尤其當

今   所賣 NIBㄉ紙盒   像剛出爐ㄉ麵包    周邊新折盒子    無受潮ㄉ蓬鬆   凹陷痕

跡   +   管身印刷    字體 都清晰ㄉ不得了    想想  30  40年前ㄉ古物    完美無暇

疵 呈現展示    拼老命去認定那紙盒    還要多花費  3000  ~ 4000元ㄉ代價    偶

只能說  :  這人一定是膽管連同紙盒    一起上機聽ㄉ              []

樹大招風ㄉ TELEFUNKAN  CCa   假貨尤其多    反不如膽管真正第一大廠  

西門子    也別再被誤導   TFK  是王者之說詞     每個人器材ㄝ不一    多一項選擇

同時擁有  趙飛燕    西施   陳圓圓    意淫一下   總不為過ㄉ  [}]

195

主題

1萬

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

五星級會員

舊站積分
3607
舊站發表文章數
4416
發表於 2008-8-10 22:12:27 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 max17914
[B]

感恩您ㄉ加分   其實偶ㄝ考慮好一陣子   只怕此文一經披露    國內店家師出有名

開始提高售價     何況躉物皆高居不下狀況下     難免膽管一族受到波及   國外大

公司ㄉ賣價    Seimens  CCA  已漲到   NTD $12000 一對  NIB   偶還回函說

牠賣20對   就能等同買一部  TOYOTA    放不下膽管    沉迷飽滿   柔順膽機朋友

伸頭一刀    將來縮頭也一刀    難逃ㄉ劫數    趁早存各種戰備存糧   以作為因應之道

因為ㄝ無跌價顧慮   當作膽管基金作定存      萬一哪天棄保潛逃音響樂友    好歹

也還有一些逃亡費用   作為支應   []

更可怕ㄉ是  ~   ~   一但熱炒之餘    不肖人等     馬上下單翻版複製    尤其當

今   所賣 NIBㄉ紙盒   像剛出爐ㄉ麵包    周邊新折盒子    無受潮ㄉ蓬鬆   凹陷痕

跡   +   管身印刷    字體 都清晰ㄉ不得了    想想  30  40年前ㄉ古物    完美無暇

疵 呈現展示    拼老命去認定那紙盒    還要多花費  3000  ~ 4000元ㄉ代價    偶

只能說  :  這人一定是膽管連同紙盒    一起上機聽ㄉ              []

樹大招風ㄉ TELEFUNKAN  CCa   假貨尤其多    反不如膽管真正第一大廠  

西門子    也別再被誤導   TFK  是王者之說詞     每個人器材ㄝ不一    多一項選擇

同時擁有  趙飛燕    西施   陳圓圓    意淫一下   總不為過ㄉ  [}] [/B]


有參考價值的文章(尤其是技術性的), 總也免不了各種帶有色彩的批評, 批判, 更
何況如果遷涉到了商業利益, 錢的問題!

給您加分, 是因為您的貼文參考價值很高! 其他的, 商業方面的, 就各憑各自的認
知和本事吧![}] [}]
Yamaha A-2000a + Yamaha NS-1000M + (Sony TA-E88/Denon POA-4400) CDP + DAT(當成D/A), Micro Seiki DD-5

149

主題

2465

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

黃花崗第73烈士

舊站積分
6801
舊站發表文章數
282
 樓主| 發表於 2008-8-10 23:27:32 | 顯示全部樓層
原發表者是 chejjs
[B]譯文由翻譯軟體直翻,看起來很奇怪! [/B]


原本想做一番修飾   一則  自己太懶   ....  二則考量到原汁原味    萬一"國文造紙"
太差    辭不達意    或是竄改某一段落    在那ㄇ長篇ㄉ文字下    沒人會作逐字校稿
逐段比對    萬一有利益輸送    也是不好  (  瓜棚之嫌  ) []  所以派用翻譯軟體
也達到節能省碳之效

看原文吃力    看譯文稍微排列組合一下   比臆測原文要省事多   看ㄉ也快   前後ㄝ能融會貫通    有如吃麵食方便     入口ㄝ能吞嚥   更何況來此人士   都馬有三兩三人物    等閑之輩    竄來此地ㄉ機會    少之又少滴  .....

因此大哥您就多擔代囉  []

33

主題

173

回帖

0

積分

新手上路

一星級會員

舊站積分
0
舊站發表文章數
95
發表於 2008-8-11 08:40:02 | 顯示全部樓層
感恩您
感恩您感恩您

49

主題

478

回帖

200

積分

新手上路

真空管級會員

舊站積分
15
舊站發表文章數
271
發表於 2008-8-11 10:40:33 | 顯示全部樓層
他還有很多沒聽過耶
例如A frame的siemens......A frame, D getter的Valvo
還有法國製的philips E188CC....Mullard 10M的6fj8....哈哈!一堆講不完
那篇文章的時空和現在有點遠....GEC CV2492長的像Brimar CV2492
我從來沒看過.....那時候或許很多.... [:O]
您需要登錄後才可以回帖 登錄 | 立即註冊

本版積分規則

Archiver|MyAV視聽商情網 test

GMT+8, 2026-11-19 20:45 , Processed in 0.125110 second(s), 42 queries .

Powered by MyAV!

快速回覆 返回頂部 返回列表